Software
Houzz Logo Print
vacuumfreak

sibling rivalry, whats going on?

19 years ago

I'm really not sure what to do here. For those of you who don't know, I have an orange tabby that I've had for almost a year now and he is about a year and 6 months old. His name is Jasper. He was a shelter cat and I got him as a companion for my first apartment. Well, I had been considering getting a second cat for myself and as a companion for him when I am at work or spending the night with a guy (maybe once every other week, one night at at time). A few (3 maybe) weeks ago I STOLE a homeless cat from the street. I broke into the open sidewalk with a crowbar and robbed this cat who was obviously owned by the street lamps and mailboxes with no intention of ever returning him to those owners. He was skinny, not neutered, and had an old flea collar on that I had to cut off. I put up posters, put an add on Craigs List, called Jasper's vet and when I got him neutered and vaccinated last Monday made a found animal report with animal services. No one has called to claim the cat yet, and I'm not sure what to do with him. I thought he and Jasper would just become best friends and play together and sleep together and frolic in sunshiney meadows of feline friendship bliss. Well... IT'S NOT HAPPENING! I kept them separated until I had the new guy 'taken care of' medically, so that should have given them time to get used to each others' scent. New guy (Jayden) wants to play with Jasper, but Jasper has no part of it. I've NEVER heard Jasper growl until Jayden came into our lives and home. Jasper started to think it was not only OK to growl at Jayden but also at me (I corrected his understanding on that though, he's back to just at Jayden). Jayden meows and creeps toward Jasper, Jasper emits a low growl and then they are fighting like alley cats. I have to keep them separate when I am at work and during the night (only if I want to sleep). I have been very careful to give Jasper food, treats, and attention first since he was with me first and he is older. I'm starting to like Jayden more than Jasper (Note: like his "personality", not love his soul)! He sleeps on me in bed and on me if I am watching TV, and wants to be in my lap if I am online. He is calm and delicate and graceful. The only problem is that he's pretty vocal and I can't stand a loud cat (or a loud anything!). He doesn't purr very much, and when he does it's when he's on my lap and very softly. He doesn't really play... he's not boisterous like Jasper. Jasper used to sleep at the foot of the bed or sit on the sofa beside me, he's never been an "in your face" kind of cat (but I want an "in your face" kind of cat). He did purr loudly and a lot though. Now he keeps his distance and really doesn't purr. He even refused his favorite treat yesterday! The only thing I like better about Jasper's "personality" is that he was a quiet (not vocal) cat and that he purred a lot. The only thing I don't like about Jayden is that Jasper is upset and that he is too vocal. Of course he sprayed before he was neutered, I almost had a heart attack the first time I caught him in the act... from my reaction I thought he was going to as well. Haven't caught him doing that since the operation. How long should I give them to get to know each other before I take Jayden to the shelter to let someone else adopt him? Also, if someone does call for Jayden I'd hate for them to call me and the cat be at some shelter.... Maybe Jasper just wants to be an only cat. Maybe Jaydens "personality" clashes with Jasper's and his companion needs to be a different kind of cat. If you have any ideas on how to help them get along, please let me know! I don't know if Jayden is going to be temporary or permanent but either way we are all going to have to learn to coexist peacefully. Thanks for any advice!

Comments (31)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    How long have you had Jayden? I got a little female calico kitten about 2 months ago and already had a female siamese who has a bad attitude. Well at first my siamese (Feeona) would walk up to my calico (Izzy) and slap her in the face/ bite her tail. Well it's been a while since I've had Izzy, and Feeona and her still dont get along, but they do deal with eachother. I have even caught them playing together, but as soon as Feeona sees that I have seen her being nice to Izzy she growls at Izzy and runs off. I think that over time your cats will just learn to deal with eachother. It may take a long while, but I'm sure eventually they will become friends.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Did you really steal Jayden using a crow bar or is your original post at http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/pets/msg050140517287.html true?

    Leave the cats alone and love them equally. Which also means stop seperating them. If they are going to live together they have to decide on their own, who the leader of the pack is. The same happens with Dogs, or if you put a new fish in your aquarium.

    Right now, all poor Jasper knows is that he had all of your love after you saved him from the shelter. All of a sudden there is a new kid in the house taking Mommies attention away, eating from his bowls and playing with his toys.

    From what you said here about how you like Jayden more than Jasper... Don't you think Jasper feels that? To him Jayden is an intruder taking his Mommy away from him. You need to be an equal opportunity Mommy, dont seperate them anymore and they will work it out. One will establish the dominant roll then you go from there.

    Just like people some animals never get along but you won't know that until you give them a chance.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The crowbar statement is sarcasm because I was accused of stealing him. It was a joke, not to be taken literally. I'm sure SOMEONE will appreciate the humor in that :o) I do "like" Jayden more, but I "love" Jasper more... we have a history and a relationship. I try not to separate them but I can't stand the fighting sometimes... I do need to sleep! When I'm home and awake they are together full time. I really want them to love each other and be friends... hope it develops!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I hope they develope a friendship too. With cats you don't know what will happen. I would give it a bit of time, Jayden hasn't been fixed for that long and he may be too male for Jasper still. Jaden may not know what he wants in life yet. Jasper knows what he wants, he may be afraid of looseing some of it. I'm sending all three of you the blessings that are mine to give.
    Joann

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Try not to worry. It takes a few weeks for a cat to adjust to a newcomer. There's bound to be hissing, growling and tussling until they establish a pecking order.

    I keep a new cat shut in the bathroom the first week with its own litter box, food and water. That gives the original cat a little time to get used to the idea.

    I am told that after a cat is neutered it still has some of the hormones circulating in its body for awhile. Jaden should settle down soon.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It sounds as if they just started mingling together recently? Since you said you had to take care of Jayden medically first? I wouldn't rush it. We were lucky with our cats in that within a week we were able to leave them alone together. But, sometimes it can take a few weeks. I would give it time and they are likely to be best friends. Let them mingle in small doses first. As for fighting, some is probably OK/normal - as long as they aren't really hurting each other. Just take it slow.

    You know - my vet clinic actually has kitten socializing classes. I wonder if other vets do too?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've integrated a lot of cats over the years, and it just takes time. The new cat gets his or her own room with litter box and meals in there. In the evening, new cat comes out under supervision. Gradually increase the time 'out' from 10 minutes to 15 to half an hour. It can take months for cats to accept that they are sharing a territory. But in six months, you'll come home from work and find them curled up together snoozing or grooming. Just give them time and keep them separated when you're not there to supervise for the first few months. It will work out. The dramatics are completely normal.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I hope they settle soon... They got into it twice tonight and Jasper ran up on the kitchen counter and HID BEHIND THE MICROWAVE..... twice! They are forbidden to go on the counter and Jasper never does but it was like he was possessed! He wouldn't listen and I didn't want to spray the microwave with the squirt bottle and cause an electrocution... this has got to end!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Follow Cynthia's advice. That's how I always handled it and mostly successfully. Only one cat, Izzy, who I fostered for over two years, never adjusted. She went back to the rescue group and is happy as a single cat with a young couple. But all the rest, and there have been 15 in the last decades have mellowed and get along. My one little tortie is pissy with everyone but doesn't fight. Just doesn't like anyone. She has a history..was found wandering the streets of the city when she was 2 weeks old. No socialization w/ her mother and sibs..so she's a little wacked. Give it time. They should work it out..

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You need to give them more time. Are you home all day? I was and it drove me crazy every cat/kitten we added. They make friends in their own time not ours!

    Someone always became a resident queen for about a month. Hissing, spitting and I am not talking about at the new addition, I am talking about at us as well.

    After the first couple of weeks I used a baby gate to cordon off a spot where the new addition could get easily get away to escape harassment, yet could come out and explore in safety. I used two litter boxes until everyone was happy again.

    I have 2 large dogs as well. It always works out.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Heed Cynthia's advice. Keep them separate for a longer period of time. Cats are not pack animals like dogs, and do not establish group hierarchy. They are territorial, though, and they need their space.

    Listen to Cynthia and be patient. It took me a few months to integrate one cat into two, and we were patient, and it was worth the wait!

    Do not let the hammer it out themselves. They will need supervision.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Agree with it all above. Don't rush it. Sounds like maybe too much time together at once? Small doses and get longer as they get used to each other.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I thought the crowbar statement was VERY funny!

    We have always had good luck with our cats whenever we've added a new one - no special separations once they were tested. We have one cat who hates all the others, but she doesn't fight with them - just hisses and does her own thing.

    But since you are having problems, I would probably do as suggested above - keep them separated more and gradually increase their time together. I know it will be a pain, but hopefully in the end you will all be happy boys.

    Sher

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Sher... I thought it was pretty funny myself. Also funny to note that the people who thought I was stealing the cat didn't bother to respond... I guess they will never answer a post of mine again! I woke up today and found the floor lamp on the floor so they must have gotten into it! I guess that's why they call it a floor lamp; thank goodness the globe wasn't broken! I didn't even hear them last night so I must have slept great. Yesterday I was off and home all day... I left all the doors open and JASPER hid in the bedroom closet and refused to come out. Jayden followed me all around all day long and if I was sitting he was on my lap. I love it! Just wish Jasper would come around!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Poor Jasper he may think he is being replaced, and got his wiskers in a twist. He loves you and I'm sure he will come around. My cats aren't allowed on the counters and I never see them there but when the person is away the cats will buggie woggie all over so I bleach my counters before using them. LOL

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My daughter had a adult male cat named Sam. He was a lovey and then she adopted another large male cat she named Sid. Sid immediately took over the house and Sam hid under the bed basically for six months. I watched them when they went on vacation and got them together in the same room talking to both and petting both...In a few weeks , all was well and Sid is still in charge but they exist peacefully together with no fighting.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It sounds to me like one of the problems is you. You sound like you are giving way too much time to the new kitty. Jasper was there first, let him know it.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    minibim, I shan't insult you by telling you to wipe the fog from your glasses, but I will subtly suggest that you go back and read the original poster's original post. In there he (I) said that he (I) gives Jasper food, treats, and attention first. It's not my fault that Jasper wants to be a PUNK and hide in the closet all day. I left all the doors open and he woundn't come out. I tried to pick him up and he hissed at me and jumped out of my arms. I'm just going to let him wallow in misery until he comes around. I'm not removing my love from him and giving it to someone else... I am adding room in my heart for one more! And doing it for him so he doesn't get lonely when he's home alone... though right now I think he'd RATHER be lonely!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sorry Vacuumfreak, I won't waste your time OR MY TIME BOTHERING to respond to your posts anymore.

    Perhaps though if you actually learned to make paragraphs instead of novels, your posts would be easier to read.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I wasn't aware that this was a formal writing class. I think I do well to spell words correctly and and use correct grammar. I am not perfrect, but I proofread every post I make at least three times before pressing submit. Except for the rare occasion I am in a terrible hurry. Very often I am typing from a PDA instead of a "real" computer because I am on the go so much. You needn't get your feathers ruffled because you told me to do something that I was already doing. I will agree with you though. If you tell me to do something that I am already doing, it does seem a bit wasteful! Good day to you.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Vacuumfreak, are you going to take any of the advice offered here? Experienced multi cat households have suggested separate the two and gradual integration of the new cat. But you are blaming your first cat for being fearful (that's normal!) and are applying human emotions to his fear:

    "It's not my fault that Jasper wants to be a PUNK and hide in the closet all day. I left all the doors open and he woundn't come out. I tried to pick him up and he hissed at me and jumped out of my arms. I'm just going to let him wallow in misery until he comes around."

    Please think about this and consider giving the new cat his own room so that both can relax and gradually learn to live together. Your cat is frightened, and your being terribly unkind to him.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Amen to what Cynthia said. minibim, too.

    Jasper's a frightened confused cat. NOT a punk. From all I've read, it seems that you're more concerned about your wants and needs than about Jasper's.

    I think it's great that you took in 2 homeless cats, but, cut them some slack. Stop anthropomorphizing them. Animals aren't spiteful or malicious.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Bobby, at this very moment, Simba is hiding in the closet bcoz Pumpkin is out of her room. He hisses and growls at her but never gets into a fight even if she goes to rub her face against his. Of course he doesn't allow that, just runs away. He also hisses at Max and Nikita when in this mood.

    I think it'll be some time before Jasper realises Jayden doesn't mean any harm. It could take weeks, even months.

    We have been lucky up until now, never had problems with integrating new kittens into the household. With Simba I'm about to learn to be patient anew.

    Good luck, and keep us posted.

    Pranjal

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    RocKat and Sam were best of friends for two years and now they don't even want to be in the same room. It has been one kitty in and one kitty out with them. If Jayden forced Jasper behind the microwave, in a place he doesn't go and you sprayed him for going there, he would feel that you are takeing the "other" cats side. It is hard to leave them to their own social life because they can be so mean to each other.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree with cynthia and bbaird. From reading your posts it does not sound like you have listened to the advice offered here. You need to introduce them gradually - it may take a long time. They really shouldn't be together for more than a short time at first. An hour, or even less, may be all they can tolerate for a while. Cats are not humans and what you are describing is normal behavior. Good luck, though. But please don't rush them or get mad when they act normal. It takes love and patience!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well... they seem fine now. Better at least. They aren't fighting anymore, but they aren't really interacting either. I got lots of advice here, but some of it was contradicting. In the end I just decided to let them experience each other when I was home to supervise and separate them when I wasn't. There is no more aggression, growling, or fighting. Jasper is even purring again! Of course they aren't sleeping together or grooming each other, and they may never, but at least they aren't trying to kill each other!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    VF - I'm late to the conversation...I was at home depot...
    first - thanks for stealing Jayden from those irresponsible streetlamps (whatever made them think they could raise an animate being is beyond me)
    As far as the two getting along, it may never happen, or it may ... it is up to them to decide. I am glad to hear that there is no apparent bloodshed these days.
    DW and I have two brothers who will just as often try to kill each other as lay in the bed head to head, belly to belly, with paws intertwined.
    Cats have a language all their own.
    J and J will work it out one way or t'other eventually. Just keep doing what you're doing and love 'em up equally (or as much as they allow) puuuurrrrrrrrrrrrr!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Great - wonderful update. Yep - good to keep them apart when you aren't at home. Didn't realize you had them together all day. They may eventually be good friends. Who knows.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hmmm.. I certainly don't have great advice to give here, but I will tell you what happened with me.

    I had my first cat for 7 years (she had moved cross country, and a few different apartments with me) and she was my one and only. Until one day at work in a barn I heard a little pathetic "mew-ing" coming from a dark corner. I searched real hard (the barn had no lights, only natural daylight coming in through the door, and the cat was black and about 2-3 lbs) until I found her. Against the advice of my boss (who owned the barn) I went inside and got some food and some milk to give to the starving kitty. I kept this up for about 2 weeks, and during this time my bf (the boss's son) started to like the kitty as well and asked if we could take her home with us. I knew my one and only cat would certainly not appreciate it, but my heartstrings got the better of me (the area was well known for kitty road kill) and I agreed to bring her home.

    Once there my precious cat, who up until now had been queen of the castle, displayed her nasty side and I have never seen so much hissing coming from what I though was the gentlest cat in the world. I was the young PUNK then because I knew nothing about socializing cats and how to introduce them to one another. I just plunked Kitty down in the same room as Jelika and watched what happened. Lots of growling/hissing/swatting and who knew what happened when I wasn't home (working on a farm is no 8 hour a day job.. I/we were gone a minimum of 12 hours a day, 7 days a week). But when I got home they both seemed to be in one piece still and eventually... eventually the hissing/growling/swatting subsided.

    This was 12 years ago and up until sweet Jelika passed away in April, they still occaisionally swatted at one another, but more often than not I would find them curled up together on the bed. Jelika would always sleep by my side, in the crook of my arm and Kitty would sleep by my feet (if on the bed at all). Kitty always wanted to be where Jelika was. Even though I had 2 exact same cat beds in front of the fireplace Kitty would always wait until Jelika left hers and then promptly jumped into that one. And even to this day, with Jelika being gone, Kitty still waits whenever I fill up the food dish, I presume to see if Jelika will want to eat first. She waits until I tell her it is ok to eat, because Jelika isn't coming back.

    Even at the end though, I think Jelika wanted to prove to Kitty her "ownership and first cat status" over Kitty, because most times when Kitty would sit on my lap, and Jelika got wind of it, no matter where she was or what she was doing she would drop anything and come over and jump up HIGHER on my lap (she would usually end up on my chest somewhere, because one lap is crowded with 2 cats) effectively hogging all the attention/petting and cutting Kitty off. It was kind of funny and I never knew that a cat could give an "evil eye" until I saw Jelika looking at me whenever I would give Kitty a petting. She would always come over and assume that since I had 2 hands, I should be using the free one to pet HER. I certainly don't NEED 2 hands to pet Kitty!

    I guess I'm telling you all this because I don't think it really matters what you do or how long you separate them or leave them together. The first little while will be a little rough, but eventually they will learn to like each other, and find comfort in each other. I guess I've never done anything "properly" or to exacting standards when it came to my cats, but as long as there is enough love to go around, it will always work out in the end.

    Good luck, and please don't send Jayden away to a shelter where he may end up in a home that is not even half as loving as yours.

    Mokanee

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm glad to hear the fighting has stopped and sweet Jasper is purring, and Jayden is still with you. I always thought they would be fine. They will work it out, good for you to give them the chance.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That is wonderful to hear, Bobby! :)

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio