Software
Houzz Logo Print
hawkgt_gw

Back splash: tile or tile over granite?

16 years ago

I am building a new house and the granite is being cut for installation this coming week. I mentioned to my contractor that I would the back splash to be all tile. He asked i was sure that is what I wanted because he usually has his granite sub cut a small piece of granite which installed and then tile can be used above that. The cabinet/counter top sub also made the same comment to me adding that it allows them to make a good tight seal between the vertical and horizontal. Aesthetically speaking I want a consistent look of only one material on the back splash. I would use a caulk that matches my grout to seal where the tile meets the horizontal granite counter top. I am thinking tile over a granite backsplash will look like an afterthought instead of a cohesive design. Am I missing something and not understanding why tile over a counter top can't be sealed or would be unsanitary?

I am thinking about using a 2x2 or 2x4 Noche tumbled marble for the back splash. The counter tops are Tropical Brown granite on top of Cherry cabinets with a Cabernet stain. Thoughts and or advice?

Here is a link that might be useful: Blog with pics of progress

Comments (7)

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with you. The counter fabricators are very used to doing the standard 4" slab backsplash because many people, by the time they get done with the expense of installing granite, don't have a budget for a full tile backsplash. Stick to one plain of material on the wall. Otherwise it looks like you ran out of money and then went back later to put it in.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Our bungalow remodel blog

  • 16 years ago

    I'm a little concerned that your countertop sub (is he a fabricator?) is talking about making a tight seal between vertical and horizontal. With modern fabrication, say over the last 20 years, there has not been a problem with that, the way there used to be years ago when counters were formica and fabrication methods were less refined and precise. And the "sanitary" comment is out of left field--did your contractor say that? In any case, I will list the reasons why I do not like a small strip of granite (usually 4") on the backsplash:

    - you will spend a lot of effort designing a beautiful tile backsplash; why cut it short by 4".

    - the additional horizontal line of the 4" strip will visually make the space between your counter and upper cabinets look smaller and more cramped

    - some people think the 4" backsplash looks dated, though opinions vary on this

    - the 4" backsplash creates a small "ledge" which collects dust. Yet one more thing to clean.

    - you will be charged for the material and installation for the 4" backsplash; money that you may have preferred to spend elsewhere.

    I think that a 4" backpslash would be good if you were NOT installing tile and just had drywall on the rest of the wall. Or, if you simply like the look, as a lot of people do. Get what YOU want, not what makes life easier for your contractor.

    BTW, who is installing your tile backsplash? You may want to find someone outside of your contractor's subs. I was recommended someone by the tile store where I bought my tile. He specialized in tile--all he did is tile, and had been doing that for many years, so he really knew what he was doing. I am only mentioning this because of my concern that your contractor is saying he needs the granite strip to "make a tight seal". How elaborate will be your tile backsplash? If it's just, e.g., plain subway tile, that's pretty easy. But with a more complex pattern, tile backsplashes can be exacting work, and if your contractor isn't so painstaking, you will have to live with a backsplash that may not look so great (we've seen that happen on this forum several times).

  • 16 years ago

    Tell them that you do NOT want the 4" strip. Buy the backsplash tile and ask them to install it.
    The 4" is a remnant from the days of prefab laminate counters. You dont need it for custom made counters.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm sorry, but I have to take issue with all those saying you HAVE to take it, or you HAVE to remove it. Mechanically speaking, there's no real difference either way. If there's no backsplash initially, so long as the countertop is caulked into the wall, there's no problem with leakage, etc.. Also, there are many people who LIKE the look of the 4" stone and then tile from there up to the bottom of the cabinets.

    hawkgt-- this is more of a personal aesthetic issue. There's no real reason one way or the other from a mechanical or technical standpoint. It's strictly an issue of whether or not you like the look. Here are a couple of similar backsplashes and countertops. Both are ubatuba countertops, and both have santa cecilia granite tile with ubatuba accents for the backsplash. Only difference is one has the 4" stone, and one doesn't:

  • 16 years ago

    I disagree with pharaoh. Don't think 4" backsplash is a leftover from the days of laminate counters. Even today's laminates can look great in kitchens. Most people do not get the 4" granite backsplash but then, there are people who do get it because that was what they wanted. Pharaoh's kitchen is beautiful-however, it's not what I would do in my house. My kitchen will probably not get wows from everyone who views it but it works for DH and me. Everybody has different taste/ideas and what is right for one may not be right for another

    Like Bill V says it's really more of a personal issue We went with the 4" granite backsplash for 2 reasons-first, had no ideas for anything else and second-well, we like it and it did cost extra $$. It was not an afterthought and we did not run out of money. Granite was installed in October 2009 and now I have picked my backsplash. Do I wish I hadn't done the 4"?? Not at all.

    I'm not one to follow trends so my kitchen will have soffits, refinished oak cabinets and a wild mix of colors and textures. It won't be featured in any magazine but it features well in DH and my hearts and we are, after all, the ones who live/cook/eat here.

    You need to decide what you want in your kitchen, regardless of what others advise/tell you. Designers, contractors, tile setters, etc. will all leave at some point and you will be the one left standing in your kitchen. This has to be/should be your decision-what YOU want. Go for it!!

  • 16 years ago

    I think it is just a matter of a 4" back splash is what my GC and his cabinet/counter sub always do therefore that is what they feel more comfortable with, even though they may not know why. This will not be the first request I have made of my contractor that he gave me one of those looks and asked if I was sure I wanted it. A good example is asking him to put the outlets in the baseboard. At first it was something unfamiliar (in terms of construction) therefore he was hesitant but then he was willing to try what ever I ask for. I am really happy we asked for the outlets in the baseboard. Same is true for the coffered ceiling I built while getting lots of looks from my GC and his subs. They all love it now. This is a fixed price contract and the counter top crew were in last Monday to cut the template so I am sure the back splash is already cut or in the process of. My GC was working on the house today so I told him to have them deliver the back splash but not to adhere it to the wall. The more I think about it the more confident I am in wanting the look of all tile. I appreciate all the feedback!

  • 16 years ago

    I don't see why it has to be that way when plenty of kitchen remodels you see in magazines and on TV have tile adjoining the countertop. There is a seam either way, rght?
    In terms of aesthetics I don't like the look of the 4 inch backsplash with tile above. Plus then you have a little ledge that collects dust. I say tile to the countertop.

Sponsored
Urban Upkeep LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Columbus High Quality Painting Expert