Software
Houzz Logo Print
bob_cville

Suggestions to fix Sink Drain Problem

19 years ago

My sister complained that the drain pipes under her kitchen sink leaked slightly. She sent me an image of the problem, and it looks to me as if she's facing a more serious problem and I was wondering if there is any easy solution to her problem.

{{gwi:2010090}}

As this image shows the outlet from the garbage disposal is lower than the drain pipe after the trap, and to make up for this problem the installer of the disposal reversed the lower section of the p-trap, which is the cause of the leak. Am I right in thinking that this is a definite code violation? And that the only possible "fixes" are to open the wall and lower the attachment to the drain pipe (which might expose other problems) or to remove the disposal and install the correct drain fittings.

FYI My sister's house was newly built a couple of years ago in Florida, and I believe the disposal was installed by the builder's plumber.

Comments (5)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The wooden center stile of the cabinet is blocking view of the connection on the disposal but judging by the elevation of the cross tube in reference to the dishwasher drain input it appears they made a very common mistake. They used the wrong end waste kit for this application.

    It appears that this is a regular end waste kit rather than a "Disposal End Waste Kit". When a regular end waste kit is used you have a 1/4 bend on the disposal port which points down, then the conventional end waste cross tube has a 1/4 bend on the end that connects to the bottom of the 1/4bend from the disposal. This causes an immediate 2.5" drop in elevation of the cross tube.

    Properly you should have a "Disposal End Waste Kit" which has a straight cross tube with a flat flange on the intake end at the disposal. The factory supplied 1/4 bend for the disposal is discarded and the end of the cross tube is attached directly to the disposal discharge port. This leaves the cross tube at the same elevation as the disposal discharge port thus the Tee section under the second sink basin would then be approximately 2.25" higher. (you would need to shorten the tailpiece from the second sink basin.)

    The P-trap can then be installed on the waste arm in the proper manner and the tailpiece from the discharge side of the Tee would be shortened to fit into the P-trap.

    You can buy a "Disposal End Waste Kit" in any local hardware or home supply store for about $10 or less.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    She sent me another couple of images that shows the outlet from the disposal more clearly. Unless I am mistaken, it looks to me like the 1/4 bend from the disposal has already been removed, and the outlet from the disposal is level with or only slightly above the drain arm as it enters the wall. If so is there any easy solution?

    {{gwi:2010091}}

    {{gwi:2010092}}

    If the only easy solution is to remove the disposal, how does one do that? Is a special wrench required?

    -Bob

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Now that we can see the connection to the disposal it appears that they do have the correct end waste kit which means you now have two options.

    1. Lower the elevation of the waste arm from the wall.
    or
    2. Remove the disposal.

    If the waste arm is connected to a vertical riser in the wall lowering the elevation is not difficult however gaining access from the kitchen side of the wall would require removing the cabinet which presents a number of problems. If the wall containing the pipes is a dividing wall between two rooms the preferred access would be to come in from the opposite side of the wall from the next room where hopefully you would only need to make a small opening into the wallboard, of course, if this is an outside wall that would also be very difficult. If the pipe runs horizontal in the wall the size of the required opening would be larger but here again it may not be as bad as you might think. The kitchen sink drain line is an 1-1/2" line and if you are under the International Residential Code the maximum length of that line would be 6' measured from the trap to the vent connection. If you are under the Uniform Plumbing Code the pipe inside the wall is required to be a 2" line but the length is limited to 5' measured from the trap to the vent. In either case it could be done with a minimum amount of destruction by coming in from the opposite side of the wall.

    If changing the elevation is not feasible or cost effective the only option would be to remove the disposal. Removing the disposal is not difficult nor does it require any special tools.

    First locate the electrical circuit breaker that supplies current to the disposal and switch it off, then disconnect the electrical cable to the disposal.

    If you will examine the disposal mount you will see a lower chrome plated ring that has three formed metal tubular projections. (one can be seen in the photo directly above the dishwasher drain line connection).

    While holding the disposal body upwards use a small hammer and tap that projection to turn that ring in a counter-clockwise direction viewed from the bottom. That ring will turn about 1/4 turn or less and the disposal will drop downwards. You can then set the disposal unit aside and begin removing the disposal mounting bracket.

    Examine the bracket and you will see three vertical machine screws. Using a screwdriver you first back those machine screws out about 1/2 way. The lower ring of the mount will then be loose and can be slid upwards on the mounting bracket. With the lower ring slid upwards you will find a heavy wire snap ring on the lower end of the tubular part of the mounting bracket. Use a flat tip screwdriver to pry that snap ring off and the ring will then slide down and off. You then push upwards on the bracket and it will go up through the sink opening.(It will be stiff because there should be a plumbers putty or silicone seal where the top flange of the drain basket meets the sink.) At this point you will have the whole disposal mounting bracket removed and you will have a raw opening in the bottom of the sink.

    You will now need a new drain basket assembly and either some plumbers putty or silicone sealer. (I am an old school plumber who prefers plumbers putty unless there is an issue of compatibility with the sink material. In the case of a stainless steel sink there is no compatiblity problem).

    Take a small amount of plumbers putty and roll it out into a rope about the diameter of an ordinary lead pencil and long enough to wrap around the underside of the sink basket top flange. Lightly press it in place under the flange then drop the basket assembly down through the hole in the sink.

    Next locate both the rubber gasket and the cardboard gasket in the parts kit. From the underside of the sink the rubber gasket is slid on the drain basket and slid up against the underside of the sink. The cardboard gasket is not really a gasket, but rather it is an anti-friction ring that is installed on the underside of the rubber gasket to prevent friction between the rubber gasket and the lock nut. Next slide the locknut up and screw it up tight against the underside of the sink. They make a special wrench for tightening the locknut but you need not buy one unless you plan on doing this on a regular basis. Instead, you can put the point of your screwdriver against one of the flat projections on the lock nut and tap the screwdriver lightly with your hammer to tighten the nut. As you tighten the nut you will see the excess plumbers putty squeezing out from under the flange inside the sink. Use the tip of your finger then a wet rag to wipe the excess plumbers putty out.

    At this point you are ready to attach a sink tailpiece to the drain basket. At this point you should connect your P-trap and lightly fit your end waste kit to the P-trap to determine the finished elevation of the waste kit ends. (you may need to cut the sink tailpieces slightly to ajust for height.) NOTE-The cross tube should be pitched 1/4" per foot downward from the second sink to the Tee connection.)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you so much for the information. After passing this along to my sister, she contacted the builder. He said he'd come out a take a look at it, and if it is indeed "not to code" he'd fix it for free. However given that it was his crew who did it this way in the first place, I'm expecting he's going to try to convince my sister that it is to code the way it is.

    Does anyone know the relevant portion of the code that would govern this situation that my sister could quote to prevent the builder from trying to snow-job her into paying him to fix his mistake?

    -Bob

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    She can tell him that all codes require an 1-1/2" pipe to have a 1/4" per foot pitch downward from the trap and all fittings are required to be installed in the proper manner,, and Ray Charles could see that trap is backwards.