Software
Houzz Logo Print
weedyacres

Coordinating with existing, discontinued brick

13 years ago

This is our house. The brick is no longer available.

Let's say we wanted to put a short wall like this at the front of the yard:

{{gwi:9311}}

Traditional Landscape by Vernon Hills Landscape Architect James Martin Associates

Would an alternate material (like stacked stone) work? Or is it a no-go out of anything but matching brick (which isn't available)? Here are some stone options:




Comments (13)

  • 13 years ago

    We went through this a few years ago, and it was very frustrating. In our case the new masonry was much closer to the odd brick than it would be in your case, it was part of the front of the house. I wouldn't think twice about a contrasting material, including any of your stone samples, in a wall in front of the yard. The sandy colors in all your samples tie in well with your front walk, stone bench, etc. In fact, even if the matching brick WAS available I'd probably still opt for the stone.

  • 13 years ago

    Beautiful home, weedy. I think the stone would be a nice complement to the brick.

  • 13 years ago

    Weedy aren't you trying to sell the house? I would not spend any money on decorative hardscape ... it doesn't make sense. Lower the price instead.

  • 13 years ago

    it would help if we could see the front part of the yard you would be placing a wall. My first thought was no go and not because a match can't happen. The photo you showed with a wall is not attractive in my eyes.

  • 13 years ago

    I think a larger stone, in maybe a lighter (or darker) color would work. Like #1 or # 3 of your samples. I would not do a skinny stacked stone.

  • 13 years ago

    Front of the house from across the street:
    {{gwi:43414}}

    The house is about 100 feet back from the road, but because the neighboring houses are closer to the lake, it feels closer to the road. A short wall with some posts on either side of the driveway would make it feel more secluded, and some plantings on the house side of the short wall would provide something pretty to look at from the front windows of the house.

  • 13 years ago

    A decorative wall would be okay in a similar brick. What makes the house above so pretty is they have alot of big trees and other shrubs which helps the wall blend in.

    I'm assuming you're not selling? If I were to put money in the yard it would be for lots and lots of trees, big one's! If you are selling, future buyers would probably want trees over a wall.

    We were going to buy a house on 5 acres a few years ago but we didn't because there were only a couple of trees.

  • 13 years ago

    Our mailbox which matched our brick (constructed while house was being built) was displaced by an intoxicated driver who ended up with a broken arm and facial bones. The bricks were scattered everywhere and not enough good bricks to put Humpty Dumpty back together again, so the contractor asked for the same brick that he had used before which (large brick company) had, but sadly, they did not match. I guess the clay was different with that lot. I would have preferred at that point not having a brick mail box but having something on a stick to the glaring discrepancy but I expect time and brick lots make a difference. House was 12 years old when it happened.

    We had a stone patio built later and used stone near the color of our mortar. It looks intentional. It's like wearing plaids, checks, florals and stripes...if it looks intentional...but not like you ran out of good taste.

  • 13 years ago

    Second the idea of using a stone that is the color of your mortar, so there is a cohesiveness to the color scheme overall. Something else you might consider is a concrete block wall stuccoed with the same color stucco as your mortar. The choices you've pictured here look very much like you are trying to update the brick with some stone---- even though that is not your intention.

    Also agree that the walls themselves, in the absence of any trees, may look stark and un inviting, which is the opposite of what you are trying to achieve. Have you considered attractive fencing---- perhaps a three board white fence? You could plant some fast growing vines on them so it wouldn't look brand new. But that would require daily watering for a time, as I think I remember from your thread on the other forum that there's no irrigation in the yard. Do you still have it on the market?

  • 13 years ago

    kswl: Are you talking about a fence like this? It seems way too casual for the style of the house, no?

    The idea would be to put plantings (bushes, flowers) on the house side of the wall (fence?) to provide a nicer view than the road. Or a stark wall.

  • 13 years ago

    How about some aluminum fencing - the look of wrought iron. With bushes on the inside.

  • 13 years ago

    In our area, and most parts of the south, homes on acreage use that type of board fence precisely for the reason that it's more casual. It would have to be painted, of course, which may be more maintenance than you want. I think a fence all along the front edge of the property would look more substantial than just a window dressing type of short wall and columns at the drive that sometimes has an "aftermarket" look.

  • 13 years ago

    With the black doors, shutters and light, you could definitely go with wrought iron (needs painting too -- maybe not as often as wood?), but if you want a solid wall, I'd have no hesitation with the first stone. It looks like it does a nice job of picking up the brick color and tying in well with the front walk. I think I would like it better than matching brick if it were available. Something to be said for texture.