Software
Houzz Logo Print
betsyhac

Tankless Water Heater

16 years ago

I'm a single person in a 1200 sq. ft. home in Wisconsin who is about to buy a water heater, a larger size, about 50 gal I believe. From what I've gleaned so far, gas is better than electric and AO Smith is a good brand. But the tankless intrigues me. Cost isn't a big deal, but I don't want to be frivolous. My plumber seems to think tankless are too expensive to be worth it. From what I've read here so far, I don't feel like I have a clear picture. Any advice appreciated.

Comments (4)

  • 16 years ago

    "My plumber thinks tankless are too expensive to be worth it"

    That statement begs a couple of questions:

    1. What does your plumber estimate is the cost?
    2. What would you consider reasonable payback or "worth it"?

    Keep in mind that it's the difference between the cost of a tankless unit and a tank unit that is the amount subject to "payback" calculation.

    For some reason, plumbers want to charge way too much money to install a tankless heater.

    My tankless cost $1000 including the vent kit and valve set. The difference was about $500 over a standard tank unit. However, I couldn't have used a standard tank unit - I needed a powervent in order to fix a venting problem or I needed to install a liner. A power vent heater would have cost as much as the tankless.

    Keep in mind there is a 30% tax credit. You can also expect to save about 38% on the cost of heating water.

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you JTWD. Can you recommend a good brand? I was thinking of getting a 50 gal regular gas WH, so I've been told to get a 9 gal. tankless; does that sound right? It's hard to make calculations about payback, bc it's dependent on use, right? Most important to me is that it's reliable and lasts, and I don't have any problems that need to be corrected (as Plumeriavine did). Don't know what the plumber would charge. I have to wait til Mon. to discuss, so thx for the point of reference. He's a good guy and I trust him. I don't think he's got a lot of experience with tankless tho?

  • 16 years ago

    how many showers do you have, go to takagi.com and then call and ask to speak to someoenn in your location, maybe someone can come over and give a site visit.

  • 16 years ago

    Within the last 3 years there was an analysis by consumer reports and I think they came to the conclusion that tankless costs much more over the life of the product and does not payback.

    A tank system has a reasonable purchase and install cost. It can sit for 10 to 15 years in your basement and work. Just minimal maintenance the homeowner can do, empty the tank once a year, check the valve. When it breaks you rarely repeair.

    Tankless costs CR noted I recall:
    System costs 2X to 5X more
    Install costs 2X to 5X more, need higher power or bigger/higher pressure gas pipe
    Annual maintenace of about $100 to $200. You should have a service call like you do on your furnance to make sure it is working right.
    More expensive repairs