Software
Houzz Logo Print
misplacedtxgal

Tile debacle - need advice!

15 years ago

I spent months searching for the right tile for my kitchen. I finally settled on a beautiful mosaic of 1x1 white onyx. I ordered from what I believe to be a reputable site online. The tile installer had installed tile for a friend and she gave him a good recommendation.

It is now installed and is several shades darker than the original color. My beautiful WHITE onyx is now mostly gray!

I asked the online company if there were any special instructions for installing this stone. I was told to be sure to use white mortar as the stone can take on the backing color and to be sure to seal it. I shared this information with the installer. He said that was fine. He told me that this tile needed to be sealed before grouting and again after grouting. He was here helping with the grouting and tile laying on day one. At the end of the day he showed me the tile and it looked OK for ungrouted tile. He said that his guys would come back the next day, put on the sealer, wait about 30 minutes and then grout. I stayed upstairs working until they were finished. When I came downstairs they were finished and I noticed that the tile was gray and the grout was too dark. I inquired about it, but they mostly spoke spanish so I didn't get a good answer. I had thought maybe it was just wet and would dry to the lovely white I had selected. They said the owner would call me to schedule coming out to do the final sealer.

The owner called me about an hour later to tell me he would come the next day (today) to do the final seal. I asked about the grout and tile colors being off. He said, what I had assumed, that the grout would dry to the correct color. As to the tile changing color he said I needed to speak to the manufacturer and basically blew me off. As the day wore on I was getting more concerned so I sent him a text message and said that I didn't want him come today and put the sealer on and that I would call him after I spoke to the manufacturer. He called me right back and said he needed to finish the job and get paid. I told him that I needed to get to the bottom of what had happened and didn't think putting another coat of sealer on was a good idea at that point. He then starts acting like I'm trying to stiff him out his payment! I told him that that was not the case, but that the tile did NOT look like it had before installation and I needed to decide where to go from here. He told me that he was coming over in 20 minutes to look at the tile. I had already left for my exercise class at this point, so DH got to deal with him. He insisted the tile had not changed color, although his little boy who had tagged along said that it had! DH told me he didn't think it was really the guys fault.

I expect to hear back from the manufacturer today.

I did find a bottle of the sealer they had left. It is 511 impregnator sealer made by Miracle Sealants. Under SAMPLE TESTING it says "Due to variations between substrates sample testing is recommended... Minimal shading may occur. User must determine the suitability of the product for its intended use. " Under DIRECTIONS it says "A second application may be necessary for some surfaces...Allow 24 - 72 hours to fully cure" Then under GROUT RELEASE: "...be careful not to saturate open grout joints and allow at least 6 12 hours before grouting." None of this was mentioned to me before the install.

Installer just called me. And said this is the way stone looks when it is properly installed. He won't admit it looks different! Keeps telling me I should have selected a white ceramic if I wanted white. I feel he bears some responsibility here. But my main concern it what do I do now?? I appreciate any advice you might have on 1) what to do about the color problem and 2) how to move forward with the tiler.

Thanks! Here's the pics:

{{gwi:1715852}}

{{gwi:1715853}}

{{gwi:1715855}}

Comments (17)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Onyx is translucent and porous. One reason your uninstalled tile is "lighter" is that light is passing through it and creates the illusion that it's lighter in color. White onyx will always look a bit darker on the wall that it does uninstalled because you're covering the edges from light infiltration. However, there are also other factors that could come into play here. If grey thinset (NOT grout)was used, onyx will look greyer in appearance because of it's translucent nature. Because of it's porosity, wet onyx appears darker than dry onyx, and it takes some time for the tile to dry out. If the tile setter used any "premixed" thinset, it may take quite a while to dry out. Days, in fact in a normal installation. Premixed thinset cures by dehydration, and you've sealed the front, so it might even take weeks for your installation to dry. The mix your own thinset in white dries by chemical reaction, but will still leave onyx looking dark while it's wet. THe sealer the setter used is a high quality one and is highy recommended, so it's hopeful that he also used the correct products for install.

    You need to find out some information from the tile setter.

    What type of thinset was used?

    What color thinset was used?

    What type of grout was used? Was it a premix?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We have a glass tile backsplash and it also looks a few shades darker than before it was installed. Fortunately for us, it still goes well with the rest of our kitchen so we didn't mind.

    I don't know about your tile but from the pics it looks translucent as well so there may be something to what the installer says. With the back and sides covered, it will look darker.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you so much for sharing your advice! So do you recommend I have him come back to do the final seal? At this point only the tile is sealed and not the grout. I just don't want it to make the tile appear even darker.

    I know he used white mortar as he special ordered it.
    Thank you again - I really appreciate it!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "... appreciate any advice you might have on 1) what to do about the color problem and 2) how to move forward with the tiler..."

    Answer:
    Shine lots of light onto it.
    You will get a two things
    1/ a bright kitchen AND
    2/ a lot of the effect you thought you were buying.
    3rdly you will have a well lit eye draw.
    4thly your eye draw will be the thing farthest away from you so the kitchen will appear more spacious.
    5thly you will even have a bit of a mirror effect without the aggravating part of mirrors (too much "showing").

    HOW: You could use fluorescent tube lighting. It will look good, no matter what type of light the bulb produces. Search T4 and T5 lights. To get comfortable, slowly, go buy a couple of them from a big box hardware store and try them out before committing.

    ".... this is the way stone looks when it is properly installed. ...."
    He is Right.

    "... He won't admit it looks different... "
    He may be willing to say the apparent difference is an inevitable result that occurs when you take something translucent and cover five of its six sides.

    "... I should have selected a white ceramic if I wanted white.... "
    True.
    You did not want white.
    You wanted translucent. It will pick up colors from its surroundings. The light bulb shining into it will necessarily have some "impurities" in its light. This will produce subtle hues.

    "... I feel he bears some responsibility here...."
    None at all.

    "... my main concern it what do I do now?? "
    See point #1.

    To go all-out, install two parallel runs of T4 or T5 fluorescents, one run with "warm" white and one with "cold" white.
    It will produce an astounding assortment of minor variations.
    Less blatant than a rainbow, but just as beautiful. Hue heaven.

    hth

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I hate to say, it but the guys above are right.... it's the nature of stone like that. Especially onyx, which is so translucent, and requires the light coming through it to look that way.

    I picked up some ungrouted honey onyx once for a project and was all set to use it until I saw a grouted sample board at a different tile shop. It looked VERY different. You'll notice that onyx is used a lot in really bling-y installations such as back-lit counters, to showcase that quality, which really gets lost when the edges are covered up with grout.

    I WILL say, though, that not all "White" thinset is really white. I was sorely disappointed when the thinset dried in my bathroom recently behind the white glass mosaic tile I'd chosen. The thinset package said "White", and my very competent tile guy used it specially because it was supposed to be white.... but it was really quite grey. Not as dark grey as the regular stuff, but still grey. I've since seen several other thinset brands that are actually very white, and I WISH I'd known and specified that, because my white tile is a cool light blue-grey and I had to quickly change my color scheme for the room.... it still looks great, though, I just had to re-adjust my expectations and design a little bit!

    One other thought- in your close-up pics I think I can see grout haze still on the installed tile... I see wipe marks, no? Maybe once that's really properly cleaned off (which should have been done already) a little more light will get in there.

    Will you have under-cabinet lights? I agree that may help. I'm really sorry it's not what you were expecting. Natural stone is a pain that way... you sort of have to be flexible about it I think.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I don't see a debacle, I see an interesting, variegated, subtle backsplash that just needs more under-cabinet light. It will be okay - more than okay, really.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's too bad it's not what you expected, but it is gorgeous!!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks everyone! Live and learn I guess. I just wish my lesson had been on something less noticeable! I actually do have long T4's above the tile and they were on in the pictures. I don't hate it - it is fine - it is just not what I expected (and wanted!). Buyer beware is certainly true in this case! I just wish one of the experts had told me these things BEFORE it went in.

    So, does everyone agree I should have him come back, clean the tile and do the final grout????

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Since you have power under the cabinets, it is easy enough to double the tubes.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This is where professionals and our experience make a difference.

    I would generalize the comments above --- when possible, select tile by looking at a sample board of grouted tile.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's beautiful! It will probably lighten a bit more as it cures. I hope you will be happy with it. It really is lovely.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My message came out wrong ... I meant professionals OR our own experience.

    It read like I was a professional looking down at laypeople, instead of a layperson admitting it can be easy to make mistakes!

    Anyway, a lot of times our choices look different than what we imagine. The tile is beautiful, even if it's not what you thought. Wait till you accessorize it ... I hops you will come to see how pretty it is.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I hope you end up loving it--the installed definitely looks very different, but still beautiful. Could we see a picture showing the overall effect from further away?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I hope you come to love it regardless of it being different than you pictured and planned for. It looks very pretty and I hope that once you accessorize your kitchen, it looks better to you.
    I sympathize with seeing something come out different and being disappointed, but hopefully, it will be long forgotten a year from now. It may take you time to digest the new look.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm positive it will please you. I won't predict the date when you will write it.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I will try to post a full kitchen picture when I get some batteries for the camera. Thanks for the support!

    I guess I'll have him come back tomorrow and do the sealing. I too hope I grow to love it. If it will just lighten a little as predicted here I think that will help a lot!

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    So the tile guy came back last night to put on the final sealer. It went fine and thankfully it doesn't look any darker than before!~

    However, as he was telling me he was finished I asked him about the electrical outlets & switches that were still hanging out of the wall. He says "Oh, you should have told me you wanted them put back, I could have brought longer screws." Really? He took them out, but didn't think I would want them replaced? He had gotten so mad when I told him last week that I wanted to find out why the tile was darker before I had him do the final seal I guess I was afraid to say anything (not usually like me!). So I wrote him his check and was thankful the man was out of my house. I told DH tonight on the phone (he's out of town) that I guessed he would have to do it. He was not thrilled! Not that he's nervous about it, he's an engineer, he just thinks it was certainly understood that the tiler should do it as part of the fee and doesn't think he should have to. Not really sure why I'm writing this other than to vent. Thank goodness, our carpenter that did the kitchen and will soon start some bookshelves takes pride in providing good service. It's unfortunate that this is not the norm anymore!

    I will post final pictures once the new hardware is installed!

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner