Software
Houzz Logo Print
gwer2007

What are my options?

14 years ago

So, my kitchen remodel has to be postponed *indefinitely* because we need to take care of more pressing issues. I have to live with "make do" for anywhere between 10 months to up to 5 years. :-(

The kitchen is done very inconveniently in every way but nobody has to deal with it except for me. People who come over are always fascinated by brick walls around the cooking are and skilfully distressed cabinets. To me, the cabinets look totally outdated but I guess they'd "do", if I had to sell the house "tomorrow" as several people asked me if they could have them when I decided to get rid of them, LOL.

But the biggest issue (in terms of aesthetics) is the counter-tops tiled with (totally dated) small bottle-green square tiles.

As far as I can tell, they are installed inside a wooden frame with plywood bottom.

What can do about it?

I am not sure whether or not the top can be taken lifted off. It seems attached pretty well to another board underneath it (that is sitting on the top of the cabinet base).

I probably could break and remove the tile and re-tile with something more decent. Are there any other options?

The problem is that counter-top is L-shaped with the longer side being 24" and the shorter one being ~28" as it was next to the old built-in fridge. I now have a counter-depth fridge and want to reverse the ratio. That is why getting a new top and letting it just sit on the cabinets is problematic.

Plus, there are 3 other tiled surfaces, including the one with the cooktop. The kitchen has a galley-like design, so the cooktop and the oven are on a different wall.

If I remove the tiles, can I fill the area with cement or something else?

Thanks!

Comments (16)

  • 14 years ago

    Replace with granite tiles?

    Here is a link that might be useful: granite tile countertop page

  • 14 years ago

    Biochem,

    But aren't granite tiles much thicker than ceramic ones?

    I want to keep the wooden frame around the countertop as it is made to match the cabinets (is distressed as well).

    Plus, I don't want to spend $$$ on something temporary.

    If I could put a new top that can be lifted off and then placed on another base (when we replace the cabinets), that would be OK. Are you saying that it might be the case with granite tiles?

    TX!

  • 14 years ago

    I might leave the "3 other surfaces" and go to the granite yard and look for a remnant and take a pic of where you need to drop in the pieces that are mandatory. Some of the Italian families that own some of the yards also install and they may easily figure out what to do for you. They are very skilled around here [SE Mich].

  • 14 years ago

    Have you considered painting the tiles? I once did that in a shower stall with tile I loathed. Required some trial and error to get a primer that worked (can't recall off the top of my head what it was, but I could probably come up with it if necessary). And then several coats of pretty stinky paint (def. not low VOC-variety). But it worked fine for multiple years.

    A countertop would be subject to more abrasion, so might require re-coating earlier. And need vigilant use of trivets to protect it from heat (like laminate, for instance).

    But it won't solve the shape-of-counter issue, just the color. You can probably move the CD fridge out to make it line up with the counter better, at least for the time being.

    FWIW, I happen to like the sound of a bottle-green tiled counter. Can the grout lines be dyed to improve how it appears? I don't know, perhaps someone else does.

    Maybe some feedback from here might help you see it in a more positive way? Pics would help!

    L.

  • 14 years ago

    Herbflavor,

    I cannot leave the "other 3 surfaces", they drive me and DH crazy! LOL.

    Yes, I have thought of a granite remnant. We actually used one for our bathroom redo and it turned out great. However, it still cost us $800 (at ~$40/sq. ft) which is not much compared to the cost of using a slab. However, the 2 of the "other 3 areas" will not exist after the remodel and the area around the cooktop will be a lot larger. That means that I'll be paying $$$ for something that may last only a year.

    But I'll do it if I have to. I am open to any ideas, seriously.

    What about removing the tile and pouring concrete instead? I wouldn't even have to remove the mold!

    Does anyone have any experience with it?

  • 14 years ago

    liriodendron,

    I don't want to post pix b/c they are too "identifiable", kwim? :-)

    But trust me, the tile looks very "dated", even my GC commented on that. Especially in my otherwise very contemporary house.

    I have a lot of left-over cement-like tile (from my bathroom remodel) that I could use. I guess the question is whether I should:

    1. Take out the existing tile and
    a) re-tile or
    b) fill with something else(e.g., concrete)

    OR

    2. Fit something over the existing top (IDK what, SS, maybe?)

    OR

    3. If possible, take the top off and replace with something that can be reused in the future.

    What would you, ladies and gentlemen, do?

  • 14 years ago

    The wood edging isn't structural. It's just decorative. It would have to be the first thing to go to do any changes.

    Either leave the whole thing alone or get out your sledgehammer ane demolish it. If you are at all handy, you can order laminate and custom make yourself a new counter to fit the space. That will probably cost under $100 DIY or around 1K if you pay labor for it. Demo of tile is expensive! If you aren't handy enough to DIY your own laminate counter, then there really isn't anything I would suggest doing to it because any paid labor will be wasted money.

    Either way, don't waste your money on something like a granite remnant when you'll just be tearing everything out in the future.

  • 14 years ago

    Here is a layout similar to mine: (the L-shape, sink under the window, wooden frame around tile, the placement of the DW, and the cabinets.

    (FYI: this picture only, the other parts of his kitchen are different.)

    Now, imagine that the countertop is not smooth like his but consists of textured small (~3") green tiles and the backsplash is made of the same tile but does not even come close to the window frame, so the wall about it gets wet all the time.

  • 14 years ago

    Hollysprings,

    I have seen tile demo in my bathroom. Correct me if I am wrong but it is doable - just time consuming, no? I think I can do it myself using a hammer. :-)

    However, I am not handy enough to DYI laminate. Plus, it would "cheapen" the house.

    So, do you think that poring concrete is a bad option?

  • 14 years ago

    your remodel is sooner rather than later? Why can't you live with it till then? It would not have the ability to drive me crazy if I was starting my remodel notebook of pics and products. Start the remodel in 6-8 mo.

  • 14 years ago

    The remodel was supposed to take place more than a year ago and here I am, still with the same kitchen, after having lived with it for 9 long years! :-(

    I feel like I have exhausted all of my patience. LOL.

    And IDK about "sooner", it could easily be another 5 years (insert crying face here), though I hope not.

    I just *hate" everything about this kitchen so much that if I could change something for not much money, it would make me more content with the wait, I think.

    WWYD?

  • 14 years ago

    Laminate would be a great temporary solution. Remember, you are not marrying it. It's just a one night stand.

    And it's not as hard as you think it is to DIY. You just tear out the tile, put down a particle board substrate and roll on contact cement on the PB and laminate sheet. Place the laminate on the backing and use a rolling pin to seat it. Then you can use a laminate trimmer or even just a sharp knife and cut off the excess overhang.

    That will at least give you a smooth surface to work on until you can get around to tearing everything out.

    But, if you can't DIY a fix for your counters, then just live with them. It will give you more motivation to get on with the actual remodel. And you won't we wasting any money that will be needed for the eventual remodel. But, if I were you, I'd try to ramp up your DIY skills. That will make your money go a lot further down the road when you can get to the remodel.

  • 14 years ago

    DH and I removed our ugly white kitchen countertop tile
    ourselves.

    It depends on if you are keeping your backsplash.
    If you are not, then slam away with a sledge hammer and
    tire iron. In fact it was cathartic to get rid of our
    hideous tile.

    If you have things around your kitchen that are precious
    to you (Appliances, glass cabs, or even floors) you might
    cover all of it with blankets or paper to protect from
    flying shards. Oh and wear eye goggles. Protect your
    eyes and of course you skin. Glvoes will do.
    It can get sharp and ugly.

    ~boxer

  • 14 years ago

    We just did a facelift to our bar in prep for listing our current home. My goal was on the cheap but not cheap looking.

    We pried the old tile (why we didn't do it sooner so we could live with the new stuff is beyond me but so be it) and then put down another layer of plywood and tiled it.

    We used granite tiles (cheap at Flor and Decor) butted together with minimal width grout lines and from a distance it looks like slab. It also looks quite nice up close, certainly better than the before. It was thicker than the original but we like the chunkier square look.

    To save money, we did the tear out and paid to install the tile. I negotiated the price per sq. ft down to $3.25 sq. ft which made the facelift reasonable. He was even able to under mount the existing top mount bar sink using the granite tiles. A new contemporary faucet and done.

    For what it cost, we are very happy, it updates the bar and really looks quite good. Let me know if you want pics.

  • 14 years ago

    Eleena, in your place, assuming I hated the tile and wanted at least some change, I'd have fun, knowing I wouldn't have to live with it always if I didn't want to. You know, lemonade from lemons. You can replace a necessarily sensible and soberly made expensive choice with something adventurous you'd be happy to live with until next time.

    Given your situation, I'd replace the tile with new of the same thickness, but I'd use the freedom the situation gave me to do what I might not if I was putting in a pretty-much-for-life counter. I'd have someone else adjust the underlayment but design, and install it, myself as an art project.

    Here at my house, faced with need for a low-cost counter I came very close to going multi-color 1/2-inch tile, set randomly. I had found very inexpensive but good quality multicolor tile mesh sheets and was choosing tiles of additional vivid colors from an expensive shop to further jewel it up. The edge would have been wood strip painted white to match the cabinets so the brilliant colors were only on the horizontal surface (brilliant up close, more restrained from farther away). I was drawing page after page of additional design details that might be included when we ultimately went a different, even less expensive way. I do love our serene wood counter, but I also regret not being greeted by the other sparkling in the sun each morning.

    Not to suggest that particular look for you, but I'm definitely suggesting the pleasure of cutting loose that NOT spending a lot of money allows. Have children? Maybe put their names or favorite silly sayings down in tile? Copy the swirly pattern in your couch fabric in a new medium. Whatever.

  • 14 years ago

    Oh, thank you, ladies, so much!

    Boxer, I think you have helped me to convince DH to DYI the demo! I do think it would be really cathartic, LOL, but DH is adamantly against DYI-ing.

    Michelle, yes, pix PLEASE!

    Roise, that is a good idea, I'll look into it. I am not sure it'd work though b/c we have a brick wall around the cooktop. Plus, the rest of the house decor is pretty much minimalistic. I want something that looks decent enough to sell the house "tomorrow", if I had to, kwim? :-)

    I'll post pix if I decide to do something unusual, promise, LOL.

    Thanks again, you made my (so far gloomy) day!