Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_10471126

Island - corner/base finishing question.

16 years ago

For some reason I've been putting off finishing my island. My Dad has some free time to remake (yep remake) my corners and I need to make sure I get it right this time.

I screwed them up by staining without testing. It looked horrible orange. Wouldn't sand off.

The base will be painted black. Dad made ....forget what he calls them.. plinth blocks? to use on the corners where the base buts into. See photos. They would get painted black. He made them..something about different widths of the wood. Smooth transition or something.

I don't know. I don't believe I've even seen an island finished like this and I've discovered sometimes my Dad and I don't have the same vision for what looks right on a completed project. I need some feedback.

The corners would be more rounded. (They're very square at the moment!) And as you can see the color of them looks like poo against the island.

1. What do you think of the width of the corners? I think they could be slightly wider. These are 1 1/4" width on each side. They were originally 1 1/2" and I thought they looked too beefy but this was before they were cut so I could see them flat against the island.

2. Will the plinth block things look ok? I can't run the base the whole way around and have the corner sit on top. It would stick out too far. Reason for the plinth thing I suppose.

It would help if I had the plinth block painted to see.

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

3. Then I've seen examples like this..........however, I was hoping to use the left over base moulding I already have that matches the rest in my house.

I guess honestly ......... I'm mainly looking for feedback on the corner pieces and I'd like to know if you think the transition is going to look odd once done.

There's these skinny pieces of moulding people add but that's going to be one more piece of wood to try and match, not to mention I think the top of the base is too skinny to try and sit something on. It would stick out over if that makes sense.

{{!gwi}}

My mind is pretty much set on the black base and I'm not painting the island at this point.

Thanks!

Comments (7)

  • 16 years ago

    Alisha, I think what your Dad is doing is just fine considering the size of the base trim. Plinth blocks are slightly higher than the base and slightly thicker than any trim above them too. You Dad did good.
    Why won't you be painting the whole island now? I would think it would be easier to paint it before you add the trim.

  • 16 years ago

    If the dark base is what you have in the rest of the house I'd go with that. The plinth fits nicely and once you paint it to match the base it will look perfect. It looks like you've already stained and finished the "L" shaped corner pieces. Your dad has a good eye and is a skilled woodworker, trust him.

  • 16 years ago

    Ok thanks guys! I needed to hear something.

    Justgotabeme - I liked Squirrel's mock up of the green island but so far in life I've been unsuccessful with glaze. I don't want it the same plain green pain that's on my walls. Painting the island black was too heavy and didn't work with my white refrigerator and white didn't look right. I will, at some point, experiment with green paint and glaze.

    I know the question of what to do with my island has been beat to death so I was just trying to stay clear of talking paint again.

    Ajsmama - He's going to remake the corners because the color looks really horrid IRL.

    I'm glad to know I didn't imagine the words plinth block. lol

    So you guys think the width of the corners are ok? A little wider? 1 1/2" on each side instead of the 1 1/4" that's showing? I know it's not much different but still...

  • 16 years ago

    I like what your dad did. You are such a busy bee!

    Smiles:)

  • 16 years ago

    Maybe you are using too heavy of glaze mixture. I always add a bit of water to mine. It flows into the crevices much better and when you wipe it off after a few minutes it doesn't leave as dark of streaks. Much softer looking. I do hope you give it a try. The green would look so nice in your already pretty kitchen.

  • 16 years ago

    Oops forgot to say the size of the plinth block is just fine. Perfect in fact. Please give your Daddy a hug for me. Since I can only remember how great my Daddy's hugs were I like my friends to hug theirs. It makes me happy.

  • 16 years ago

    Becky - I've been trying to shoot you an email on and off all day and there's an error in the server or something. Can you try to email me?