Software
Houzz Logo Print
gwer2007

dyi ss countertops?

14 years ago

Sorry if this is a silly question but I was inspired byt the Copper Countertop thread (gorgeous, btw).

I have been told that it might be possible to cover my existing ceramic tile countertops using SS sheeting, while awating the (now postponed) kitchen remodel.

Is it possible? Can it be done as a DYI project? If not, is done by th same people who make SS countertops (i.e., expensively) or are there less expensive options?

Thanks!

Comments (25)

  • 14 years ago

    I'm not an expert on diy SS counters... but we're doing a diy kitchen update, that includes SS counters.

    My husband (also known as my free labor) was unwilling to consider this because of the tools you'd need. Not just a metal break, but the heavier duty welding etc. Stainless steel is a much stiffer/harder metal than copper. My husband is very talented - electrical, plumbing, tile, carpentry (custom cabinets and doors), oh... and he's an architect... but he drew the line on stainless steel counters.

    We were determined and inspired to get a SS countertop after touring the Hearst Castle kitchen.

    We were very disappointed when the quotes from sheet metal shops came back really high... ($6-8k) but we got a reasonably affordable product when we approached a restaurant supply place. (I would definitely explore all your options for SS, not just 1 or two quotes from sheet metal shops. In some markets, that's the cheaper way to go, in our market the restaurant supply house was cheaper.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks!

    I called a place that makes residential SS countertops and the price was $130/linear ft.

    I'll try a local RS store.

  • 14 years ago

    DH put together the underlayment for ours and took it to the local sheet metal shop to be wrapped in stainless. It took just a short time, on the spot, for our two pieces to be cut, bent, and folded on their tools. It cost us $17/sq ft. I think that if you put stainless right over tile, it might be noisy?

  • 14 years ago

    You are right. I have been just told that most countertops can be simply lifted off the base cabinets. If so, I am going to look into replacing the entire counter.

  • 14 years ago

    I just saw this at The Home Project Blog. The owners call it "DIY," but they did have a metal fabricator make the SS countertop and cut a hole in it for their sink, then the homeowners installed it themselves. They have photos to show what it took to install over existing laminate countertops. Cost them around $400 for the SS fabrication.

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Home Project Blog

  • 14 years ago

    That kitchen, "the home project blog". It's those darn CUP PULLS that make that kitchen! LOL!

  • 14 years ago

    Rhome, Could you describe the underlayment? Plywood or MDF? And you made it as thick (gluing?) as you wanted the countertop to be?
    I'm going to check with the neighborhood welder/metalworker this week, so I'm really curious -- and hopeful that I can persuade him.

  • 14 years ago

    DH used MDF, but plywood should would work, too. He's pretty sure he screwed them together, but glue might do it. We have thicker-than-normal counters, so he used 3 layers of 3/4".

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks -- your counters look great!

  • 14 years ago

    Not just anyone can fabricate stainless. It's very unforgiving and not at all DIY friendly like copper. To be able to bend the edge will require a big professional grade metal brake. It cannot be bent by hand like copper can. It's too stiff and has a "memory" that will fight you. If you want to try the trick where you attach solid bar stock to the edge and sheet to the top, then you're talking about a TIG welder, not epoxy. That's also a pro grade machine and an experienced pro to do it.

    While stainless counters do not have to cost the $150 SF that many kitchen showrooms charge, it's going to be be rare to get them under $50 unless you are willing to do the fabrication of the base yourself and then have a truck and trailer to transport it to the scary parts of town where the cheaper metal shops will be located.

  • 14 years ago

    rhome410,

    What is the paint on your walls? It looks "sage" - or is it just the light?

    I need that color!

    You kitchen looks more than fantastic! I wish I could have one like yours - but I have to go with a transitional style, not modern/contemporary, b/c of the house design. Sigh.

  • 14 years ago

    And thanks everyone who has responded so far! You have talked me out of trying to DYI it. :-)

    DH and I are NOT "handy" at all, I was just exploring the option b/c of seeing the copper countertop.

    Where does one get copper sheets?

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks, Eleena... The walls started out as Lincolnshire Olive, which is Ralph Lauren color. It was a little too green for me, so now the walls are Benj Moore Sag Harbor Gray, which is barely a different color, but just exactly what I wanted. I can't remember which color is in this picture. Sag Harbor doesn't come off well on the little swatch, but I think it looks great on the walls.

  • 14 years ago

    it's going to be be rare to get them under $50 unless you are willing to do the fabrication of the base yourself and then have a truck and trailer to transport it to the scary parts of town where the cheaper metal shops will be located

    I don't know how large your counter pieces would be, but we didn't require anything more than DH's pick up, and our sheet metal shop is right in our downtown... Not a scary place at all. ;-) Guess the scariness issue and price probably depends on your area...

    And, we have an American Foursquare style house, but built from 2006 -2008, so not an authentic one from the 1920s or 30s. We did kind of Craftsman, but with current appliances and hardware, it has a contemporary touch. I think you can lean contemporary in a transitional house if you'd like... If the other trims, etc. aren't too strongly styled in a certain way.

  • 14 years ago

    You will save by providing a template for a fabricator and for use as a substrate for the top. I would not use MDF, but rather MDO or good plywood. The SS top is then glued to the substrate for stiffness and quietness. The edge treatment and integrated sinks can start to add cost quickly. Also the desired finish adds cost. The finer the shine the more it cost.

  • 14 years ago

    Thank you ladies!

    I have no problem using plywood as I don't like MDF for anything, period.

    Can anyone make a template?

    Rhome410,

    I AM leaning toward contemporary big time, LOL. I am a Retro Modern addict living in a Southern, (sort of) "New Orleans" style house, imagine that! And I think I have done a pretty good job "marrying" the two, in terms of furniture and the decor. But cabinets are a different story as they are part of the house and shouldn't be too different architecturally.

    Thanks for the info, I'll go get a swatch of the paint this week. And I'll definitely talk to a local RS company!

  • 14 years ago

    This thread came at the perfect time for me. The kitchen I'm working on blends late 19th-early 20th century elements with industrial, so a plain edge treatment is fine. My main worry is finding someone who will be able to make a corner seam disappear. (I'm also fine with a drop in sink.)
    There are no real scary parts of town where I am. Or there would be a lot of them if I were scared of cows.

  • 14 years ago

    ZINC!!!! You can screw up a whole bunch, buy more, screw up some more, buy some more....and still come out cheaper than copper.
    I really wanted zinc instead of copper. BUT, was worried that it would be way too "industrial" looking with stainless appliances. (same thoughts with using stainless).
    The copper is installed, but, I'd sure like to have seen it in Zinc.
    OH, Copper Sheets (ebay). You cannot get the exact size you want, but, you can get 4x10' sheets. Take what's left over to a recycling center. It will then wind up being cheaper than any on-line metal "store".
    My DIY project included a new counter substrate/base and 24ga copper. It would up being right at $10/sq ft.
    26ga copper would have been better for the installation, and after doing this? I don't see any problems with using the thinner 26ga copper sheet.

  • 14 years ago

    Dando,

    Would you come over and do my counters?

    This way, you'll get to install zinc counters as well, LOL.

    I REALLY love your kitchen. It also made me think of putting a butcher block next to SS (or zinc) where the cooktop is. That was smart!

  • 14 years ago

    N'Orleans? Heck yeah!!
    Seriously, the DIY thing isn't all that big of a deal. Patience is required though.
    The method that the above links show, for stainless, seems to be lots easier than the way I did it. Although, my method didn't require any outside help. (okay, so I shoulda had an HVAC guy stop by and solder the seams...LOL)

    Can you post a couple of photo's of your countertop?
    Butcher Block? 1200 grit sandpaper on an orbital sander will make one shine like glass. It also closes up the pores in the wood so that nothing can soak in so easy. (to begin it's life anyway. knife tracks will cure that real fast though...lol)

  • 14 years ago

    Speaking from my own experience making copper countertops, I'd possibly try to avoid buying the sheets rolled up from online -- my glue has become undone in a few places due to the slight curve that got into the metal's memory when we rolled it up for two weeks' storage before we began the project. It's developed into a few annoying ridges that run the width of the counter. (Either that, or store the rolled sheets weighted flat for quite a while before attaching them.)

    Eleena, we got the sheet at a local roofing supply store - it's branded by Revere (yes! just like my grandma's RevereWare pans!) and is stored in flat bulk packs. They peel off however many sheets you need. I suspect it wasn't any more expensive than buying online because of saving on shipping costs -- not that I object to using eBay for just about every shopping need, mind you. ;-)

    Rotometals has some excellent videos on making your own zinc countertops with their very affordable sheet and homemade brakes much like Dando's.

    The only issue with zinc vs stainless is that, like copper, it will patinate easily with every touch and every substance. You might want to seal zinc if you use it for heavily-used counter areas.

    Which leads me to a note of possible interest for anyone making their own metal countertops:

    I recently experimented with a coating called Protect-a-Clear, sealing the sink section where we were getting the most unwanted gunky verdigris. I have to say it's pretty incredible stuff for this purpose. The counters look just like they did before the coating, all the patina preserved, no weird plastic-looking sheath. And they can now just be wiped with a damp cloth, no more scrubbing and scraping with a razor to get the really adhered green-blackened gunk.

    They claim Protect-a-Clear is food-safe once dry, and I can attest that it has very little odor and is easy to apply. I'll report back with my use experience over the months.

    As an addendum for those who are making their own copper counters like Dando's amazing ones, I'll link my post detailing the method I used. I did it slightly differently, using mitered bar on the sides so I didn't have to bend the sheet at all, just router it smooth on the sides. I also didn't solder anything, although I definitely applaud that as a best practice and who knows, maybe one day mine will need it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: my copper counter process

  • 14 years ago

    Dando,

    The BB was in our previous house. Yes, we sanded it, but DH does not like anything DYI. Currently, we have ceramic tile which I despise very much. There is really nothing to post, they just have to "go".

    Thank you, circuspeanut, that was helpful!

    My head is spinning now b/c of TMI, LOL. I need to digest it. :-)

  • 14 years ago

    Hi guys, me and my husband installed our own stainless steel countertops. We cut out a model of our counter in high quality plywood, took it to a local sheet metal shop and they cut and bent a piece of 20 grade stainless steel to fit right on it. Then we took our plywood model + steel back and assembled everything on top of our laminate counter with liquid nails. Our 20 feet counter ended up costing us $400 - so that's $20/square foot.

    More info: DIY installing stainless steel counters

    We love the way this came out and it wasn't that difficult either. I bet the tricky part would be to find a good local sheet metal shop to work with.

    I also love the copper counter above, if we ever were to remodel another kitchen I would so go for copper counter, white drawers and oil rubbed bronze hardware!

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Home Project

  • 14 years ago

    you can get it here for $68 a square foot - but you have to purchase through a dealer.

    I contacted them about their Zinc but ended up just going with stainless. oh, and I love it.

    I didn't use one of their Dealers, I actually had my contractor sign up to become a dealer and I bought it through him and he installed it.


    ps. DIY stainless steel sounds.. scary. The welds are really important, too. They show can show Big time. Bad ones would be bad news.

    Here is a link that might be useful: stainless steel - cheapest complete/finished option i found

  • 14 years ago

    I couldn't have done the "bend it over the edges" method with an undermount sink.
    Need to plan ahead if you have an undermount sink, or, a curved edge somewhere. You'll have to use a separate strip on the facing/edge of the counter.
    I'd think a bit thicker metal, or (bar stock) would work best for the edge?