Software
Houzz Logo Print
stinky_gardener

Better, Worse, About the same?

17 years ago

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

Silver, rectangular mirror above, or gilded, more ornate mirror, below?

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

Comments (34)

  • 17 years ago

    Oh, I love the gilded mirror! It really adds a lot of interest to that space, much more so than the rectangular mirror, which (while nice) just mimics the angular lines of the table and the other items on the wall.

  • 17 years ago

    Give me big and ornate any old day!

    Did you see dlm2000's post about the mirror she just inherited?

  • 17 years ago

    Gilded, ornate mirror!!! Really pretty and graceful.

  • 17 years ago

    I love the ornate mirror but, can't get a feel for it with the close up photo you've taken. Can you step back and take one on the wall like you did with the other mirror? My first inclination on the ornate mirror is the piece below it isn't substantial enough to support it (visually). I really like the one that's hung right now. It appears to be the right scale and weight for the table below.

  • 17 years ago

    Definitely the gold ornate, it goes best with table & drawer pulls, the silver would be better over a modern glass topped tabe with silver legs..

  • 17 years ago

    Both are very pretty mirrors -- and look wonderful!

    I do like the more ornate one with the simple classic lines of the console table and bench .... very elegant! :)

    Jan at rosemary Cottage

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the feedback, Auntjen, Parma, Susie100 & Susieq! Bru, is this any help?
    {{!gwi}}

  • 17 years ago

    Love the gilded mirror!! Do you have a matching lamp for the one on the table? One thing I would change is to switch the two pictures nearest to mirror. Put bigger one below smaller one. Area is very nicely done!!

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks, Teacats! Nice hearing from you.

    Threedgrad, thanks. I like getting feedback about accessories. I don't have another lamp like that, & while I agree that a pair of lamps on that table would be pretty, I don't pursue that because on the other side of the room is my sideboard w/a pair of buffet lamps. Two pair of lamps so close together seems too busy to me. I wish I could come up w/another light source for this side of the room, but having the lamp in this spot seems to cast the prettiest glow for some reason.

    Btw, I so very much want a larger, fluffier, wider, taller tree than the one you see. I think that will go a long way toward softening & adding interest to that corner. I don't think I want another piece of furniture over there.

    Is this what you mean about the pictures?

    {{!gwi}}

  • 17 years ago

    I love the gilded mirror! I like one lamp with it and the balance with the plants and pictures on the other side. Very striking.

  • 17 years ago

    The gilded mirror in your space much, much better. It adds interest to the otherwise neat, clean straight lines of the furniture.

  • 17 years ago

    Fron a distance it does look better now. It goes with your other beautiful decor. I'd say, go with it.

  • 17 years ago

    I avoided posting becasue I did not want to come across as a 'big downer'. But, you do specifically ask "Better, Worse, About the same?"

    I think the new mirror is way too bulky for the delicate table on spindley legs. It looks too heavy sitting on it.

    Also, having a mirror sitting on the table, makes the console, with the bench under it, look like a lady's vanity dressing table in a living room and that makes it look out of place in the room.

    How do you feel about just using art on the wall above the table? Get a large art piece with an oval frame to add softness and arrange the other art you already have on the wall to make it all one large grouping. Maybe even add one or two other art pieces to the wall.

    The mirror is very nice. Can it be used on another wall? It looks like it would be perfect for an entryway. It could be used alone on another wall in the LR too.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks so much, Marti, Patricia & Bru!

    Dilly Dally, I don't think you're a downer, I want feedback! All feedback is good feedback! Thanks!

    Have tried artwork there several times & am always disappointed & end up putting a mirror back there. I don't know why that is, really! One thing I can tell you, I do have a very bad glare issue with the sun coming in from the window to the left.

    I *have* been concerned about it looking like a vanity w/a mirror over the console, however, so what you say makes sense to me.

  • 17 years ago

    I really like the ornate mirror and like how it looks with everything else you have there!

    I think as long as you don't accessorize it like a vanity it doesn't scream that imo.

  • 17 years ago

    I love the gold mirror too, wonder how it would look without the bench under the console with either a
    wicker basket or what you have now....

  • 17 years ago

    Now that someone else has broken the ice....
    My first thought also was "vanity". It's not the table itself, but rather the bench. You might try without the bench. You'll lose some of the "busyness" and the ornate mirror will stand out better without the competition. I like both mirrors, but can see the added benefit of the ornate mirror in your formal room. And so for that reason, I'd also remove the magazine basket from under the table.

  • 17 years ago

    I love the gilded mirror! However, I would remove the bench and put something else in its place like a big basket with cream hydrangeas. The bench looks like a piano bench and not suited for the space. Removing it would take away the "vanity" feel too!

  • 17 years ago

    The mirror is wonderful, but you do have a proportion issue.

    I would remove the three pictures altogether, hang the mirror, centering it and keeping it about six inches off the table (no more). The pictures throw the composition out of balance, and pull focus from the mirror.

    I would also replace the bench with something solid under the table...the basket of hydrangeas idea is a good one. Make sure that it is rectangular, wide and tall enough to fill the space, and not so deep that it gets in your way. If you have a small elegant chest of drawers lying around the house somewhere, you might trade it for the table and solve the problem that way. Or, if you like the look and can do without the drawers, make a tailored, full length cloth cover with pleats at the corners for the table and put a glass top on it.

  • 17 years ago

    I was reluctant to suggest removing the bench to take away the 'vanity' or 'church organ' feel that is has now, since I know it may be a necessary piece in the room. You may need the bench to pull out, for entertaining larger groups, and if the alternative is having your guests stand when visiting, or bulking up a tiny room with upholsterd pieces that are rarely used andy other time, then the bench has to stay of course.

    I still feel that the lovely ornate mirror is too overwhelming for the delicate table, and yet, that whole wall needs "more" on that end of the room. You say that there is a problem with glare from the windows with the mirrors there too.

    Are you opposed to trying a completely different furniture arrangment for the room? There may be a way to incorporate all the pieces that you love in a new arrangement that works beautifully. It is hard to judge this without pics of the whole room of course. You have georgeous furniture and sometimes just a little bit of tweaking with the arrangment can make a world of difference.

  • 17 years ago

    I think some people may be getting a "vanity vibe" because the mirror is sitting on top of the table -- like a vanity mirror would. I think if you hang it up, though, you'll get a different feel.

    But it's clearly not a vanity. ;-) You can underscore that fact even more by adding a few attractive books to your table -- or anything else that might give it more of a desk look.

  • 17 years ago

    Wow! Sheesharee, Enailes, Andee, Kmcg, B'smom, & Dilly, thanks so much! I have a lot to think about now, & am mulling over the ideas presented. I appreciate the feedback very much. I may just return it, but will take a couple of days to see what I can come up with first. Dilly, as far a rearranging the furniture goes, I don't think that will work. It took me so much time to come up w/this arrangement after experimenting w/so many other configurations that I just didn't like at all.

    Here's a pic w/out artwork & bench:

    {{!gwi}}

    Here's a slightly bigger console that I have. Don't think it would really make that much dif. though:

    {{!gwi}}

  • 17 years ago

    Hey auntjen, thanks for chiming in again! Yes, that may just be the issue. I should try hanging it before I dismiss it altogether. I need to go to HD to get some hardware & try that. Thanks again!

  • 17 years ago

    I'll be the voice of dissent here, but I like the clean lines of the "plain" mirror better. Take away the bench and I think the mirror allows the table to stand on its own, rather than be overwhelmed by the ornate mirror. Both mirrors are lovely in their own right, but for me, less is more.

  • 17 years ago

    With the larger gilded mirror, I would use the other table, which also has some curves to it like the mirror does, instead of the table that's presently there. The curves in both pieces would add cohesiveness to this arrangement that isn't felt with the straight lines of the first table. I would hang the mirror just a few inches above the surface, not prop it against the wall, and use the hydrangea arrangement below, without the bench. Accessorize the table with a lamp and some other objects, and it would look lovely.

  • 17 years ago

    I like the plainer mirror, too, as it seems to coordinate better with the other parts of the room I can see (chair).

    Even though you didn't ask, perhaps you could switch the bench under the console for two upholstered stools.... there are too many legs in that vignette.... and I would replace the ficus with a real tree or plant.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with nanny2a. Everything about the other table makes it a better fit with the ornate mirror - the curviness, the color, the slightly larger size, the ornate hardware. sometimes it is just the tiniest little details like that, that can add the *wow* factor to a grouping. The mirror hung on the wall and the green leafy plant under it sounds perfect.

  • 17 years ago

    Very nice SG. I like both consoles... the blue and white collection would look nice too clustered on top or underneath either one and would tie in with your other
    vase.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree about taking away the bench. The ornate mirror...no. The square mirror is a cleaner look. I like the square mirror with the art in the first post. The 3 blue jars might look cute under the table?

    If you do go with the large ornate mirror then the 2 lamps idea is the look your going for....maybe not at this time?

  • 17 years ago

    I liked it before you took down the pictures and took out the bench myself..and I thought both mirrors were nice but did like the more ornate one better if you were doing traditional..the other was more contempoary..

    when you remove too much it begins to look too sterile

  • 17 years ago

    the ornate mirror looks too heavy for that table with it's spindle legs and openness. The simple mirror looks a thousand times better to me.

  • 17 years ago

    Ditto on the ornate mirror I love it.. and I like the bench under the table also..
    Huggy

  • 17 years ago

    I want to say thanks to all of you who helped me out on this thread. I have decided to return the mirror, & I am concerned about getting it to the pack & mail store in one piece! I'll probably attempt to do this Friday.

    After carefully considering all of your comments, & moving mirrors & accessories around all day (oh, my aching back!) I have decided that I really agree w/those of you who see the ornate mirror as too top-heavy for the console. Even the somewhat larger console, I decided, is too delicate & wispy for it. Nothing I own has the needed heft to carry the piece visually, & style-wise, though I still find it quite fetching, it is probably not the best choice for me.

    Y'all are helping me to learn some valuable lessons! Again, thanks so much!

  • 17 years ago

    No, dear, thank YOU for letting us natter on about what is best for you. It's lovely to be asked.