Software
Houzz Logo Print
swim_team_mom

Do we need additional pump for solar? (2-story)

19 years ago

We are down to two very reputable companies. One solar company (Aztec) says that we will need a supplemental 1/2 HP pump in order for our solar to do it's job and effectively get the water up and over the top of our 2-story home. He says that our 1.5 HP pump is going to be quite taxed with having our Polaris wheel around to clean the pool (he says the Polaris probably won't even move). And our 2 water falls create even more demand. All that and solar too would be too much. His price: $5,396 for 6 12-foot panels, plus the supplemental 1/2 HP pump.

Solaron says that we absolutely have enough power within our pump, and that it's not necessary to spend more for an unnecessary pump. He tells us if we're concerned, just turn off the water falls. His price: $4,140 for 6 10-foot panels.

The price disparity is so big, that we're hedging towards Solaron, but I'm afraid of regretting it later if we don't have enough power.

My pool specs are 430 sq. ft. surface area/ 17,000 gallon pool, 18 ft. X 32 ft.

Do any of you think the extra pump is a necessary? Thanks!

Carol

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    You might want to consider the extra pump. A friend of mine had a similar setup to yours at her last house. When the solar ran, it sucked up so much of the pump power that the water coming out of the sheer descents was basically a trickle. (Well, he actually said something pretty funny that I won't repeat here. But when I told the story to my PB, they laughed so hard that they increased my pump to 2.5HP at no cost just to ensure there was not a trickle coming out of my sheer descent.)
    Christy

  • 19 years ago

    i have a large 32k pool 32k and have a 2-hp pump that drives the returns and solar. i also have a pool cleaner with a separate pump so the cleaner get's what it needs. i would think about having a separate pump for the cleaner and i bet you could keep the 1.5 hp pump. Also i'm in Folsom and used Solaron and they are good.

  • 19 years ago

    I would be concerned that you won't get enough water movement at the skimmer with the solar working off that pump too. I have a separate pump for waterfalls and a booster for my pool sweep. I also have a 1 1/2 for my pool that also runs my solar. I notice that with just the solar and filter on the same motor I don't get the same skimmer action with the solar on. I think it is smart to have another pump, just so you aren't having to mess with not enough pressure for the skimmer. We used Aztec and they were good. Also, don't know if it was a misprint, but Aztec was giving you bigger panels. You can always turn the solar down if it is too hot, but you can only get as much heat as you have panels. We got the most panels we could put on our roof and are happy about that. We swim earlier in the season than our neighbors and keep it about 88 degrees in the summer- no problem.

    Hope this helps.

    BTW- You might want to investigate a variable speed instead for all your pumps? Might not cost as much to upgrade at this stage of the game.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks! Yes, the fact that both companies have us set up with two different sized panels further complicates everything. I am still putting in calls to both companies, but have not been able to wheel and deal because the packages are different. I'm getting anxious because the summer weather is right around the corner.

  • 19 years ago

    There's a guy called Stu with Steiner's Solar Service.
    If I ever had any solar needs, I would call him and that would be the last call I'd make. Not to knock anybody else (I don't know them), but Stu is very passionate about the quality of his work. It's been several years since I've needed his services, but he's still out there playing the game in his classic step-side pick-up truck.
    The man lives for solar heating systems. I think he feels about solar the way some people feel about their Harley-Davidsons. Ever hear of solar panels coming loose and flying off a roof? Not on Stu's watch.

  • 19 years ago

    The best way to determine what is correct is to do a hydraulic calculation. You need to know the pump curve, solar panel specifications on recommended flow, legnth/size/elbows and height of the solar panels on the roof. As an example, I built my pump system to support 9 solar panels on a 2nd story roof. The pump is dedicated to the circulation (waterfalls are on a different circuit and a booster for the cleaner is plumbed to the discharge side of the circulation loop) Pool builder wanted to put in a 1 1/2 hp pump but my calcs said flow would be perfect with the 1hp unit (in addition to saving electricy costs it keeps pressure on the solar at a lower pressure). Short story is that the system works great! My own recommendation for your situation is if you add a pump, keep the original and dedicate it to the waterfall circuit and size the new one for the filter/solar loop.

  • 19 years ago

    Call someone who is familiar with the IntelliFlo series pumps - solar is right up the pumps alley. Also you can repalce the existing circulation pump you have and the IntelliFo will do both applications - it is a no brainer.
    Deek