Software
Houzz Logo Print
lhayes1976

Preventing heater damage??

17 years ago

It seems we actually got lucky and Jandy is going to honor our warranty and replace our heat exchanger. The technician who came to check the heater said that the auto chlorinator was the cause of our problems--something to do with gases causing the copper damage. He told us to start using one of those silly little floater things instead of our chlorinator (which our pool installer put in). This is fine with me, but are there other things we should be doing to extend the life of our heater. Would switching to the salt system be easier on our heater?

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    Hi love2weed.....the inline chlorinator should be downstream of the heater and a checkvalve should be installed between the chlorinator and the heater to prevent the backflow of highly concentrated chlorine water going back into the heater causing damage to the heat exchanger.

    I think this is pretty standard in the pool industry when inline chlorinators are used. With salt systems, the chlorine levels are not high enough to cause problems with the heat exchanger and therefore a checkvalve is not needed. However, I think it is still recommended to place the salt cell downstream of the heater....maybe some of the pool industry experts can weigh in here.

    Hope this helps!

  • 17 years ago

    Im not sure if its right or wrong but my salt system was just installed right before the heater.

  • 17 years ago

    I believe we do not have a checkvalve. The technician said something about our chlorinator not being installed properly. It this an easy fix, or should I just use the little floater for chlorine. I love the convenience of our chlorinator, but I love the heater more, esp this time of year.

  • 17 years ago

    love2weed-

    Installing a checkvalve is not a big deal if you have enough pipe between the chlorinator and the heater. A pool tech should be able to do this with a nominal cost for material and labor. This would allow you to continue to use the inline chlorinator and not damage the heater.

    coolpool-

    Not sure about the salt cell before heater....I had mine installed after the heater to be on the safe side.....hopefully some of the industry experts here can help.

  • 17 years ago

    love2weed,
    Ask your tech to install a chemical resistant check valve.
    It's not the chlorine that's the problem. The 3" pucks that are used for the chlorinators have a low PH (app. 2.9) and it's the acidic water that gets to the heat exchanger when the equipment is off and causes the problem.

  • 17 years ago

    coolpool08

    i think its a no no having the chlorinator cell before the heater.

  • 17 years ago

    coolpool,
    I think every SWG system recomends install after the heater. It does create hydrogen gas after all.

    Loveto,
    Wow I am really suprised that they replaced your heater for you, usually the idiot that installed it wrong has to bite the bullet.
    Golf is exactly right, follow his instructions.

  • 17 years ago

    This was a case of the Jandy rep. making a problem go away. I think you need to find a new pool builder / service company.

    And there is no 'think' to it, the chlorinator always goes:
    after the heater.

    Read the manual, any manual.

  • 17 years ago

    The chlorinator is after the heater, but the Jandy rep. said the checkvalve was not working properly and gases when the the pump was off actually corroded the heat exchanger. Which is strange, because we ran our filter 24/7 last summer. The pool installer disagrees with the rep. and claims this is not the reason. I only know that I am happy we are getting a replacement heat exchanger and really would like to keep this from happening again.

    We use to have an above ground pool and I always kept a chlorine tablet in the skimmer basket. Can I do this with my inground pool?

  • 17 years ago

    Jandy has always been very good about honoring warranties in gray areas. They went the extra mile in this case.

    Always inject chemicals downstream of all equipment. Although HTH advertises putting pucks in the skimmer, this is a bad long-term practice, especially when the pump is off. It will eat up the skimmer.