Software
Houzz Logo Print
wingit_gw

Waterline tile question w/pic

19 years ago

Thought I'd be able to chose a waterline tile for our pool remodel, but it's all boiling down to asking existing pool owners what their thoughts are - so here I am.

The plaster in the pool will be white and the newly redone deck is concrete. I thought some sort of smooth marine blue was going to be my choice, but now that I've seen all of the beautiful natural stone looking tiles available, I'm torn. One side says smooth tile is easier to keep clean - the other side is: Don't worry about it.

If any of you have a textured stone type tile - what has been your experience with keeping the lime/calcium buildup off the tile?

I welcome all thoughts - I'm choosing soon. Here is a shot of the pool undergoing rehab....

Comments (14)

  • 19 years ago

    I appreciate that - I've been concerned about the maintenance level on a matte/smooth vs. porous/textured finish, but in reality we had a glossy brown and white Mexican mosaic before and it still built up the deposits.

    I like the idea of blue-gray - sounds pretty and natural looking, too.

  • 19 years ago

    "Go with what you love and with the look you're trying to achieve. Don't sweat the maintenance - it hasn't been an issue for me."

    That is easy for those who don't have hard water to say!

    If you live in a place like Phoenix then maintenance is DEFINITELY an issue. We chose not to get a tile line, to go with PT all the way up and are sorry we did. If you have hard water I would definitely go with the high gloss tile, they are much easier to clean. We have the nastiest waterline, caked with calcium that is impossible to clean off. I would find out what the hardness of your water is then order your tile accordingly. Our neighbor has a high gloss tile and he says he has to get out and scrub every week or two, but he can get it off.

  • 19 years ago

    Well, yes - we have VERY hard water and had issues with the old tile (brown and white glossy mosaic 80's style) - so that is what I'm trying to keep in mind with this new tile.

    We have been told not to use pumice stone this time around on the tile either, which we couldn't do anyway with a textured version. Just trying to keep some peace in the family here and to that end, pick a tile that will be the easiest to maintain as possible. (If there is such a thing. LOL)

    Thanks for the hard water issue input - it's pertinent.

  • 19 years ago

    Even with the glossy tile you have to keep up with it year-round, even with just a scrubby and some vinegar, but it is definitely the easiest!

  • 19 years ago

    With the hard water, I think you should stick with smooth tile for the water line. Do you have any other areas where you can use the natural stone with texture?

  • 19 years ago

    Yes, maybe. Will look around - maybe I can get a firepit out of this - thanks for the idea. It will be smooth tile in the pool/spa, don't want to ask for more work at this point in time. Will post some pics when we're done (within the next week I hope...)

  • 19 years ago

    Are you allowed water softeners where you live? When our calcium gets a little high, we fill from the spigot connected to the water softener instead. We don't get any deposits on our matte finish tile.

  • 19 years ago

    We have PebbleTech, and you can void the warranty if you use water that has gone through a water softener. Our pool is new, hard water area (we use a softener for the water used inside the house), and we went with glossy tile - we just plan on having to clean it as part of our pool regimen.

  • 19 years ago

    Have you made a decision? The only real way to keep your tile looking good is through constant maintenance which really only takes a few minutes a day. We get the whole family involved and we start them young ;>D


  • 19 years ago

    Houseful, that's cute!
    Wingit, great view. I live in Florida and you don't get to see palm trees and mountains together.

  • 19 years ago

    Houseful - I have a 2 year old granddaughter I'll put to work - great idea! (Wonder if she can scrub the tile with floaties on her arms...she LOVES the water, so we'll have to work something out. Teach them early and all. Ha ha.)

    Black327 - well, it's a So Cal view and it is kind of neat to see palms and pines both against the mountains. Unless it's smoggy and then all bets are off...;-).

    Update on the waterline tile - finally chose the tile and it will go in on Wed 5/16, the plaster will follow on Friday - God willin' and the creek don't rise.

    The tile is NPTG Espana Blue - texture and depth, but smooth. We'll see how it all plays out. Will post more pix along the way.

    Here is a link that might be useful: NPTG Espana

  • 19 years ago

    Nice choice, wingit. I don't remember having seen that one when I built 1.5 years ago. I can't wait to see pics!!

  • 14 years ago

    Hey Wingit,
    I'm looking to possibly use the NPTG Espana Blue. Are you happy with it? Any chance you have any pictures of the pool with the tile??
    Would love to see.