Software
Houzz Logo Print
joanneswimsct

Help! Deck poured wrong; pitched toward pool

17 years ago

Hi gang!

We thought all was well last year when we finally installed our telescoping pool enclosure but nooooooo... Our PB insisted he had installed "millions" of our type of building when we questioned his decision to pitch our deck toward the pool. Our deck guy also questioned the PB but he was adamant that the deck be poured his way. The outcome? Pure c***. The enclosure is NOT set directly on the deck like the PB assumed so any time it rains, the water POURS into the pool from the deck surface as well as the building's roof. The water brings w/ it pollen, worms, dirt, tree buds, grass, etc. It is so disgusting... My question is aside from a lawsuit that we just don't have the heart, time, money, etc to go down that road unless there is no other way to correct the disaster does anyone out there have any great ideas? We've thought of a drainage system along the interior perimeter of the enclosure but have no experience w/ this. Our deck guy is willing to work w/ us but is afraid of winter freezes/spring thaws that may cause heaving. The enclosure measures approx 31'X 54' if that makes a difference. It is set on rails that have been screwed into the deck.We've considered caulking the rails to help keep some of the water out but there are gaps b/ the individual rails so we'd need something in addition the caulk. We also considered some sort of gutter system but since the modules telescope over each other the gutter would bang into the next module. I think our best bet is a drain system; anyone out there w/ experience???? Of course, it's pouring again and I spent 2 hours vacuuming the pool and sweeping the pool deck already today... The worms are the worst... Ugh...

Sorry for the long post; I hope it makes sense and I hope to hear back from you!

Joanne

Comments (16)

  • 17 years ago

    Since he didn't contract to do the patio, a lawsuit probably won't help. Why didn't you have him do the patio?
    Did your deck guy not have experience with pools? This just doesn't make much sense. Thats the downside off breaking up a contract,you end up with lots of finger pointing and no one to hold accountable.

  • 17 years ago

    joanneswimsct,
    Sounds really dumb. Never, ever seen a deck sloped totally toward the pool. STANDARD is 2%(1/4"/ft) slope away from the pool. Your PB should fix at his cost.
    If your state has a licensing board, you should start there. After that you should talk to the local DA. Sometimes they do sting operations and may already have received complaints. Good luck.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi guys
    According to the PB he assumed the enclosure would be flush to the deck as would a traditional stick building and he didn't want water pooling up against the walls. He again assumed incorrectly that the only water on deck would be from splashing so he said we would just squeegee the splash water into the pool if there was enough of it. The deck guy fought the PB on the pitch but as stated above was vetoed by the PB who said he knew what he was doing. After all was said and done, imagine our disgust when the first rain storm hit... We called the PB to let him know the result and asked him what we could do and his response was "gee, I guess I shouldn't have pitched the deck that way after all" We had the deck guy out during a huge downpour and he was also disgusted. He said if it was his pool he'd have no hesitation to sue. His advice was to dismantle the enclosure and rip out the deck and start again at the PB's cost. If we were squeamish about a suit his next best idea was some sort of drainage system. Again his concern is freezing over the winter. (We had planned on using the pool year round but after seeing the gaps in b/ the walls and the deck as well as the gaps b/ each module, we feel it'll be way too expensive. We'll be lucky to get thru Nov and reopen in Mar. Those winter months will allow for plenty of freezing opportunities...) Can we "paint" the trough w/ a water proof paint to keep it from freezing? I know drains are usually placed prior to decking but can a drainage system be put in after the fact? There are copious amounts of water; we'd like the drain to run the entire perimeter; how many spouts would you recommend to send the water out? Tresw, I don't know how much re pouring the decking outside the enclosure will help although that is one idea that the deck guy proposed. The water literally pours in off the walls; it sneaks in under the walls and drains in almost from inside after running under the bottom of the walls. Let me tell you, 34X54 feet of roof carries a s*** load of water...
    Well it rained again today so I plucked out more lovely worms and pumped more water out of the pool... No one told me about the many joys of pool ownership!
    Joanne

  • 17 years ago

    Might be able to change the coping to cantilever a little higher than the coping you have now and sloping it to the encloser, you can pour on top of the existing deck. your deck guy should be able to do this.

    One other option is to remove the coping and raise the pool beam, you can raise it 2 1/2" with no problems then pour a new deck ontop sloping it back.

    There is no easy way, and if your PB made the call to slope the deck the wrong way he should take care of the problem.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi rick k
    I understand what you're saying and raised the idea w/ my deck guy. We live in CT and he said we may not be able tp reliably bond 2 surfaces together due to freeze/thaw. I thought of laying non-slip tile on top w/ a heavier application of the tile "cement" poolside then lowering the "cement" height as we got to the enclosure??? If it were as easy as layering on top of the existing deck I would think the deck guy would have jumped at the idea... We have a vinyl pool; can we still raise the pool beam by 2 1/2 inches? I'd love an easy answer!!!
    Thanks for the feedback, everyone! Keep it coming!
    Joanne

  • 17 years ago

    It's the PB's decision, so he needs to correct it. I'd insist on having him break it all out and start over from scratch.

    Other than that, channel drains come to mind. You could saw cut just on the outside of the coping and install a channel drain around the perimeter of the pool. And you could also do the same around the structure. But I think the debris(and worms) would still gather at the front of the grate, but at least the water wouldn't drain into the pool.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pictures of channel drains

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks so much, tsunami, for taking the time to add the channel drain link. The deck guy and I have discussed it; he is to come out again this week to revisit the site. This am, my husband went out w/ the camcorder to record what it's like during a heavy rain storm just in case the PB thinks we're blowing things out of proportion! My husband is convinced that a lawsuit will drag on for years and we'll still be dealing w/ the problem during that time so we will try to come up w/ an alternative solution at the PB's cost. Thanks again to all who have solidified what we think and who we believe is at fault as well as the ideas you all came up w/.
    Joanne

  • 17 years ago

    Have you demanded that the PB fix the problem? You might try to let him know that you will go to the BBB as well as your city or county code enforcement and report it. I know our pool was inspected by our city office. Although they really didn't know what they were looking @, but there should be some liability there as well. I would hate for you to go to the expense of repairing it, without putting pressure on this guy. Maybe just a letter from an attorney would start the ball rolling. Sometimes the pressure is all it takes. I sure hope it works out for you.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi mneel
    We are now at the "blame game" stage; the PB blames the enclosure company for manufacturing a piece of c*** building, the deck guy blames the PB and we blame the PB as well. The PB is our GC and the same man who told me after my repeated questions to him during the build that if I didn't trust his judgement then I should fire him. He said he doesn't tell me how to do my job therefore I shouldn't tell him how to do his. At that point I said okay and now we have a big problem; go figure! I already have neighbors who hate us for installing the enclosure (they claim it's an ugly monstrosity) what's one more person to add to the list if we choose to sue?! We do have the installer coming back to fix a few little problems; he is aware of the water/deck problem and said he'd do his best to advise us of some options. I'll keep you posted!
    Thanks!
    Joanne

  • 17 years ago

    You say the Pb is your GC. Does that mean the deck man and the enclosure man are subs for the
    PB. Did you contract with him for the entire job? If so he is responsible and can be held accountable. Or if he recieved consideration to manage the subs, he can be held accountable. Who did you contract with and for what?

  • 17 years ago

    Joanne, Your husband is right, litigation is not the route to take.

    For the record, there are a lot of enclosed pools that have decks sloping towards the pool. This how the YMCA used to build indoor gutter pools. They could recapture the splash water and condensation plus keep water away from foundations. There are pools enclosed by aluminum structures that slope towards the pool inside the enclosure and away from the enclosure outside the pool. Some health depts didn't like this and so alot more are built using channel or area drains. In no case would you slope the deck that was outside of the enclosure towards the encloseure and pool.

    In any case there should have been a plan for drainaige. You can fix the problem with channel drains on both sides of the enclosure track. There are many sizes to choose from to fit the flow requirements.

    Putting in these drains will not be an easy task, but they will cost a lot less than litigation and be done sooner

    Fault might have to be shared to get the project complete.

  • 17 years ago

    Joanne, how big of a deal is it to disassemble and reassemble the enclosure? If it's not too bad, you might consider removing it and pouring a 6" curb on the decking (doweled into the decking), then setting the enclosure on top of the curb. You can put a bentonite water stop under the curb that will prevent any water from seeping underneath the curb (if bentonite gets wet it expands to fill any gaps).

    I understand what your PB is saying about not wanting to slope the decking towards the walls on the inside, but he should have asked for cut sheets on the enclosure before making the call on that. Also, the decking STILL should have been angled away from the OUTSIDE of the enclosure so that the enclosure would be sitting on the high point of the decking. If I understand you correctly, the decking outside of the enclosure is sloping towards the pool as well.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi tresw and renovxpt
    Thanks for your insite and questions...
    tresw: can we use that bentonite stuff under the rails now and in b/ them w/o taking it all down? Is it something like the expandable gunk we use to fill in gaps in the garage to keep the mice out? I asked the enclosure installer how expensive it would be to dismantle and he said "a lot". My husband wondered if we could just use a crane to lift the modules off the rails then saw cut/jack hammer out the decking under the enclosure. The decking outside the enclosure is pitched away except for an approx 6' wide perimeter that the enclosure "sits" on. If you want, I can take some pics of the rail system to better explain how it is laid out... You mentioned a 6' curb; is it 6' high or 6' wide? When the modules are open would we have trouble stepping over it?
    renovxpt: We would have had no problem w/ the PB pitching the deck toward the pool had he put in a drainage system OR checked first w/ the enclosure manufacturer to see if pitching toward was the correct way to go. He is our GC and subbed out the decking but not the installation of the enclosure; that guy came w/ the enclosure so to speak. I asked the manufacturing co. "hypothetically" how the deck should be pitched and was told away due to the fact that it is not sealed to the decking... A simple question that should have been asked in my opinion! The installer guy is returning in a few weeks to replace a few broken panels. He will take a close look at the problem and assess what can/could/should be done. That being said, are we correct to assume that the only one responsible is the PB? I'll keep you all posted...
    Thanks!
    Joanne

  • 17 years ago

    Joanne, I looked at a couple of websites for telescopeing enclosures (have never had one installed on ajob) and they claim to be "waterproof". It sounds like in your case the majority of the water entering the pool is coming from the roof of the enclosure rather than the patio around it.

    It also looks like some of these enclosures have ways to channel the roof water.

    Good luck with this tough issue.

  • 17 years ago

    Hi renovxpt
    I don't recall if ours ever claimed to be water proof or not but today we had a brief thunderstorm and while the outer perimeter of the patio never got completely soaked, it wasn't long before water started pouring in under the enclosure. Specifically from the support pieces (which remind me of gutters on my house) as well as the breaking mechanisms that surround the rails.
    Do you recall the sites that showed a way to channel the water off the roof? That might be helpful to see; it may work for us...
    Thanks!
    Joanne