Software
Houzz Logo Print
rosieo_gw

Going from induction to maybe gas?

14 years ago

I've had my induction range for 6 months. I love so many things about it. I love how I can boil a pot of water nearly instantly. I love how I can keep it low enough to melt chocolate or hold a gentle simmer. I love how easy it is to keep the glass top clean. And I really love how responsive it is.

But we had an electric surge or something and the cooktop blew out. Luckily it's still under warranty because the repair guy said the parts were going to be a thousand dollars.

Talking to the repair guy was eye opening and discouraging. Apparently induction cooktops are very sensitive and prone to needing expensive repairs. When something goes wrong with them, it's never just a $50 service call.

I'll be without a stove for at least a week waiting for the parts to come in and to reschedule the repairman. And then just wait for the next time it gets flakey, or goes out altogether.

I'm seriously thinking I want to sell the thing (after it's repaired) and get a gas range. I'm curious if any of you have bought gas after having induction (or wished you had) and what you looked for or ended up with. I've never had gas before and don't really know what to look for.

I only have a 30" space and can't afford a top of the line range. Any tips on what to shop for or what to avoid?

Comments (9)

  • 14 years ago

    Sounds like hooey. Get a surge protector of some sort on it sure, but you just had a bad part. Electronics tend to fail early or not at all. (unless you drop them...)

    When I remodeled a few years ago I took out a fully functional induction cooktop that was made in 1983. I had bad wiring in my house causing all the lights to pulsate when I was using the cooktop. Should have gotten that fixed. Eventually had a fire where the cooktop plugged in. Major surges from that incident while diagnosing the electrical problem. Lost tons of electronics from that. Not my cooktop though.

    Anyway, gas is a lot of fun to cook with. You'll enjoy it. Flames!

  • 14 years ago

    I don't know of anyone else who has had a similar issue at all with induction, (and I know a lot of folks with it) but I do know ones who have had issues with their telephones or computers due to power surges. Whole home surge protection is probably available from your utilty company. It should be de rigueur in this modern age of electronica. The same thing could have happened to your 60" screen TV or gaming console or microwave as well. It's no reason to shy away from having induction, despite the repair persons scare tactics.

  • 14 years ago

    Do you have a natural gas line running to your kitchen/stove area? If not, having one run will be an expense to consider. Gas cooking has its drawbacks, you won't get nearly-instant boiling water and on many gas stoves simmering can be a bit difficult.

    Although I haven't used induction, I went from an electric stove to gas when we bought this house and it took a bit to get used to, everything seemed easier with the electric stove. And it took my husband forever to figure out how to make a pot of rice on the gas stove without burning it or cooking it to death. lol

  • 14 years ago

    I have a friend who's gas cook top BLEW UP. The entire cook top blew straight out of the counter top, while she was standing nearby. Then three of the burners caught fire - we're talking flames 3 feet high. She had to turn off the gas at the main valve. This was caused by something to do with a faulty manifold (but out of warranty). It sounds scarier than heck to me! She's lucky she or her kids (one of which was sitting across the counter) wasn't hurt or worse.

    Her repair bill is going to be over $1000. Another reason I love my induction.

  • 14 years ago

    What that repairman told you just does not "Jive" with the info we see in Garden Web about Induction.

    You will have to search , "Long & Hard" to find posts about induction failures, I do recall one, maybe two??? but they are rare compared to those of us that have Induction.

    You did not list the manufacturer of the range, but if you do, I will be glad to search for "similar failures" and report back.

    If you've never had gas, you will need to learn to beware of hot handles, cleaning will definitely be harder, You will have to learn to cook by looking at the flame, rather than selecting a setting, like you do with the induction.

    (I know, I know), somebody's gonna "pop in" and say "Watch the Food" but be honest, have you ever seen Anybody cook with gas and not look at the flame, I sure can't recall anybody doing that. They watch the food whilst it's cooking but when they go to adjust the heat, they always watch the flame!

    So just a few of the changes you will have to make, and more than likely caused by somebody that just doesn't know what they are talking about!

    Gary

  • 14 years ago

    I watch the food. And I totally disagree with ghostlyvision - gas is soooooo much more responsive and easier to cook on than any of the five non-induction electric ranges I owned prior to my current kitchen.

    But to the OP....I would give your induction range another chance. It's too big an investment to toss out, especially while still under warranty. But I'd be really PO'd to be without a range for a week! My gas oven pooped out last week, and it took less than 24 hrs for the needed repairs, under the dealer's extended warranty.

  • 14 years ago

    Some geographical locations are more prone to power issues. Ask your electric company if they can surge suppress the whole house on the outside. Sometimes its cheap (like a few dollars a month) and its permanent.

    I'm saying ask about it cause the alternate is to buy a higher voltage surge suppressor/voltage regulator (looks like around $300) and have it installed by an electrician. It will likely need to be replaced every 5-7 years - depending on how its made and how many electrical issues you have.

  • 14 years ago

    I cook with gas and love it, but if I were you, I would invest in a whole-house surge protector. It will protect all your appliances. We lost several appliances: air conditioner, refrigerator 2 tv's and a wine cooler over 3 years. I researched a bit and found the info on a whole-house surge protector. The parts were $100, install was $100 (unless you have tons of tech equipment, you don't need the $1000 version.) That has been 3 years and we have not had one issue since.

  • 14 years ago

    I'm with gharborwa and others who recommend a serious surge protector.

    I cook with gas and always have, so am very used to it. But I wouldn't recommend it to someone who hasn't, particularly if they've been comfortable with induction -- and that goes double for someone in your position with a new, under-warranty stove. Even if gas comes to your house already, it has a much more serious safety downside than electric stoves, and definitely needs serious ventilation. There will be a learning curve.

    To survive the week without a cooktop, get a portable induction unit (I have and love the Max Burton 6200, available lots of places for less than $100). It's not expensive, and has many uses beyond backup when the stove's out -- enabling you to deep-fry on a porch or outdoors, acting as a warmer for buffets, etc.

    My induction unit sits permanently on a flat aluminum cookie sheet on the back left burner of my gas cooktop, where vapors rise right into the not-very-powerful vent fan. It replaces a nearly useless little "simmer" burner, and is in use constantly, for boiling and for using a pressure cooker (way more precise control than our flaky-pressure burners).

    If I were to have the kitchen of my dreams, the stove would be induction with one big gas burner (mostly because I'm too old to become as skillful with sauteing, omelets, and other open-skillet jobs on induction as I am with gas).

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio