I would probably get the chairs in one finish to let the table have more emphasis.

I'm thinking the same...have the chairs in one finish (black) and leave the 2-tone for table only.

Yep, I vote solid black chairs also. The table top would be the accent.

it depends on how much attention you want to draw to the chairs..the two tone will draw attention but will likely be beautiful..also depends on how much busyness you have in the room..two tone will add visual clutter if the room is cluttered..but will be stunning if it is sparse

Thanks for the responses! You know, I'd not even considered the fact that doing the chairs in a two-tone would detract from the table, but you are absolutely right, palimpsest. And ronbre, your point of it creating visual clutter is well taken. These will be in an informal dining area off the kitchen, not in a room of their own, so keeping the chairs all black will likely be the best choice. It gives a bit more polished look, too, I think.

I appreciate the feedback. Now I need to stop dithering and place my order. :-)