Software
Houzz Logo Print
tvalenti_gw

Wrong Size Cabinets - what 'normally happens'

18 years ago

We have a custom cabinet maker and we are in the final stages on install. Two of our cabinets - appliance cabinet and the hood were made to the wrong size. The hood is 2 inches smaller then it should have been - it is now a 34" piece over a 36" cooktop! The microwave was not cut for our inset microwave.

I have written specification for the hood and the appliance list email so there is written proof on how they should have been. The cabinet maker is trying to deny anything is wrong.

What normally happens when cabinets are made incorrectly?

Comments (14)

  • 18 years ago

    Normally, they get replaced. Your cabinet maker obviously doesn't want to take responsibity for his mistake. It's good that you have written specifications - you need to get stern with him - I hope you haven't made your final payment to him yet.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks - that is exactly what I figured - final payment is not paid.

    We get stern - and he gets nasty at this point...

  • 18 years ago

    I guess that nasty is a negotiating tactic to not take responsibility for his mistakes. I also guess that your cabinet maker is not going to be your next best friend so you just have to ignore it and make him stick to his part of the bargain. What a drag! Whatever happened to the customer being right?

  • 18 years ago

    Welcome to the club! Damn, I didn't want to let anyone else in!

    Fern said it best- he's not going to be your next best friend- that's priceless! :>)

    When it FIRST happened to me, I felt as bad for the kitchen company as I felt for myself, then when it happened with the carpenter they hired to fix the cabinets that came wrong the first and then the second time, #1 I couldn't believe it, #2 I was SO disappointed when the carpenter tried the 'that's the way they were supposed to be' route. Luckily, my kitchen company did have it in writing. Carpenter also fairly quickly admitted his mistake - but I still haven't seen the 'fourth' attempt at my cabinets yet, so not holding my breath- but I have really lost all sympathy/worries for the money the company must be losing- and no longer have guilty feelings about 'having to put them through this'. AND, just my own take on this, firm doesn't have to mean getting nasty in return- play the high card! Holding off final payment is definitely an ace in the hole.

  • 18 years ago

    He's trying to bully you into accepting his mistake, it costs him money to redo it. Do not accept the wrong size pieces, he has to make it right or you take it to court, you win..his loss.

  • 18 years ago

    I will tell you this: a tape measure can't be wrong. And the written specs can't be deviated from.

    Just keep ASKING him. "How can you possibly expect me to deny reality?"

    or "You want me to accept a cabinet that is the wrong size?"

    Or stand there and look at him and don't say ANYTHING.

  • 18 years ago

    The previous posters are giving great advice. I'd add that in our order of Omega Dynasty there was 1 wrong size cabinet and 6 warped glass doors. Without a question or evil eye, the cabinet supplier and builders took the bad ones and replaced them with acceptable products. These problems happen and good business people replace the inferior products without charge or hassle.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks - these all help a lot.

    If for some small chance the cabinet builder agrees to rebuild the cabinets that are incorrect do they keep the wrong ones there till they make new ones in most cases? One of the cabinets that needs to be remade is the one holding our oven and microwave. Waiting weeks for new ones to be made and installed is just too much. At the same time we feel that they would even rip them out then just abandon the job.

  • 18 years ago

    Try not to let the desire to have it all done and over with overwhelm you and influence you unduly to do something you normally would not choose to do- ie accept the cabinets as is.

    I am 'living' with the original wrong cabinets- couldn't wait any longer to put stuff in- thank heavens or I'd still be waiting, but the second and third tries got sent back, still waiting for lucky #4!

    I am concerned by your statement, "If for some small chance...". Did he deliver what he was supposed to? Why wouldn't you expect him to correct his mistake? Did you purposefully prevent him from doing his job properly? Why is it your responsibility to live with the 'wrong' cabinets?

  • 18 years ago

    The reason we are concerned is he is trying to deny there is an issue even though we have written documents proving they were made incorrectly. The cabinets will never get fixed if we can't get him to admit they were not made to plans.

  • 18 years ago

    That is so unfortunate. I'm shaking my head, because what a PITA during an already stressful time. Regardless of the plans and what was said and done, I can't believe they wouldn't want to fix them to make you happy.

    I too had the wrong size hood cabinet. It came down way too far. I had talked about this with my KD, but once it got built it was made about a foot too long and I would hit my head on it. They re-ordered new panels and re-built it no questions asked.

    I also had a problem with my fridge cabinet. Couldn't open the doors on my cabinet-depth fridge. Called the company up, they sent two of their best guys, we talked about my options, decided on one, and they have since fixed it.

    It's been a pain to have to do all of this, but the point is they have been very agreeable and so have I. I still owe them 10% and will pay them the full 10% and not ask for any credits, because I've been satisfied with their service and solutions.

    What to do? Have you tried another route, like asking what they propose? I'm so sorry. I hope you find a solution quickly.

  • 18 years ago

    tvalenti - there's no reason to give him back the "bad" cabinet until the new one arrives - he has no use for it - if it hadn't already been installed it might be reasonable, but since it's in place I would not rip it out.

    Why do you think there's only a small chance that he'll fix the problem? I hope it isn't necessary, but threats of legal action should bring him around. You've got the documentation on your side. Hopefully, he'll calm down and come to his senses and do the right thing.

  • 18 years ago

    tvalenti - I reread your original post and I may want to amend my previous post. You said that the oven cabinet was not cut properly for your microwave. Is it possible he could fix that cabinet or reuse some of it rather than building a complete new one? If so, it might be reasonable for him to take it back and fix it.

  • 18 years ago

    Normally, the cabinet company takes it back and redoes it, especially if they or the custom cabinet maker did the final measurements.

    In our case, we triple measured everything, and the salesman came out himself and remeasured everything. We still ended up with one base cab and one upper cab that didn't fit because we had to change the thickness of a short pony wall in the middle of reframing(this was after measuring and ordering, and while the cabs were being made). No one caught this mistake, and my cab guys offered to take them back and redo them.

    There were other slight errors and changes elsewhere, so I agreed to compromise...if they fixed the other things, I would take the upper and lower cab and reorder some new ones. I was able to use them in the basement laundry room, and everyone was happy. My salesman didn't have to bite the expense, and he ended up throwing in a bunch of other stuff free out of gratitude.