Software
Houzz Logo Print
jbsb_gw

North Dallas Builder Suggestons

16 years ago

Hi All,

Been reading all of the threads pertaining to PBs in the DFW area. I have many questions but I should probably start by asking for recommendations, feedback, etc.

So far we've met with Robertson, Hobert, Riverbend Sandler and Anthony & Sylan.

We told Robertson we'd like very simple and under 30K. We met with them and sent our plot plan. We didn't hear back and we emailed them asking if we could see the design he was working on along with pricing. They did not respond.

I called Hobert in Frisco twice. The first call I was told my name would be given to someone and they would call me back. After 4 days I called back and the lady was very apologetic and assured me she would have someone call me back before the end of the day. No call.

Riverbend Sandler needs a soil sample and already said we'll need to get the soil treated because he could tell by the trees that were growing nearby that the trees typically thrive in clay. He's already made several attempts an upselling us and said "we're probably looking at a minimum of 40K."

The guy we met today from Anthony & Sylan seemed to be the most personable, upfront with pricing, etc. He told us typically how much chlorine, salt & ozone pools typically cost, what parts typically wear out, how much they are to replace, etc. Seemed very honest and upfront.

Based on what we've encountered so far, we like Anthony & Sylan the best. Does anyone have positive/negative feedback on them as a company? I realize a salesperson job is to sell us a pool. I'd like to hear real world experience good or bad.

Thanks in advance.

Comments (14)

  • 16 years ago

    I assume you're referring to Anthony Sylvan. They are a national volume builder with a not-so-great reputation in many areas of the country. They will build you a pool for 30k, it's up to you, but I would avoid them at all costs if it were me. I'm sure their salesman is great, their product, that could be a different story.

    I've heard decent things about Robertson. Riverbend Sandler is very good despite your experience so far. If you don't do a spa and don't have major soil issues you should be able to build a decent pool for around 30k, probably a little higher. If you want a spa that 40k number is accurate, if not low.

  • 16 years ago

    gawebber,
    Thanks for the reply. I've heard good things about Robertson and Riverbend Sandler as well. I'm looking forward to hearing back from RS on their design.

    Do you have any experience with Anthony & Sylvan? The BBB rated the one in Carrollton an A+. Why would you avoid them?

  • 16 years ago

    I had the same exact experience with Hobart in Frisco. I called them and they never called back until 6 months later when I already had a pool.

    Riverbend was one of my final two choices. I ended up choosing a smaller builder primarily based on design.

  • 16 years ago

    Ignore the BBB ratings. Just because they have an A+ does not mean anything. BBB is a joke.

  • 16 years ago

    If you Google Pool Builder Dallas TX some of the first names that come up are Anthony Sylvan and Blue Haven. They are national builders that build in many cities. Some cities they're okay, most they're not. I haven't used them personally, but I've read enough bad things to stay away. My neighbor used Blue Haven, had a problem after the pool was installed and is getting the run around.

    I would go with a local custom builder who will work with your budget. 30k isn't bad but it's a basic pool, you're not going to get any upgraded features such as custom decking or PebbleTec plaster or anything like that. You're going to get aggregate decking and white plaster. And no spa. That's fine if that's what you want.

    Don't just look at designs and cost, look at the materials and processes that each company uses. What's their steel schedule? Plumbing schedule? What equipment are you getting? What about if they hit rock? Do they re-route sprinklers? How do they apply their gunite? Etc... There are so many factors that go into choosing a builder.

    Riverbend was my 2nd choice. They had the best design but lost out because I felt I wasn't getting the quality I was with another builder, and their price un-negotiated was higher.

  • 16 years ago

    See if Paul Miller will build in your area.

    You may also try calling my pool builder but I don't think he goes that far. Seahorse Custom Pools-ask for Bob Bucanan and tell him Greg sent you.

  • 16 years ago

    We understand that we're getting a basic pool - that's what we'd like. I didn't want to start asking the more detailed questions until we picked a reputable builder and this feedback helps.

    I've had enough people tell me to avoid Blue Haven and everything I've read supports it.

    It does seem that every builder has it's fair share of dissatisfied customers so it's hard to sift through who the better builders really are.

    Is there a way to PM or email so I can ask more specific questions?

  • 16 years ago

    There are several considerations to make. One is who will treat you fairly, honestly and provide a structurally sound construction, and the other is assuming all the first what will the pool cost to operate including maintenance, electricity, chemicals, and routine replacement of parts.

    A well built energy efficient pool can easily cost $100.00 per month less than a "minimally" constructed pool. Once this is factored in it often pays dividends to spend a bit more on the front end, especially if you intend to remain in the home 5 or more years.

    That said, Anthony Sylvan can meet the first half requirements in many cases, but it is dependent upon the local rep more than the company. On the second half, you would need to provide the specs, as that is not the pool they typically build.

    One GREAT company to check out is Southwind Pools. They will be a bit over your 30k number, but will build it correctly for longevity and energy efficiency.

    Lots to consider, best to remember that what ever you do you need to spend "enough". because anything less will cost you much more than you bargained for.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Poolinfosite.com

  • 16 years ago

    paradigmdawg,
    Thanks for the info. I'll give them a call and see what they have to say. Much appreciated.

  • 16 years ago

    Funny coincidence: my husband just texted me at work to say that he was talking to our neighbors who had a pool installed a few years ago and said to avoid Blue Haven pools at all cost.

    The reports on them aren't looking like sunshine!

  • 16 years ago

    jenn.in.dfw,
    Are you guys looking to have a pool built too?

  • 16 years ago

    This site does not allow for PM's. May want to try troublefreepool.com if you want to be able to send PM's.

  • 16 years ago

    Jbsb: we're looking to build a pool within the next year, just doing some preliminary research now. Some companies we will probably get bids from:

    Platinum
    Tahitian
    Hobert
    Gold Medal
    Riverbend Sandler
    Southernwind

  • 16 years ago

    jenn.in.dfw

    We're going to check with a few neighbors in our subdivision and see who they used. In addition, we're going to call:

    Paul Miller Custom Pools
    Leisure Living
    Southernwind
    Seahorse Custom Pools

    I'll report back to this thread once we hear back from them.