Software
Houzz Logo Print
my3mutts

Please help with our 'Layout with a View' floor plan!!!

16 years ago

I'm new at posting online, but we are in real need of some of the planning advice on this forum that I've been admiring from afar for months now!!! We moved into our house a few years ago and are just getting started remodeling the kitchen, which is original to the house (1991). We are going with new cherry cabinets from a local custom cabinetmaker, new countertops (soapstone or granite, still undecided), new lighting, and new flooring (probably continue the adjoining oak floors into the kitchen). We will not be making any structural changes, and for budgetary reasons will keep the current range (about 5 yrs old) and possibly the 2 yr old dishwasher. I hate the way the refrigerator fits so it has to go in favor of a cabinet depth one in black or maybe stainless (another design dilemma but not as permanent)!

We are having major problems deciding on a floor plan. The kitchen is hard to plan around-it's spacious enough but very broken up with large windows and 3 doors. Actually the whole house, kitchen included, was built with an eye toward the lovely view out of our back windows. We are on a hill and you can see miles over trees to a skyline view of our capital city and mountain ridges beyond, and the sunsets are spectacular. So when designing we're willing to make sacrifices to preserve our current view from the kitchen table.


As far as we can see there are two possibilities - 1. keep current layout and just update everything. Pros: keeps current efficient working triangle, less expensive, and I enjoy having the range on a island facing the view while cooking. Cons: not gaining any needed working counter space, range choices limited in future to downdraft Jenn-Air, also harder to figure in microwave placement and trash base cabinets without losing any needed storage space.

- 2. we can move the refrigerator to where the desk area is now and box it in along with a short run of cabinets alongside, move the stove to the current refrigerator wall, and have a smaller island that's all working space. Pros: can install an outside vent hood and we gain a lot more counter space. Cons: distance between the fridge and range and the fridge and sink will be about 12 feet each. That seems long. But maybe ok with a prep sink in the island? We intend to be here for a while but we don't want to impact any future resale with an unworkable floor plan. I'm not even sure how we would feel about all that walking.

Anyway we are at an impasse and are looking for additional ideas or thoughts to help us decide. It's just my husband and myself (daughters are grown and on their own) and we mainly prepare vegetables and salads for meals, no real gourmet cooking. The current Jenn-air is vented outside and is adequate for the type of cooking we do, so that is not a big consideration.

Thank you for any advice you can give!!!

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    It would help us give some ideas if you could post a layout of the kitchen. It doesn't have to be anything fancy, but will allow us to visualize what you have to work with.

  • 16 years ago

    It sounds like you live in a great area! The view sounds wonderful!

    It's really difficult to give advice without actually seeing the layout of the floorplan and the surrounding rooms. Could you possibly post one? You don't need anything fancy...just some graph paper, a pencil, and a digital camera or scanner. You can get the graph paper for free online. Search on "graph paper" and many sites offering free graph paper will be on the first search results page.

    Be sure to label everything...widths of walls/windows/doorways and the distances b/w those walls/windows/doorways.

    Check out the "Layout" post in the "Read Me" thread.

    Welcome! Enjoy the ride!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Read Me If You're New To GW Kitchens!

  • 16 years ago

    I'm sorry, I thought I had included the link, let me try again! Hope this works...

    Here is a link that might be useful: Kitchen Pictures

  • 16 years ago

    Sorta stumped, actually. It feels like the table space should be where the ref is and the kitchen should be the rest of the room.

    A few questions...
    the great view would be out the ref wall (if there was a window?) and if not there, then where?
    If you sit at the table, what's them windows?
    Do you have to have a table in the kitchen? Or just seating for 2?
    Which way do the ceiling joists run?

  • 16 years ago

    {{!gwi}}

    I hate being stumped. This is one alternative drawn right on top of the existing layout. The only building thing )that I know of) is reversing the swing of the door leading to the deck.

  • 16 years ago

    bmorepanic-
    Thanks so much for trying to brainstorm, this one has had us stumped for months now! Your plan would solve a lot of our problems, unfortunately in the dinette area the existing five windows are almost floor to ceiling (the sills are only 18" from the floor).

    I agree, in our kitchen seating was given prominence by the builder, and the working area not so much...

    Lets see if I can explain the view situation - the dinette area faces the front of the house and the view is in the back. The dining room has two walls of windows, and if you're seated at the kitchen table you have a direct view over the dining room table through them and also through the kitchen door which is full glass. The windows around the table look out over the front yard and the neighborhood. A window on the refrigerator wall would look directly at our next door neighbors' house and deck, which isn't that far away. We do like having a big table in the kitchen because we tend to relax there and it's my favorite spot in the house to sit. Also, my parents spend time here and the big table is nice to have then. (Oh, you asked which way the ceiling joists run - it's front to back...)

    If we are stuck with the original two ideas which do you think would be the best? Thanks for the help!

  • 16 years ago

    For me, I'd go in front of the windows anyway,but I'd probably be happier with cart parking in the window area and would leave that end blank.

    I'm kinda of sweeby's persuasion that dining rooms are meant to be used. If you aren't using the dining room and its got some of the best view, I'd try to figure that out first. If you can use the dining room, I'd see what it would take to open the wall to the dining room more to access the view.
    If you want the view, the other obvious question is: Have you looked at trading the dining room and kitchen?

  • 16 years ago

    The problem w/your current kitchen/dinette arrangement is there is very little space for everything that has to go in the kitchen and for what goes on in the kitchen. The kitchen is the busiest room in the house and to shortchange it is doing it a disservice.

    Your current setup with a range in the island with very little walk space in behind it (36") and only 9" of counter behind it (instead of 24") is that it will be dangerous, especially if you have children. There's also a narrow walkway in front of the range (37") near the sink where it will be busy.

    You only have two access points to the kitchen, both are narrow and both are around the range...the most "dangerous" appliance in a kitchen. I would much rather have the sink in the island in this situation (well, really, in all situations...I really don't like cooktops/ranges in islands or on peninsulas...safety, functionality, aesthetics, and venting effectiveness.)

    Oh, and when you're short on space, I would think twice about corner appliances or corner sinks b/c they take up a lot of wall and counter space. Just MHO!

  • 16 years ago

    bmorepanic - I don't want to give the impression that we don't use our dining room, because we actually use it a lot. Our house is where the extended family gathers for holidays and special occasions, and that usually means 14+ people for dinner. At other times the table is used for projects or jigsaw puzzles, anything that needs a large flat surface. It's so nice to have someplace where you can leave these things set up for extended periods. I was glad you mentioned opening up the space between the two rooms because we had been thinking the same thing but hadn't added it to our list yet. I'm doing that now.

    buehl - that's an interesting idea - having the main sink on the island. Does the dishwasher have to be located directly next to the sink or would it be ok in it's present location? If we moved the sink then we could move the range to the same wall as the fridge. There would be 18" between the two appliances, and a whole run of counter space to the right of the range. Do you think this layout might work? It's something we hadn't thought of...(One problem I can see is that we'd lose a 36" wall and base cabinet and I don't know where I could make that storage space up)

    Thank you both for your help!