Software
Houzz Logo Print
carajon

Steps, lights and solar - advice please?

16 years ago

We finally signed our contract for a pool, but I am still waffling on steps, lights and solar. I'd so appreciate any thoughts!

We are in upstate NY and have decided on a 20x40 vinyl lined Pacific pool with a 3' bluestone deck (and coping) and lawn around that. Regrettably we will not be installing an automatic cover due to the cost. The liner will be 27mil blue granite with no border design. Originally we were going to do the wedding cake steps inside the pool with a matching vinyl liner for a nice, clean look. But I keep hearing bad things about liners over steps. So we are now leaning towards the thermoplastic steps instead. Our options are the corner steps or steps that extend outside the pool rectangle (does that make sense?): either 6 ' or 8' straight steps or 10' Roman steps. The thermoplastic (I think?) steps come in white, blue or grey marble or blue or grey granite. So here are my step questions:

1. Any thoughts on placement and width of steps? Do steps inside the pool perimeter interfere with the use of the shallow end? Does it matter if we do the 6' vs the 10'? I'd love to hear how others like (or don't like) the step placement and size they chose....

2. I am really concerned about how the plastic steps are going to look with the liner. Does anyone have a blue granite liner with plastic steps? Any thoughts on what might look best? (Of course Pacific's blue granite liner does not match their blue granite steps!!!).

3. Anyone have anything positive to say about vinyl lined steps?

Regarding lights - we don't want to spend more than necessary but don't want to regret our decision later. We are not really interested in lots of color options, but would like the pool to be pleasant when it is lit up (I don't want it to look like an airport runway). Is one LED light sufficient?

And finally - solar. We have solar domestic hot water, and were going to tie into that system for pool heating, but have discovered that because the pool is going to be over 50' from the house, running the piping will be very expensive. So now we are considering the solar mats (we have plenty of space). Our solar guy gave a quote of $4000 for a solar mat system for our pool, which seems somewhat high to me. Does this sound high? Can we simply buy and install one of these systems ourselves?

Thanks thanks thanks for any thoughts or advice!!!!

Comments (2)

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Carajon,

    We are getting ready to break ground on a vinyl lined pool any day now in SW Michigan. This will be our second such pool. Our first, had liner over stairs. It was wonderful. I had a difficult time finding a contractor in our current area who had experience with this type of construction. We finally found one who has 37 years worth of experience and an outstanding reputation. He is traveling approximately 40 miles to take on our project. I just could not live with the molded plastic stairs. We will break ground any day now. I will post some pics as soon as possible. Best of luck to you.

  • 16 years ago

    Thermoplastic steps, IMHO, are better than liner over steps for a few reasons. First, when the liner gets replaced in 10 years or so, it will be less costly. Second, they take the pounding from feet, vac heads, brushes, and other pool tools. Third, they can have step jets installed.

    When liners are replaced, getting a liner to be tucked in correctly and neatly with a liner over configuration costs more for the liner and depends on the measuring skill of the technician and the liner manufacturer. Often, the liner is slightly smaller and is expected to stretch into the corners. This can leave small gaps in the corners and edges. A pool brush or vac head can poke a hole.

    If you have a dog that likes to swim or hang out on the steps, the animal's nails are known concerns. I also have a raccoon that lives nearby that likes the pool. I've seen him use the pool on a few occasions and it uses the steps. I'm no expert on 'coon behavior but since it's been late at night and my dogs are in the house, I have no problem with it.

    I like my step jets. When I turn them on with the pool heater, I find it very relaxing.

    When liners age, they shrink. This doesn't help the liner over steps configuration any. If step jets are there, there will be a puckering around the jet.

    Replacement liners cost more to make. They can be a PITA to install too. I charge extra for that.

    Underground water can cause the liner over steps to float slightly out of position and it isn't always easy to move it back.

    Thermoplastics aren't without issues either but I have found that when they are installed correctly, they last and last. The worst issue I have found is that sometimes a gasket needs replacing, be it on a step jet or where it meets the liner.

    Improper setting of the steps or lack of prep for the area can cause a loss of support, exerting unequal pressures. This can create a crack that is difficult/costly to repair. Then again, this can happen anywhere, not just the steps.

    I am not a big Solar fan in my geo (NJ) due to winterization related issues. I have seen too many not get properly drained and result in freeze cracks.

    Ground installations present landscaping issues, trip hazards and, depending on how they are laid out and supported, snow load issues.

    We have no idea what skills you have so asking us if you can do it right is not something I would be comfortable answering.

    I will say this though. Buying anything on the web may save some coin if you plan on doing it yourself but you can't bring your own steak to the Outback Steakhouse and expect them to serve it to you. If I didn't sell it, I won't install it because I could be held responsible.

    I personally prefer a gas fired heater and solar cover to warm a pool and to help keep it warm.

    A single LED fixture will not be enough for a 20 x 40. I would expect two as a bare minimum or three for an even glow to be needed.

    Hope this helps.

    Scott