Software
Houzz Logo Print
ashburngirl

Please vote and help me decide

15 years ago

I want to get started on my family room and the first thing I want to do is decide on the seating arrangement but had to step back and decide on the TV location before getting to seating. And I'm stumped at this point. Here are my options for the TV location with advantages/disadvantages.

Option1 - next to FP

Advantages

1. TV has a greater visibility, can be viewed from the kitchen/breakfast area where we hang out quite a bit.

2. Room feels more roomier and allows for extra love seat which we need badly as we entertain a lot and need that extra seating.

Disadvantages

1. Is it getting too crowded next to the FP?

{{!gwi}}

Option2 - directly across from window

Advantages

1. TV will have its own wall, so FP wont get influenced by it

2. Since the old TV was at this location for few years, I got bored of the setup and wanted to change the orientation of the room.

Disadvantages

1. Cannot be viewed from the kitchen/breakfast area

2. Glare from the window across makes the day time viewing impossible(had to go through this for few years with our older TV)

3. Not much room left to add more seating

{{!gwi}}

Here is the top view of the room, I moved the sofas around after the above pictures were taken. Except for the sofas and floor, everything else will be updated so ignore the tiny knick knacks on the mantel, old tables etc

{{!gwi}}

What do you think? Please vote on the options and help me decide.

TIA

Comments (19)

  • 15 years ago

    I don't like it next to the FP for obvious reasons, BUT, it sounds like that works best for your family and that's important. How about getting (or building) a black shelving unit that is the exact size of the TV + stand and placing it on the opposite side of the FP for balance.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree the TV doesn't look right to me besides the FP.

    If you moved the TV to the wall across the window, it would be beside a loveseat, right?

    I agree to do what works best for you and your family and maybe a shelving unit, like Gracie mentioned above, would work better.

  • 15 years ago

    Gracie, thanks for the suggestion, will think about it.

    Sheesharee, if the TV is across the window, then the love seat will be moved from there, it wont be next to the TV.

  • 15 years ago

    I think you should have built-ins (or semi build-ins) on both sides of the fireplace and incorporate the tv into that.

  • 15 years ago

    Could you angle the TV in the other corner where the glass-topped table is now?

  • 15 years ago

    How about mounting over the fireplace?

  • 15 years ago

    Builtins probably wont work on the other side of FP because of the stairs. I can probably add a not so deep cabinet or something like that but not much as it will block the way. Here is an old pic that I found which has a better view of the other side of FP.

  • 15 years ago

    Since you wanted a vote, my vote is for the staircase wall. The way it is presently, it looks disjointed and sofas too far away from one another with nothing to pull it together.

    Regarding the glare, have you tried your new TV in that location? My DH was resistant for a long time putting our TV opposite the window because of that, but with the new flatscreen TVs it doesn't really present a problem. Also, you can change your WTs to allow for more light control/filtering. Something like bamboo shades that will still allow some light in. The seating the way it is now doesn't look grouped well for conversation and the loveseat on the staircase wall looks too far away from everything else and can't be moved closer due to your traffic patterns. You could replace the loveseat with a couple of club chairs flanking the fireplace, add some end tables and ground it all with a large rug.

  • 15 years ago

    Could you put the TV on the wall where the brown love seat is in the first picture? Put your brown love seat where the white one is and get two comfy chairs for either side of the fireplace positioned toward the TV?

  • 15 years ago

    I vote for option 2. Intead of reupholstering the white loveseat ( which I think you had mentioned in the other thread) I would just try and find a nice big comfy armchair for the corner where the tv is now and then pull it all together with rug, tables, lamps etc

  • 15 years ago

    Aestheically, I think it works much better across from the window.

    But, if it works much better for you near the fireplace that is what I would do--it's your house and you live there.

    So for me, I would just see which would annoy me more--the crowded fireplace wall or the glare/inability to see the TV from the kitchen.

    I think the best solution would be to mount above the fireplace. That would eliminate the crowded fireplace wall; allow for kitchen watching; give you plenty of seating.

    My sister has a very small room wtih the tv over the fireplace and there is no trouble with viewing.

  • 15 years ago

    grandmaof3, I could do what you suggested, seems like that would be ideal but the main problem with that would be that we wont be able to watch it from kitchen.

    Kristen, TV over FP will be too high, considering the TV size(60") and FP being already raised by about 1ft.

    I guess I will figure out whats best for us for now. Thank you all for your input.

  • 15 years ago

    Try angeling it into the corner where it is now.

  • 15 years ago

    I see...you want to see the TV from the kitchen. Then I guess it will have to be where you have it. I would get a black bookcase...tallish but narrow to put on the other side of the fireplace. Sort of make it look like a unit. If you put your TV where the white love seat is, can you see the TV from the kitchen.

  • 15 years ago

    even though the tv would look big and high, i would still rather have it over the fireplace than where it is now...you could buy the mounts which tilt it downward for more comfortable viewing... maybe?? hard to say, but i would at least give that a try.

    OR across from the window.

  • 15 years ago

    Joanie and I think alike. How would it look angled in the corner where it already is?

  • 15 years ago

    I don't agree with those suggesting you put the TV above the fire place. It would make for very uncomfortable viewing. The TV is best placed with the screen at eye level for seated viewers. Furthermore, most TV "consoles" sold today are too tall for the average large screen TV.

  • 15 years ago

    First, I think you need to pull everything away from the walls. Arrange the furniture in a grouping that makes the tv and fireplace the main focus. If the TV must be in that corner, then pull it out a little from the corner and set it on an angle. then, put a tall plant or a few bookshelves on the wall on the other side of the fireplace to balance things out a little.

  • 15 years ago

    jddar - I agree with you, yesterday I sat in the sofa right across the FP and tried to imagine my TV over FP, it was very high for the neck. I'm not sure if the pictures are giving a good sense of the height. It might have been ok if the FP was to the floor.

    RedTurtle - I started out by putting the TV at an angle and then flattened it out, I guess I will angle it again, I'm liking the angled position better. Thanks for your suggestions will keep them in my list.