Software
Houzz Logo Print
marylandpoolseeker

In-Floor Cleaner---Got Advice?

18 years ago

I am in the process of getting new pool estimates. Would anyone care to comment on the in-floor cleaning systems? Are they 1) worth the additional installation cost, 2) efficient cleaners, 3) low-maintenance, and 4) do they really maximize pool cleanliness while reducing the amount of manual labor that the owner needs to put forth for this reason?

Thank you in advance.

Comments (14)

  • 18 years ago

    We are currently building a pool in Arizona. I have had two pools previously. One had an in ground system and the other a Hayward Navigator vacuum system. Now I am trying to decide on my new pool which to go with. I would love feedback. Let me break down my thoughts based on the systems:

    In-Floor:
    Pros:
    -No vacuum hose to fight when swimming.
    -Floor was kept very clean with the exception of a couple dead spots.
    -Min. Maint. I never recall having any issues with the system itself.
    -Chemical and water temperatures seemed pretty even throughout pool.
    -Estetics. Clutter free clean look.

    Cons:
    -Expense of the system
    -2 dead zones
    -Stubbing toes if swimming when system was running.
    -Larger particles would not stay in suspension long enough to get filtered out.

    Vacuum:
    Pros:
    -Was able to clean larger debris and particles.
    -Less expensive to install.

    Cons:
    -If hose becomes disconnected the pool gets no cleaning.
    -Maintenance. Many times I have a small rock or twig get in the moving parts of the Navigator and it would lock the thing up. I had to take it apart and remove the debris. Also had parts wear out (I only had it a year when this started) and I had to replace wings, feet and internals. The internals were under warranty but it was still work and time the pool was not getting cleaned.
    -Hose in the water all the time. If you take it out to swim you have to go through the process of making sure it is completely refilled with water or the system will not prime and you can burn your motor up. If you donÂt take it out you have to move it out of the way and I have heard peoples concerns about pets getting entangled. I have never heard of it happening but I can see the danger for pets and smaller kids. Either way you end up wrestling with it.
    -Estetics. I donÂt like the looks of the hose in the water and if I am spending money on water falls etc why do I want a hose in the pool 24/7.
    -Water circulation was not as good. Now this could have been because the pool with the navigator was over 9 foot deep but it was always colder at the deep end.
    -Would not clean steps.

    Just writing this out makes me lean again towards the in floor system. It is surprising what the expense makes you reconsider. My big fear with either system is that in this pool I will have a Baja step (sun shelf by some peoples terminology) and a table. I know this means that the in floor will require well placed extra heads. However, I know for sure the vacuum will not get the step (any of them) or the bench by the table. I also can see it getting wrapped around the table pedestal and causing problems too.

    Well thatÂs my feedback. I am excited to hear what others say.

    -Rick

  • 18 years ago

    I currently have the infloor-Polaris Caretaker....My old pool had the Hayward Navigator.. I live in Arizona and I love my infloor for a few reasons..the hose is gone!!!!! No large pieces of debris getting stuck inside the Navigator..The water is circulated so well, I have had very little problems with Algae. I do have one spot that the infloor does not get well, but the large play/baja step is always clean with the infloor. My only complaint with the infloor is the fact that the leaves dont get sucked into the drain, so I have to fish them out....I would go infloor if I had to do it again...Just my 2 cents..

  • 18 years ago

    I don't ever remember stubbing my toes on the pop ups. I don't remember my kids ever saying anything either.

    One of the pool builders we were talking to told us how many heads would be in the pool of the plan she gave us and it was about 5 more than our other one and the pool was quite a bit smaller. She said that they don't like dead spots so they make sure there are enough heads in it. So, just make sure that your pool builder gets it right.

    BTW, we did have a couple dead spots and it was no big deal. The only time we really noticed was after a big storm. Other than that it really wasn't an issue.

  • 18 years ago

    I can't help you compare the two types of cleaners as this is our first pool. I can say that in over a year we have had NO problems with the in floor cleaner. No dead spots, no debris, no stubbed toes (though a pop up did give my SIL a surprise when she was sitting on one of the pool steps - with hilarious results!) The pool heats evenly and the chemicals mix evenly.

    If I had another pool, and I certainly would now I know how easy they can be to maintain, I would be very willing to pay the extra for an in floor cleaner.

  • 18 years ago

    Sis3. Thanks for your response. I am quickly planning to show my DH your comments about how the pool can easily be maintained with the in-floor cleaner. As we get closer to making a decision to build, DH becomes more and more concerned about maintainence.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi,MarylandPoolSeeker--

    After being away from this board for a very long time I decided to check back on things tonight and was surprised to see your reply to an old post of mine. Thank you for your input. Yes, I think the quote I got was pretty off-base as others have similarly reported the cost to be in the 3K to 5K range. Actually, I had become so overwhelmed with the whole process that I put everything on hold for a while. I found it very stressful trying to understand what the differences were between various pool builders construction quality & design and equipment choices. Furthermore, the way the items were combined it made it difficult to clearly see what I would get and at what price. The PBs I contacted locally in my area as it turned out all provided much higher quotes than I've seen others report for similar projects. I only had received one quote for the in-floor system (a rarity in our area) so I had nothing to compare it with, but it stopped me dead in my tracks and had me re-thinking everything. If it was only (ONLY) 4K more, I would not have gone for it. But, added to the other high-end construction costs and inflated prices related to the other upgrades and accessories and things began to escalate pass 100k.

    You might know this already, but there are only 3 manufacturers of these systems (1) A & A, (2) Paramount and (3) Polaris. Builder's typically have an exclusive arrangement with one or the other which further complicates the question of selecting a PB on the basis of other factors.

    If you are able to get an apples-to-apples cost comparision for all 3 I would be interested to see if there is much of a difference. Make sure, however, that the type of system, number of heads, skimmers, and other accessories (special leaf basket, etc.) are comparable. They have more than one type of system and package things under private labeling for various pool builder consortiums and national chains/franchises. If you get prices from any of the big national companies, I would be interested in knowing what they charge as compared to the independents.

    Good luck and let us know what you find out. Considering the economic and housing market situation we as homeowners and potential pool buyers need be well informed to make wise choices.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi njfolks,

    Some basic prices...one local PB quoted just over $4K for the Paramount PCC 2000 with MDX Debris Removal System while one national builder quoted around $4K for the A&A Autoclean. These quotes were for a pool about 650 sq ft with extra benches so your quote may have been higher if your pool design was larger and had more features. I still need to compare systems in depth more but I think I read that one system operates just as efficiently with 1/3 fewer heads than another due to higher flow rates, etc.

  • 18 years ago

    For what its worth, I received a quote for an A&A in-floor unit that was north of $7k for pool just under 650 sq ft!

    About made me fall out of my chair - and I guess that's why multiple quotes are a good thing to get!

  • 18 years ago

    Works great where thre is sand... stinks on leaves. Not worth the money. Go with a Polaris, Rayvac or similar animal. If it breaks, take it out and repair. If the infloor breaks, it can mean jackhammering the pool bottom. Good Luck !

  • 18 years ago

    There is already great advice here, but this last comment by "davemoore" makes me want to clear something up.

    The odds of an infloor cleaning system breaking to the point that the pool floor would have to be jackhammered out are astronomical. The only things that is incased in concrete that is part of the infloor cleaning are the collars and the plumbing ran to each head...both which are non-moving, non-mechanical pieces. The plumbing should be under pressure for roughly 90% of the build. If a head breaks or malfunctions, it can be replaced in just seconds with a stadard pole and head removal tool. If it is a Polaris-Caretaker system, and you're the original homowner, the replacement is 100% free for the life of the pool. Im not sure of the other infloor system warranties. The actual water valve (5 or 8 port) located outside the pool even has a lifetime warranty minus a couple of small parts like o-rings.

    Also, the problem with leaves.... Polaris makes a device called a Leaf Trapper. Solely works off a veturi and collects a very large majority of large debris when plumbed right and used with an infloor. Its basically one more drain in your deep end with canister in the deck that is completely hidden, minus a skimmer lid in the deck (no skimmer throat though).
    so..from a builder, polaris caretaker with a leaf trapper is unbeatable hands down in my opinion.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the great feedback, natural_one!

  • 17 years ago

    I would never purchase the caretaker system again. I was talked into by the pool salesperson, and it has never kept my pool clean. The warrenty says 99% clean guarentee, mine is about 60%, try to collect on the guarentee. I ended up buying a $400 Polaris 360 that does 100% clean the pool. Now 4 years later I have floor heads going bad, they are going to cost me $100 per head plus labor. Needles to say, I will save the money and invest in another 360 when this one dies.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    In floor cleaners are ugly - blemishes on the finish everywhere you look.

    When they fail, they are difficult and EXPENSIVE to repair.

    They spray the water directly across the surface - etching & staining the plaster.

    They do NOTHING for heavy leaf and debris loading.

    They require a high head and large HP pump to operate.

    They are a HUGE consumption of energy, compared to the 3/4 HP pump of a robotic cleaner.

    They do not push water through a filter, only through a leaf catcher.

    Pool builders make A LOT OF MONEY on the pop up systems.

    There is so much more that can go wrong with pop up heads.

    Debris oftentimes just gathers and accumulates in piles around the pool (dead areas).


    Robotic cleaner hoses RARELY come lose from the wall.

    They can be REMOVED 100% and there is no visual indication that they were ever there.

    They collect debris for disposal, reducing the load on your filter.

    You can rebuild the robotic cleaner yourself.

    There is no hose to get tangled in - you simply disconnect it from the pool wall to swim.

    The booster pump from a robotic cleaner can be used to power a leaf master to collect bulk debris and leaves after a major storm... pop-up heads are worthless in assisting after major storm/leaf events.

    They even suck up gophers and mice.

    A pressure side (booster pump) driven robotic cleaner is the way to go!

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert