Software
Houzz Logo Print
jharrell_gw

Thinking about new filter is bigger always better?

18 years ago

I have a 12k gallon pool with an ancient Pac Fab 48 sqft DE filter with worn out grids and I am thinking about upgrading instead of just getting new grids.

I am leaning towards the Pentair Quad DE and going with the 100 Sqft as it seems "bigger is better" when it comes to pool filters.

I am concerned though that it is possible to go too big a on filter and my old pump/plumbing might not be able to to fill it completely or some other issue going so big as I have seen a few references of this on the net, is this true at all?

I do plan on upgrading my pump probably to a Intelliflo in the future (1-2 years), would it be better to wait for that time and just fix the grids for now?

Thanks for any info.

Comments (18)

  • 18 years ago

    I'd like to hear this too. We keep getting the Quad DE quoted for the 80SF instead of the 100SF. Is requesting the 100 overkill or should I do it? We are oversizing our pipes to 3" pipes too after recommendation from you folks here. Thanks. KL

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, a larger filter will have less head loss in the plumbing, will require cleaning/backwashing less often and more important will actually filter better for a given flow rate.

    The only downside of course is the cost but I think it is worth the cost.

    One thing to make sure of, is that the pump flow rate does not exceed about 75%-80% of the maximum flow rate of the filter to achieve optimum cleaning. So it is important to match the filter to the pump. The larger the pump, the larger the filter you will need.

  • 18 years ago

    mas985,

    I will NOT be matching my pump to filter though, but the Quad DE 100 sqft will be very OVERSIZED for my application, the 60 sqft would be plenty, but if 100 sqft will filter better with less maintenance then the extra few hundred dollars is worth it to me.

    I just want to be sure its not possible to oversize a filter, such that my pump won't be able to put enough flow to make the 100 sqft work properly or something. I don't believe this to be the case based on what I have gathered here.

    Thanks.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm in the process of a 16K gallon pool build. My original plan called for a Hayward DE4826 Pro Grid with a 1 HP TriStar SP3210EE pump.

    When I talked with my PB about upgrading to the Hayward DE6020 Pro Grid his only caveat was that the 1HP pump might not have enough oomph for a good solid backwash.

    As a result of my research and discussions with my PB I decided to upgraded to the 1.5 Hayward Tristar 2 speed pump and the Hayward DE6020 .. This setup will save money with the low speed for my filtering and I'll have the high speed when I need it for backwashing.

    I would also add that before I decided in this change I did some checking at several online suppliers for the difference in cost between the equipment in my original bid and the upgraded equipment. My PB came in at $6 over the lowest price I could get the upgrades for online.

    Yet another reason I've been extremely happy with my PB.

    Linky Thing: My Pool Build

  • 17 years ago

    I am bring back this thread because I have the same question, and it never really got answered. Is it possible to have a DE filter that is too big? Flow too sluggish. Is there a minimum flow rate? Will 25 to 30 gpm through a 100 Quad DE work equal to 25 to 30 gpm through a Quad DE 60? Maybe a stupid question, but inquiring minds want to know.

  • 17 years ago

    Chill, The 60 will be fine for you. But if the money is burning a hole, then send it to the scholarship fund set up by one of the Buffalo crash victims when her husband was killed in the 9/11 attack.

  • 17 years ago

    Wow very hard to get a straight answer on this one. I am sure a normal pump would be "fine" as well instead of say an Intelliflo and I could send the extra money to a charity instead...

    However the question remains, is it possible to oversize the Quad DE? Does it have a min flow rate, or does bigger simply mean less restriction and longer periods between cleaning with no downsides, excluding the higher cost?

  • 17 years ago

    The only other downside will be the higher cost in the future to replace the filter elements. Larger filter elements cost more to replace but do not last any longer.

  • 17 years ago

    quote" is it possible to oversize the Quad DE? "quote
    Yes. There's no such thing as a DE filter that's to large for any pool.
    quote" does bigger simply mean less restriction and longer periods between cleaning with no downsides, excluding the higher cost? "quote
    Yes

    Personally, I'm no fan of the new Quad DE filters.
    I prefer the FNS and FNS plus filters. Their more affordable and easier for homeowners to work with.

    I hope this answers your questions.

    See ya,
    Kelly

  • 17 years ago

    I'm sorry, I meant to say No, there's no such thing as a DE filter that's to large.

    See Ya,
    Kelly

  • 17 years ago

    Sorry Kelly,
    I don't normally disagree with you but this time I do.

    FNS and Plus grids are a pain to clean without getting soaking wet in the process. Replacing its grid sux too.

    The Quad DE's elements are easier to clean off and do last longer than standard cartridge elements.

    Peace Love and Jelly Beans! Happy Valentines Day Ladies

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    The Pentair website shows the flow rates and turn over capacities of the Quad D.E.'s. The Quad D.E. 80's flow rate and turn over capacity are equal to the Quad D.E. 100. The D.E. 100 also requires more D.E.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Product Specifications

  • 17 years ago

    Scott,
    The reason I'm no fan of these filters is that they are expensive and don't backwash as effectively as the 60's.
    They, even the 80 and the 100, must be broken down and cleaned more often than even a FNS 48.
    I'd rather have a smaller filter which will take more backwashes in between bust down and cleans.
    I've found the Quad's would rather be broken down and cleaned than being backwashed.
    At 120,000 gallons I've probably got the largest capacity pool on the forum. I run 3 60 sq/ft DE's as my filtration.
    I can go 12 months between breakdown and cleaning grids.
    There's NO WAY I could do that with either of these much larger filters.
    You are correct, the manifolds and grids are a pain to reassemble. But, I do it much less than a homeowner with one of the Quads will.

    It's just my .02

    Jay,
    If you want an AWESOME filter purchase the Nautilus 72 with the stainless tank. If I'd of been able to get mine for free I'd of taken 3 of them instead of the FNS 60's.

    See ya,
    Kelly

  • 17 years ago

    Wow much better information, thanks guys.

    So beyond higher cost of the filter, and higher cartrige cost it sounds like a larger filter will not take backwashing as good as a smaller one? I am not sure I understand why that would be, it is because the larger surface area lowers the pressure in reverse causing less cleaning action?

    there also seems to be some debate as to whether the Quad D.E. is better/worse than the standard D.E. design, I had thought from researching here it was settled, that it was better, that is all the advantages of a DE with the ease of breakdown of a cartridge. Sound like there is still some differing opinions, I think my only main concern is how long the Quad's cartridges last compared to the grids, and if finding them years down the road will be difficult, since they are somewhat unique.

    On the stainless Nautilus, what would be the advantage? does stainless just hold up better than a composite tank?

    Thanks,

    Justin

  • 17 years ago

    A bad ground can make a stainless tank rot.

    The cartridges are make to last many years and will not be hard to acquire. They are somewhat more expensive than regular cartridges but overly so. They are easier to clean than grids and will get coated more evenly with DE or DE substitute.

    The Quad DE is also unique among other cartridge filters in that they can be equipped with a multiport. While this will add some head lose, it offers other advantages such aseasier backwashing and a waste setting to lower water levels after a rain and for vacuuming very dirty pools or algae blooms.

    WRT the overly sized DE filter (or sand for that matter) you are correct about the amount of area effecting the backwash and rinse cycle.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago

    The 100' DE will work well with the intelliflo pump, but the existing pump may not have an adequate flow rate to backwash properly. It will filter well though. The carts. are easier to clean and replace while the grids are universal and can be found easily (Pentair fits Hayward fits Jandy etc.). Avoid stainless tanks esp. on pools with chlorine generators.

  • 17 years ago

    Well my mind is pretty much made on the Quad DE 100 to replace my old pacfab 48 DE.

    I will probably be replacing all the equipment at the same time with an intelliflo/intellichlor/intelltouch i5/mastertemp.

    Anyone know if Pentair is going to integrate a ph sensor/acid pump into the intelltouch setup anytime soon? Seems like that would be nearly the last piece in pool automation.

    Justin

  • 17 years ago

    Pentair bought Acu-Trol for this but the work to integrate it into their automation systems is not yet completed. Acu-Trol has their own monitoring system. I've been asking about adding the ability for two years at the Atlantic City show. Year one, the bought Acu-Trol, year two began the product development. It is coming.