Software
Houzz Logo Print
lindamarie_gw

Tile or wood floor?

17 years ago

I had planned on a tile floor in the new kitchen. I saw a post with concerns of the hard surface being tiring on the legs and feet. I am considering a wood floor. I have concerns with water possibly damaging that wood.

I have experiencing with refinishing solid wood floors if damage was a problem. Are most people putting in engineered wood floors in the kitchen? What are the pros and cons of wood vs engineered wood vs tile?

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    We have always had hardwoods in our kitchens. I can't imagine the wear and tear of standing for hours on tile, not to mention the increase in breakage when I drop things.

    We have had zero problems with durability. Just be sure to re-urethane every 2-3 years. That avoids waiting to the point of requiring resanding of the floors and keeps them in great shape.

    Or, as we did in the lake house, use Waterlox for a more rustic look. It's extremely low gloss, no "plasticky" sheen, and tough as nails. Super easy to maintain: just throw a coat or two on every few years. Fabulous stuff.

  • 17 years ago

    I have heavy hardwood planks in most of my house, and it took one good plumbing flood to warp the ones that got really wet. I'd never do wood in a kitchen.

    As to the hardness, it depends on your underlayment. If you have proper suspended wood over open joists it's probably a lot softer on the joints. My wood "floating" floor on the ground floor slab is functionally just as hard as tile, even though it's supposed to be a little softer. So a lot depends on what your house is like. Wood laid on a rigid underfloor isn't going to give as much as wood laid over joists, but more than wood laid over concrete.

    I've also learned that the perceived hardness of tile--or a slab, for that matter--depends on how used to it you are. One learns to stand differently if one expects the floor not to give, and gets used to it.

    I find I get just as tired and achy if I work just as over-hard on a raised, cushioned floor as on my own tile on concrete. And I find that cushy mats, shoes, etc., actually make it worse, because they alter the stance. So, hm...LOL! I guess I'm saying it doesn't matter so long as you cook barefoot!

    That said, get what you like! Tour your friends' kitchens and feel out the different floors. Decide on the looks, cleanability, etc., and get what you like.

  • 17 years ago

    I haven't noticed any incredible difference in the ceramic in my new house compared to the wood in my old above the ground house.
    I have BR111 Amendiom engineered wood in my DR and LR - and I wouldn't put it in the kitchen cause it scratches too easily, and I'm all thumbs.
    If you do get tile, make sure you do not get one with a beveled or rounded edge of any sort. Mine is slightly rounded on the edges, and because of this, the grout sits lower and the edges of the tiles are more exposed than they should be in the corners where they meet. I have many small chips in areas around the fridge where I've dropped frozen items when we had a top freezer.
    So, if I had to do it again I'd still go ceramic, but would have chosen something flatter.

  • 17 years ago

    I adore wood and loathed the porcelain tile I had in my last kitchen -- but these things are SO individual, you will find many extremely conflicting opinions within one group of folks. My feet ached a lot on the tile I had, and don't do so on the wood I now have, with no change in cooking habits - if anything, I now spend even more time in the kitchen since it's warmer and more welcoming. I also hated hated HATED having to bleach every little thing out of the tile grout, like espresso grind spills, ugh.

    I will say that I find the concerns about the durability of wood are not always justified, not with today's finishes. My refinished 100-year-old fir floors are chugging along just fine in my kitchen. :)

  • 17 years ago

    Tile for me: hides dirt, easy to clean and sanitize [assuming you pick a dark grout] and feels great with radiant heat.

    I'd rather replace the occasional plate than have big deep gouges in a wood floor, and it's nice that kids can play there, even ride their trikes from outdoors without hurting a thing.

    You can always use gel mats in the 'stand zones' of stove and sink if you find you have an issue.

  • 17 years ago

    circuspeanut. how funny cuz I'm the exact opposite. I love tile and find wood annoying to maintain and then ugly to look at. I loathe refinishing wood floors. Plus I love standing on tile. I love the solid feeling like being on the earth. My favorite house style is Spanish with terra cotta floor tiles.

    I'm ripping out the kitchen in the cottage I bought and putting in ceramic floors. Can't wait.

  • 17 years ago

    There's no question that like many other debates (induction vs gas, granite vs marble, paint vs stain on cabs), this is in the end an individual choice and no amount of logic will sway a wood person to tile or vice versa.

    pillog is right on the money re underlayment. We have engineered wood over concrete slab in the basement and it's hard as a rock. The kitchen floor is indeed over open joists and is much more resilient as a result. I can really tell the difference in feet and ankles after a long cooking session.

    I would make one point: refinishing wood may annoy you, but for me (to quote another website) this sounds MUCH more annoying:

    "The first part of re-grouting is the most difficult and also the most time consuming. This involves removing the existing grout with a cold chisel and a hammer. Be sure to wear goggles or some type of eye protection when completing this step. Work in sections, chipping out the old grout and the using a shop vac or a stiff bristled brush to remove the debris as you go. Depending on the size of the floor and the tiles, this step could take several hours to complete"

    Give me urethane any day.

  • 17 years ago

    I appreciate all the comments. Now I have more to consider. I didn't think that the floor resiliance would be affected if it was over joists, cement etc. This floor is over joists with a diagonal wood floor covered by plywood. I can feel how tired my legs are just sitting in the studio with the brick floor. I am also considering wood because I can't seem to co-ordinate all the choices, cabinets painted or stained, granite color, backsplash, floor.

Sponsored
Snider & Metcalf Interior Design, LTD
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars25 Reviews
Leading Interior Designers in Columbus, Ohio & Ponte Vedra, Florida