Software
Houzz Logo Print
parma42

Added one more dining table with base Les liked

18 years ago






















First table is the new one. Disregard second picture of the table top. It's out of order and is the top from the table that is second to last.

OK, new table is from French Heritage. Tom-Price (Chicago furniture company) is having a 40% off list sale this week and this is a brand they carry (as is Hickory-White). It has a base similar to the one Les liked, but this one DOES have a leaf.

Score so far...everyone except two people liked the Drexel-Heritage (second from last).

Nobody liked the Thomasville (last)

One other person besides me liked the Hickory-White done in all wood not white bottom (Les liked some elements but had a few issues).

What about the new one? Change anyone's opinions?

DH thinks I'm nuts obsessing so much over one table but it's going to have to last until they bury us at these prices.

Comments (21)

  • 18 years ago

    Love the new table - Vote for #1

  • 18 years ago

    Like #1 - what does the top look like? Is it less distressed than the others? If so, really love it. Also love the chandelier - do you mind if I ask where you found that / what brand it is?

  • 18 years ago

    That's the only problem with Table #1. I haven't been able to see the top yet. Will do some more digging.

    Trying2buy, the chandelier is from Savoy House. I bought it online. I just tried the link and it didn't work for me. It is from the Burgundy collection, so if you just google savoy house burgundy, I'm sure you can find it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Savoy House Chandelier

  • 18 years ago




    I found it. Here's the top of the new table #1.

  • 18 years ago

    I like #2 and #3 equally. Both are very nice!

  • 18 years ago

    I don't know your room setting, but table top #pic 4 looks beautiful with your chandelier. Its wood tones and detailing look perfect to me. I thought that went with the white-based table, but see you say it goes with the second to last one, whose base doesn't work at all for me. Pic #2 table top doesn't work, imo -- looks to new wood and style-wise for the chandy.

    I prefer the white one, but in a wood finish, not white. Don't know about the table top style or wood tones and detailing, though, from the above pic.

    Based on the chandy alone, something Old World with some aging, both more refined like pic #4 or more earthy would work well too, I think. Not too ornate, imo (unless that's the overall look you're going for in the room).

  • 18 years ago

    I like the new one a lot. The top is beautiful, and no scallops (which was one of the issues I raised). The base is a little less bulky, which IMO means better leg room for the people seated there.

    Toms-Price is a great place, isn't it? I go there once every decade or so and drool over the Stickley pieces, among other things.

  • 18 years ago

    Definitely #1 (I am voting twice for #1) - The less ornate top allows your chandelier to shine. Agree with Les on the extra leg room - The bottom base the pedestal is attached to looks like it will add the stability needed when you put in the extra leaf. We had a very heavy round table with the 4 leg pedestal that became a little unstable on the ends when the leaf was added, which made it an oval. People had a tendency to lean on the ends when getting out of the chairs, which I never noticed when it was round without the leaf. The legs also interfered with the chair placements as others indicated above. I also found people would rest their feet on the tops of the wood legs - another reason not to have legs (for me anyway).

  • 18 years ago

    Squirrel, the table top you like DOES go with the white table (which I would do in wood tone). I made more sense in my first post (pick from 3 dining tables). When these pics were out of order, I'm afraid my explanations were a little confusing.

    Les, I haven't even seen a Toms-Price store yet. I really wanted to get to the outlet store and the one in Wheaton. The maze of suburbs out here really have me intimidated (driving-wise). In my younger years, I lived in Wrigleyville in the city and for most of the last 20, in Rockford.

    I looked at their ad and what lines they carried, then started narrowing down possible tables. Thought DH might drive me out there this weekend but now he's on a project of painting the sheetrock in the garage. What's with most men? We don't even have pictures hung yet, lol. He hates furniture shopping because he wants me to BUY when I want to LOOK and compare.

    Maygothyrivergirl sure likes the new one, so does trying2buy. Squirrel and rosewind like #2. Almost everyone on my first post liked #3 the best.

    Well one thing I DO know is that the Thomasville gets scrapped.

    Thanks, and if the people who voted last time still have the same opinion or changed to #1...let me know!

  • 18 years ago

    I vote for #1 which I love.

  • 18 years ago

    Well, then I vote for the white one in wood, whichever number that is : )

  • 18 years ago

    Love the Hickory-White in all wood. That is the table I wanted for my breakfast room, but it was too pricey!

  • 18 years ago

    LOL, like you and squirrel, I just love the Hickory-White. The only problem with it is the lack of a leaf. DH thinks that for the price it is, the lack of functionality becomes an issue. The new contender has one.

    If I was rich...the HW would be in my kitchen, too, texanjana.

  • 18 years ago

    I like them all! But, my first thought regarding the ones with the wood pedestal base, is the wood base is going to be a resting spot for people's feet, and I'd worry that the base would get scuffed and scratched over time. If you're paying big time $$ for this table, I'd not want to be checking under the table to make sure my guests weren't putting their feet on my table base! Have you actually had the opportunity to sit at the table? Maybe there's enough room, that your feet wouldn't even come close to touching the base.

    But, for that reason, I like the second from the bottom with the four leg pedestal. I do like the top of the hickory-white...

  • 18 years ago

    I like French Heritage because they are known for quality furniture and they still manufacture many of their pieces in France. But you have to ask because not all of their collections are.
    Have you seen the DVD yet? It's interesting to see their craftsman making the furniture.

  • 18 years ago

    Love the new one. (I still like the scallops of the other one) :)

  • 18 years ago

    new one is very pretty!

  • 18 years ago

    My DD is an interior designer and she LOVES the chandy you posted. She strongly suggest you buy this kitchen to go with it, heehee!


  • 18 years ago

    Inspiration picture for parma

  • 18 years ago

    OMG, that's so beautiful!! Thanks caminnc.

    I've been out of town most of the week taking care of my Dad and had no internet :( Couldn't wait to get home and jump on GW to see what I'd missed. Must be an addict.

    Have to make up my mind on the table this within a week and didn't have my computer to do any more research.

  • 18 years ago

    BTW, did you ask your DD what she thought of the tables? :)