Ask her if it has pink undertones and see what she says.

If it does, there may be a reason she suggested it, but if it's not what you want I am sure she could suggest something else.

Looking at pictures of paint colors is only moderately productive at best. You need to paint a big piece of poster board with 2 coats of Athena and move it around your room(s) at different times of day to see how it looks in your house.

I agree, ask her. And paint a big sample board to check in all lights on all walls.

I just viewed it on my mac and it's a gorgeous warm tan, no pink.

I just Googled it to see the color and found this from the GW Kitchen forum from Dec. 7, 2010. I linked the entire post below.

"meanwhile i had tested ben moore's ATHENA in the old house and determined it was colder than an arctic blizzard. just TOO cold, so i forget about it. i return to the paint store and buy over $100 worth of sample grays and each of them ends up so warm in the new house that they too, are boringly beige. i'm sitting here at my wits end trying to figure out what's going on. and then i spot the giant 4' swatch of way-too-cold athena and it hits me. everything i was trying was warming up so, i got out the athena sample and headed over. i found a clean wall and started painting. and low and behold, the overly cool athena in one house was The Perfect Beautiful Gray in the new. it was the first gray sample i purchased. i could have saved myself a lot of time (and even more money) by just testing it out IN THE SPACE."

Here is a link that might be useful: Looking for pale gray paint suggestions please!

I found that looking at samples no matter what size in an existing room is very difficult as the reflected light off of the existing walls always taints the new sample. When the entire room is done in the sample colour and the LRV is all consistent , thats when you get the true look and feel.