Software
Houzz Logo Print
kathy_94952

Undermount sink worries - foolish?

15 years ago

Okay, I had been all set to go with an undermount sink, probably a Silgranit. But what if there's a problem with the sink down the road? Can Silgranit be repaired? I've read about Silgranit sinks having cracks before installation; what about after? Can stainless be repaired? In general, what kind of post-installation undermount sink problems happen, how often, and what's the solution?

One specific concern is that to fit everything else in the cabinet run, I'll probably have to go with a smaller than spec'ed sink base. The sink calls for a 36" sink base even though the width of the sink itself is only 32". My cabinet maker says it's not a problem, he can fit the sink in a 32" or 33" sink base, notch the subtop and not use the clips. The sink will be secure because it will be resting on the cabinet sides. The catch is that there then wouldn't be anyway to drop the sink down into the cabinet if it needed to be replaced. The only way to get the sink out would be to lift the granite slab (yeh, right!).

Am I being foolish to worry? If I don't go with the above installation, I'll either have to go for a smaller sink, a different installation method (top mount, which I don't much like), or change the cabinet run to include the recommended sink base width.

Any insights, advice, or reassurances appreciated!

Comments (5)

  • 15 years ago

    You can what if forever. Go with the undermount sink. millions do.Your not breaking new ground in kitchen design. We love ours and if there is ever a problem we will address it when it happens.

  • 15 years ago

    Umm, how "to drop the sink down into the cabinet if it needed to be replaced" implies it has to be inserted from above. I think that if, if , if, it had to be replaced one could cut a side panel enough to let a sink in, and rebuilt the side panel. Not rocket science.

    I'm glad someone finally posted a succinct description: "... can fit the sink in a 32" or 33" sink base, notch the subtop and not use the clips..."

  • 15 years ago

    Yes, foolish. Would you really ever pull out a drop-in sink from granite and find another one to fit in the exact same hole? Even with my old, old laminate we had to cut more of it and the plywood underlayment out to fit our new cast iron when we replaced the old double-bowl. I cannot imagine doing that with granite.

    The cracking you are reading about with silgranit is very far and few between. I've never read anything here about one cracking after it's in except one just the other day where someone reported they read it somewhere on the web. You'll read about a lemon or very unusual circumstance with ANY product of any kind from any manufacturer if you look long enough. Yes, some of the early silgranits had cracks during shipping, but that's not the case anymore. Blanco is using a newer and better generation of silgranit now.

    You're lucky to be doing custom cabs where you can go with a smaller base and still fit a big sink. Go for it!

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the input - I love this forum! It's great to hear the calm voice of reason. I do tend to over-worry and imagine all the bad things that can happen. The good news is that I sometimes even manage to prevent bad things from happening. The bad news is I lose too much sleep. I need to learn to be more choosy about what to worry about. :)

  • 15 years ago

    I'm a worrier too. Stick around here for very long and you'll find all kinds of things to lose sleep over!