Software
Houzz Logo Print
anele_gw

Alternatives to shutters?

18 years ago

I live in a simple Cape Cod home with the er . . . requisite shutters. However, my shutters are not the right size, nor can they be . . .there isn't enough house to hold shutters the right size.

What other options are there? The house has white siding and uninteresting windows (no panes). I'd love something else around the windows to bring in some architectural detail that is so sorely lacking.

Thank you!

Comments (13)

  • 18 years ago

    I've always loved to see substantial trim-- how about just beefing up the trim around each window? Window boxes are lovely as well.

  • 18 years ago

    Windows with no panes must get awful breezy... ;-)

    Our previous house was a Cape with palest green siding, boring boring boring. I chose to use a strong color for the trim (although it turned out brighter than I intended, it was supposed to be more like BM Chrome Green) and an even stronger one for the front door to make it stand out. There was only one window that could have taken shutters which would have looked a little odd. I did get a good bit of nagging about putting a windowbox on that left-hand pair of windows but it would have been a maintenance hassle as the bottom of the window was nearly 7' off the ground and the windows screens did not open.

    {{!gwi}}

    Do you garden? Trellises with climbing whatevers (vines like clematis or sweet potato vine, climbing easy-care roses like Climbing Carefree Sunshine, etc.) and vertically-oriented evergreens can do a great deal for perking up a bland facade. I have the original black thumb and even I managed to keep pencil-point juniper chugging merrily along with total benign neglect - it grew almost a foot that first year. The trees flanking the steps were dwarf alberta spruce and they were lovely but the constant battle against the spider mites got old REAL fast. Where I live now everyone and his cousin has at least one lilac in their yard - I swear sometimes they must be required by ordinance since this is called the "Lilac City" because of the enormous stands of wild lilact that go berserk blooming every spring. We have four common lilacs that are 50+ years old and are planning to add a few other varieties like Paliban (dwarf Korean lilac) and Miss Kim (some people hate it but I really like it, doesn't hurt that it's practically bulletproof) next year when we tackle the curb appeal issue.

  • 18 years ago

    Without seeing a picture of your house, its hard to offer advice. A friend had a similar style home. They added shutters and window boxes to the bottom 2 separate windows. Their window boxes were in the shade and they were not 7 feet off the ground. They did add lots of gingerbread molding especially to the upper dormer windows. They too used a bolder color. When they replaced their roof, they added the textured roof shingles. They also added a covered porch. It matched the dormer look above. They had wrought iron posts supposting the porch roof. It really livened up the house. They even added an old fashion brass door bell & hardward to the door and a mail slot. The door was decorative with the upper arched glass. Shrubs play an important part to sprucing up the home. Bigger shrubs on the corners and small near the door work well. Sorry, I dont have a picture, they live in NJ, I am in FL.

  • 18 years ago

    I'll come back with more but I wanted to put this picture up:
    {{gwi:702437}}

    johnmari, I love the colors you chose. I think the stronger colors really give it a good punch, and the landscaping is lovely. I, too, live in a Lilac Village (not a city) and everyone seriously does have lilacs . . .they give them away for free.

    gk504, gingerbread trim is my favorite. I thought about window boxes (well, one for the smaller window) but didn't know if it would look too low.

    Another snafu . . .if I take off the shutters, then it looks like I will be left with some holes, and maybe some discoloration too (haven't checked that yet but the holes are there for sure). Does that mean I'm stuck with shutters?

    PS, Pardon those xmas clips . . .DH likes to leave them up.

  • 18 years ago

    Ah, a picture makes it so much easier:) One thing I would do is either lose the storm door or buy one that is all glass, I think they call them forever view. Thats relatively inexpensive to do. You need to show off the door. And I would probably paint the front door another color. I dont dislike the green, I am just at a loss as to what color to then change the front door color to. Personally, I like when the door is different than the shutters. Its unfortunate that the gas meter is right on the front corner of the house. It looks like there is little room for shrubs on the driveway side of the front door. I dont know where you live to recommend plant material, but getting the right shrubs will really liven up the home. What happen to the other railing? I think it needs one on the other side. Its a really cute house with lots of potential.

  • 18 years ago

    gk5040-- ITA with all of your suggestions. We have (obviously!) made zero improvements/changes on the exterior when we bought this house. Both doors have to go . . .the storm door is a rusty mess, and the other door has just seen better days. I am thinking of no storm door (maybe crazy considering how cold it gets here) since I'm just not feeling the love for storm doors in general . . .I am painting the new door something with kick, probably red. If I keep the shutters (do you think I should keep them?) I am thinking either a blue or gray. I've thought about changing the colors since forever, but now I don't even know if the shutters should stay!

    The gas meter is a thorn in my side. WHY would they put it there??? It's something else I've been wondering what to do about . . .I was planning on putting some sort of evergreen in front of it (an evergreen because it looks especially awful in the winter here in the Midwest) but I'm not sure I can- can one block the gas meter?

    RE: the railing . . .I don't think it ever had one on the other side. Goofy, isn't it? My dream is put a white wooden stoop instead of the concrete along with wooden railings. (I can't put in a porch according to my contractor neighbor unless the village makes an exception.) And to complete this dream, I'd put some shrubs to act as a fence along the front of the yard (and along the driveway), an arbor in the middle, and a curvy path made up of salvaged bricks leading to the front door.

    I have some ideas, now I just need some cash!

    Thank you so much for your input!!!!

  • 18 years ago

    Your house is really cute - I love cape cods. I think the shutters look good on the house. I think it works because they are the same size on both sets of windows. Without them I think it would look plain. With some new paint and a little new landscaping, it's going to look great. Maybe if you take the railing off and put two nice pots on either corner of the concrete, that will give you some color and interest by the door.

  • 18 years ago

    I like the shutters, keep them. As polkadots said, if you remove them I think the windows will look lost. I think a red door would look great if you changed the shutter color. There is a pretty color called SW Wrought Iron Gate, its a dark charcoal gray (almost black) that would look nice for the shutters, or even black would look nice with a red door. I am not a fan of the blue idea for the shutters, not with red, I would stay in the dark gray to black range for the shutters. If you are not oppose to tossing the storm door, I would toss it, you can alway add another later. If you eventually replace the front door with a good insulated door, you wouldnt need a storm door, unless you like opening the front door in the warmer months. I dont know if there is a way to remove some of the concrete on the corner near the gas meter. I am trying to think inexpensive for you. Unless you are able to take out the walk and make that bed deeper, I am not sure you could plant anything near the meter. But if you can make the bed much deeper, you could plant far enough in front of it that the gas company can still get back there to read it. I would try to plant some type of Holly or medium size tree on the far corner of the house (wish I knew how to photoshop), just make sure you leave plenty of room for the tree (or shrub) to grow to its full size. I would put azeleas or rhododenrons under the windows (if they work in your neck of the woods) because they add nice color in the spring. I would dig up and line the flower beds with all your tulip so next spring they come back as a border. I would move the butterfly bushes. Cut them down, dig them up and move them to a sunny spot in the back yard. I think they are butterfly bushes, its hard to tell. I would make sure you pick plant material that stays green all winter. Plants are relatively inexpensive, especially at HD or Lowes. We have bought small to save money. We always fertiziled and watered well the first few years. After 3 years our shrubs were the same size or bigger than the neighbors. One thing to remember is if you buy small plants, read the tag to see how big they will get so you leave ample space for the plant to grow. Miracle Grow in the small box where you add a scoup to the water can works great:)
    I also think the single railing needs to go. Adding some pretty decorative pots like polka suggested would look nice.
    Just starting with 2 quarts of paint (one for the door and one for the 4 shutters, and removing the storm door and railing will be an inexpensive beginning. Another suggestion to finish off the door area would be adding a new slightly bigger light fixture and painting the mail box the house color. If you cant afford the new walk, I would relandscape the right side. Next year you can tackle the walk and finish off the plants on the left.

  • 18 years ago

    Two of my favorite houses nearby are Cape Cods with no shutters. The emphasis is on an interesting door & oversized flanking sconces. My photo site doesn't let me post pics in these posts, so here's a link:

    mock up

    I thought a low stone-lined garden bed with herbs & creepers under each window would look nice. Here's a low stone wall with spectacular garden: garden wall

    Finally, the blinds are probably good for light control, but ball-fringed curtains I think would look classic & add more interest: Ball fringed curtains. They look great from the outside.

    Finally, I have a wrought iron railing. I love to cover it with morning glories in the summer (no pix, unfortunately).

  • 18 years ago

    polkadots . . .thank you so much for your thoughts! I keep wondering how I can get that railing out of the concrete without destroying the concrete. Is that possible? Maybe I could paint the concrete white, too? I agree that the pots would make a huge difference!

    gk5040, I've read your post several times trying to soak it all in! I am glad to hear your thoughts on the no blue. I was trying to get that cottage feel by using blue instead of gray or black, but it would probably just end up looking tacky instead. The charcoal sounds perfect! I think I am going to get some shrubs from now and just be patient. Much more affordable that way, and like you said-- better in the long run. Love your ideas for the inexpensive fixes! Thank you so much!

    awm03 . . .thank you so much for the mock up! The door, no shutters, and new lights really change a lot. It is amazing how the details all add up! That low stone-lined garden bed is just fabulous. I love, love, LOVE those curtains and have been eyeing them for some time (ITA that the blinds just don't work with the cottage theme) . . .my only (big) problem is that 2 of my cats are absolute fanatics when it comes to little puffy balls, so I think my curtains would be destroyed. I will keep investigating curtains, though, as they'd make such a change both on the interior AND exterior.

    Thank you everyone, so very much. Your input is invaluable!

  • 18 years ago

    I vote for the shutters and agree that dark gray or black with a red door would be nice. And if you ever needed a new roof, same, dark grey or black, that would be a nice crisp historical look.
    I think you'll like a new quality all window storm - they operate really smoothly and are well fitted enough that you can leave your door open in spring and fall and still not lose all your a/c or heat.

    I wonder, if you do the black or grey shutter scenario, what would happen if you painted the outer trim of the....the....dang, can't remember the word for the upper window things. I first thought paint all the inside trim the color of the shutter ala johnmari to make them appear larger, and then mimic on the trim above, but on second thought dont think it would look right.

  • 18 years ago

    Your welcome:)

  • 18 years ago

    marys1000, yes . . .as much as I like the look of no storm door, I think since we have no real overhang or whatever it's called in our entryway, it is a must. Otherwise, the entry door would take a real beating with the weather here!

    I think I will stick to gray for the shutters. I keep looking at doors with storm doors everywhere for inspiration, but the things around here are generic. I did see this that was interesting-- practical yet different.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Victorian Steel Door