Software
Houzz Logo Print
lindabarbara_gw

Backsplash Misery

18 years ago

After two years, the work that began on our summer condo is coming to an end....Oh, thank you, Lord! The last remaining project is our kitchen backsplash and it's causing me to lose sleep...really and I know I'm dramatic but I do see tiles in my sleep.

My kitchen is open to the dining area and living room; it's quite standard in that the cabinets are a linen-white Shaker style and the counters are Canyon Crema granite...which I love.

My problem is the granite has gorgeous colors ranging from creams, to caramel to copper and browns which should be easy to match, however, the backsplash tiles seem to have either too much movement and fights the granite, or the tiles seems too "bathroomy" with a glazed finish and I can't seem to hit on the right tumbled tiles. Any suggestions for me before I just paint everything and call it a day?

Thank you and I appreciate your help...

Here is a link that might be useful: Summer Condo

Comments (27)

  • 18 years ago

    Well -- how about wood beadboard for your backsplash -- simple, clean and painted white to match your pretty cabinets? Or paint it to match your wall color! Beadboard would really let your counters take center stage! Just add some wonderful copper pots on a potrack or even a copper kettle to the stove to bring in those tones.

    LOVE your kitchen -- you are so lucky! :)

  • 18 years ago

    How about forgetting color and doing it in a stainless steel tile to match the appliances? Very easy to maintain and not too pricey. Great kitchen btw.

  • 18 years ago

    That's a great kitchen! Since you love the Canyon Crema granite...how would you feel about using granite tiles? We had the same problem when we remodeled the kitchen in our summer home. After experiencing similar frustration in trying to coordinate the backspash with the granite and cabinetry, we followed a suggestion to this and were very pleased with the outcome.

  • 18 years ago

    tumbled marble or another stone sub way tile would look great. Stone with stone doesn't compete.

    Here is a link that might be useful: link

  • 18 years ago

    I think more light tile will make your kitchen float away. Would you consider using a darker tile, with very deep brown or black tones? Your cabinets and counter are really lovely!

  • 18 years ago

    I think subways would look great too. I used honed marble subways with subtle gray and cream veins that I was really happy with.

    Did you check out the backsplash gallery on the finished kitchens blog? It's a great resource for ideas.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Finished kitchen blog

  • 18 years ago

    I lost a lot of sleep over my backsplash, too. I ended up using a combination of materials: wood, slate, glass, and stainless steel. I get lots of compliments on it:

    {{!gwi}}

    {{!gwi}}

    You could do something similar with beadboard, white stone or ceramic, a different color glass tile, and copper instead of stainless steel.

  • 18 years ago

    I was also going to suggest beadboard. I think it would look lovely and your cabinets and granite would be highlighted. I see that you used it as wainscoating.

    Could you tell me what brand of appliances you used? I have a smooth cooktop, and I love the look of yours.

    tina

  • 18 years ago

    Why don't you just paint for now, and add a 3" backsplash of the granite? There is nothing that says you can't tile later, and that may be better than to pick something to 'get it done'.

    In the one pix I see beadboard below chair rail level, so I would not do beadboard above. I think stainless might be cool on the wall right behind the stove, but I don't see doing it all over in that space. Remember, too, that while you look down onto the granite as you try to pick something, the overall effect as you look at the kitchen is more just the edge of the countertop, and much more of the backsplash.

  • 18 years ago

    I would think a nice handmade glazed tile in a matte finish with mainly cream and sprinklings of caramel, cinnamon and coffee. Set one row straight, then diagonals above?

    I must be hungry! ;-)

  • 18 years ago

    I'm with sweeby. I see a handmade tile. A friend has a kitchen very similar to yours and did a mustard coloured hand made subway. It looks awesome. I'd probably go with a colour pulled from your granite.

    I'm of the camp that believes that a backsplash should be fairly neutral and then use accents on the counter and walls to add more interest. I know others have made beautiful kitchens doing the opposite (uxorial for eg.) but I am a neutral loving girl.

  • 18 years ago

    ...or what about painted tin ceiling tiles?

  • 18 years ago

    Here is an example. Scroll down to see the kitchen.

    Here is a link that might be useful: tin

  • 18 years ago

    If you wanted to do something relatively inexpensive for now, what about these faux tin backsplash panels? Their website shows 14 different finishes, 6 possible styles, and matching finish outlet covers. They can be adhered two different ways, one of which would make for a relatively easy removal if you decided to do something else later (some type of double backed tape). Both our Lowe's and Home Depot carry the various finsihes as instock items, but the paintable white ones are special order. Their website shows that you can get up to three free 6"x6" samples, also; it also shows DoItBest and Menard's as additional retailers. Down here (in Louisiana), the 18"x24" panels run about $18.50 each.

    Disclaimer: I have no experience w/ these, other than seeing them in the store, nor do I have any ties to this mfr. :-D

    Here is a link that might be useful: Fasade decorative backsplash panels

  • 18 years ago

    I was amazed to see all the responses and the variety of solutions to my backsplash problem. I'm going to look into all suggestions offered. I want to thank all of you for the nice comments as well as the thoughtful suggestions offered.

    Hopefully I will soon have this resolved. I would also like to post some before pictures soon, if I have them. The entire condo was re-done and this kitchen was a nightmare from the 60s with its almost black peeling formica cabinets, harvest gold and avocado green fixtures. The worst of all was the fact the cabinets completely enclosed the space so walls were removed, etc.

    Thanks again and I'll be back soon! You're all so talented and generous.

    PS: Tinam61, all appliances are Jennair...had to use an electric stove because there is no gas available. Good stove but nothing, at least for me, like cooking with gas.

  • 18 years ago

    We look forward to pictures. Even without a splash, your kitchen is a dream.

  • 18 years ago

    I love all the suggestions so far. I was leaning towards using colorful tiles instead of neutral. Everything in the kitchen, although gorgeous, is very neutral and you need something that really pops. Maybe a beautiful red mosaic tile, or some other color. But I also loved the tin ceiling tile and beadboard ideas.

    I'm sure whatever you choose it will be beautiful. You've done a fabulous job so far, and nobody expects your fine taste to take a nose-dive on the backsplash!

  • 18 years ago

    Beautiful kitchen! Light and airy! I think it is screaming for cream colored subway tiles.

  • 18 years ago

    OK...I may be too late to weigh in - but - it looks light and clean...wish you had a closer picture. I think you could take care of the problem with a few well chosen accessories. The backsplash could just be a neutral backdrop for your choices...put the emphasis on the things in front of the BS. I'd hate to redo it without at least trying to make it work....but that's me. If you hate it, you HATE it!

  • 18 years ago

    How about something neutral like this:

  • 18 years ago

    My kitchen is nearly the same as yours. I finished Sept 07 but still looking for a backsplash. What about crema d'orcia? It is a lighter cream tumbled marble, but the edges are not tumbled, they are straight.

    Regardless, let us know what you decide!

  • 18 years ago

    jbrig Thanks for the web site. This is what I have been thinking about. I just sent a request for samples.

    lindabarbara Did you ever decide on anything? I agree it can be very mind boggling.

  • 18 years ago

    Well I can only go with what I know! I really like my tumbled stone and I think it would look nice with your granite as well (without the glass tiles).

  • 18 years ago

    I agree completely with lsandler--when I saw your --I'm blanking--but the window treatment, I thought "harlequins!" That's what's needed to bring this kitchen to life! And lsandler's suggestion is spot on, IMO--mostly cream, with some gold harlequin handmade accent highlights. Perfect.
    IMO. :)

  • 18 years ago

    Was it something I said?

  • 18 years ago

    Brutuses link to the tumbled stone is exactly what I was going to suggest to you. (I liked either the light or the Noce in her link.) I kept trying to come up with design or pattern or glaze or something when I did my backsplash two years ago and finally went to my friend who designs kitchens and has some huge kitchens displayed in town in the design centers. She loves natural stone and this was no exception. She went out to her warehouse and found some tumbled marble much like that in the Brutuses link for me to take home and try out. Well, I did but still was unsure. However, we needed to get done and I trust her taste. I love the result. I prefer my backsplash to be more neutral so that I can dress up my kitchen with color and fabric and dishes and accessories. Five years from now I could repaint and change out window treatment & art and the backsplash would still work well with other colors.
    You have a pretty and neutral space. I love the wall color that you splotched. It's calming and gorgeous. Let your granite shine and keep your backsplash more background rather than center stage.

    Red

  • 18 years ago

    How about this tumbled stone? I have it in my foyer on the floor and love it .I think it would pick up your dark appliances and show off your cabinets.
    http://www.daltilestone.com/images/products/tiles/small/emperadorTS55_4x4_300.jpg