Software
Houzz Logo Print
tofoi

How much $ can a GC save on materials?

19 years ago

I posted this on the kitchen site but realize this may be the best place to post.

Thanks!

Hi All

This may have been asked before but we've got 2 options for our Kitchen plus (kitchen, living room, master bath, laundry, kids bath, master walkin closet) remodel.

We've got a group of subs which we will GC but one of them is a GC that will let us use his license/GC clout to purchase things at a discount.

Our other option is to have a GC do it all.

My question is, how much is it worth to have the GC there vs being able to manage the subs and use the GC's purchasing power for our materials? Do GCs get that much of a discount for materials or would be be better off saving that 20-30k (from the GC's fee) and using the other subs, GCing ourselves but having access to GC materials rates?

Apologies if this is confusing but I'm hoping others that have gone the GC it yourself route can share their experience in terms of cost AND anyone who knows what the typical discount a GC would receive when buying things (our kitchen cabs are custom but we would need everything else from sinks, and faucets to sheetrock to beams).

Thanks SO much

BTW we're in the Bay Area (San Jose) if that matters

Comments (12)

  • 19 years ago

    You better hire him quick. He'll be out of business before you know it. Part of the GC's profit margin is the markup of materials. You can't run a business just charging for labor.
    Ron

  • 19 years ago

    I disagree with the above poster. My GC gave me a fair price for overseeing the project, submitting plans for permits, etc., selecting and coordinating subs (electric, HVAC and tile/granite installers and fabricators). He supervised his own crew (anywhere from 2 to 3 regular guys who were here every day doing everything from framing to plumbing to painting).

    My GC gave me a budget for fixtures, but let me take advantage of his contractor's discount with no mark-up (He gave me his card to use. I found that the contractors' discounts varied anywhere from zero to a 10-30 percent discount, depending on the place). I usually found better deals on my own, though, through Ebay, Craigslist, web searches and Gardenweb recommendations). If I wanted anything additional (we did a ton of additional lighting), my GC didn't take an additional mark-up over his subs; I negociated directly with them). If I had my own subs I wanted to use, my GC would back out that portion of the bid and I'd pay the subs directly (e.g., I used my own tile guy, granite fabricator and flooring person and got credit for all of these).

  • 19 years ago

    arelitas mom,your experience was definetely the exception and not the rule.Good for you in the days where builders claims of going belly up when they dont get their mark ups is shaky at best,imho.I understand a builders mark up, but is something that is highly abused these days.

  • 19 years ago

    my husband is a remodeling contractor that does NOT mark up for materials but charges the customer the exact cost and runs his business on labor alone AND he charges below average for the area. He does all his own work and doesn't have any employees so that must be the key.

  • 19 years ago

    Where I live, GCs don't get much in the way of discounts anymore. They used to, but the big-box stores changed all that. If you go to HD/Lowe's as a GC, they might give you a bigger credit limit and preferential service, but you'll pay the same as the weekend warrior does. GCs do still get some discount, maybe 10%, at some of the lighting and plumbing stores in town, but that's about all. Appliance stores, zip. And even the lighting and plumbing places will often give a homeowner the GC discount if the job is big enough, or sometimes just for the asking.

    I will say this: having recently been forced into the position of GC'ing the completion of my house (because the builder abandoned the job), think hard about how much your time is worth to you before you take on that task. You may find that the incredible amount of time you have to put in to save 20K off of a GC's fee is not worth it in the end. (Provided you have a reputable builder. If you have one like ours was...)

  • 19 years ago

    Our local places all give the contractor rate to a homeowner purchasing materials. Since the cost of materials keeps going up, we usually have the materials billed directly to us. Workers still do the footwork of ordering what they want or need. We can keep better track of the expenses and what can be returned if not used.

    We have only done remodels, not building an entire house.

    Gloria

  • 19 years ago

    Hire a GC! I have worked as a sub for a couple of clients who GC'd their own projects when I was starting out and I don't have enough space to summarize the stupid mistakes they made. You pay for the GC's experience in assessing potential conflicts and problems, seeing the big picture as opposed to the limited vision of each sub (who will each lead you down their path of self interest, conflicting with every other one), using subs they know well as professionals and work well with, knowing the best materials to use, who to buy from and who/what to avoid, knowing how to parlay the building inspector/permit process and effectively solving any problems as they arise (which will).

    Would you as a civilian assume the role of platoon leader in the army tomorrow without experience?

    Would you assume the role of any other job you haven't performed before tomorrow?

    Enough preaching.

    I don't mark up materials as I follow my overhead costs in other ways, such as a total margin, plus itemizing.

    BUT, if I have to pick up materials or do any extra work or extend my credit to purchase them, yes I will charge accordingly and often the contractor's discount allows me this without too much pain for the customer.

    I do get some discounts from some local lumber yards and millers, but again, a discount is not the driving factor for my choice of what suppliers to buy from, nor do I mark up as a rule.

    suntoamom: that's good that your husband can afford to operate that way, if I run my business as labor only and as a one-man operation, I would barely be able to feed myself.

    I'd also be bored to death.

  • 19 years ago

    Most general contractors in the Cleveland are are getting 35-45 bucks an hour.
    The one I use passes his discounts along to me. I have gotten him a lot of jobs.

    Lowes.... I had a $2000 bath order ready to be delivered... asked for the discount .. no sorry ...
    OK cancel the order... OH, ok ahhh..hold on, let me check for you....
    sure 10% discount no problem... we'll deliver today..
    OK thank you.... ( saved me $200)

    Scott

  • 19 years ago

    I love this thread....and I will confirm that the era of the big material discounts for GC's has been over for a long time. We don't have an account that offers us a 10% discount. We do receive the occasional early pay discount of about 2% and I can assure you those vendors are paid before the ink on their invoices is dry.

    As for contracting your own project I can tell you this story. We were contacted by someone who was moving into our area to do some minor work. We did the small project at cost hoping for future work....she kept calling and asking for information and referrals to our subcontractors because she wanted to "save the markup". So we gave her some names. She calls back a few months later with an emergency water leak on a Sunday....we headed down to her house which is an hour drive each way, found the leak, shut down the water and went home. She calls the next day and wants the name of our plumber to "save the markup". Our plumber was busy and couldn't accomodate her needs that day so she calls us back complaining and we bail her out again by calling the plumber and having them onsite in an hour. The moral of this story is....with a GC you are getting long term relationships with the subs and material suppliers not just a friendly face on the job. Without our connections the response time is slower and the job isn't as efficient... not that subcontractors are unresponsive to homeowners but their bread and butter is GC's

    In closing...the client is still calling and asking for information. We have spent countless hours on the phone with her explaining construction process etc and helping her to "save the markup". Do you think our unbilled for time will pay off someday?

    Good luck!

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks to all who responded. We did sign a contract with a GC that we really liked, had good refs (of course) and we felt a connection with. I feel we've got the best of both worlds in that he will install whatever we purchase and he'll give us his discount when its better than what I can find. He doesn't seem irritated by this and we feel comfortable that things will be handled as quickly as possible and the work will be quality.
    It's a relief actually to know that with this scale of project we will have the help of a pro !

    Thanks again for all the replies :-)

    Onward ! Demo started today and we're off and running.

  • 19 years ago

    You have a great attitude that is very respectful,bellamy.
    word of mouth is everything, but what i can't figure out is that after driving an hour, why didn't you just fix the leak? Just a thought.

  • 19 years ago

    Here in NYC, I can get a trade discount just about anywhere just by telling them that I'm working with a contractor or architect (which I am doing). The discount (on plumbing fixtures, tiles, etc.) has usually been 25%. My GC and the subs have offered to buy things for me using their discount or I can just use their names. They have never tried to mark anything up.