Software
Houzz Logo Print
ejr2005

Leaf Covers for Gutters

20 years ago

Does anyone have any recommendations for those covers that go over gutters to prevent leaves from getting into them. Do they work? Do they cause other problems that we should be aware of?

Comments (13)

  • 20 years ago

    In my opinion, cheap plastic gutter shields work about as well as anything. Gutter-Guard, Gutter-Cap, Gutter-Helmet and so forth cost more than they're worth.

  • 20 years ago

    If you search the forum, there are at least two very length threads with info about gutter guards. Like mag77, we've had very good experiences with the cheap plastic gutter guards...we purchased the ones with the mesh overlay, because we have a huge pine needle problem in addition to leaves.
    Lots of very strong opinions on this issue!

  • 20 years ago

    I just bought some 3 foot vinyl sections full of little diamond pattern cutouts at HomeDepot for about $1.25 each . Replacing the plastic roll mesh that works fine until a branch falls into it and gets tangled - quite a bother to remove smallest branch and get the screen back in nicely.
    Oak Trees here, lots of em.

  • 20 years ago

    Mikie..I haven't had anything happen like that, yet. But the mesh stuff is just mounted to the same 3-ft. vinyl sections that you bought, just costs a bit more. Lowe's sells them either just like you bought, or the same with the mesh attached to the top. I would think that it would be easier to just replace the whole 3-ft. section, rather than trying to re-mount the mesh.

  • 20 years ago

    Following is a repost.

    Have experience with Leafguard, Gutterhelmet, and
    gutterguard.

    Have found them to all work well. What your friend says is true, but a clogged gutter will run over a LOT more. I have not found overrun to be an issue with any of them.

    My preference is Gutterguard, but it is the most expensive! Has the largest profile to the gutter and can move the most water with the fewest downspouts. The covers are about 10' long segments which can be replaced individually if needed.

    Gutterhelmet does a fine job but must be fitted under the second row of shingles. A plus for it is it can fit on current gutters, thus not as expensive. It also has a bit of a different look, which we did find to be a problem.

    Leafguard does fine but due to the smaller profile gutter, it requires more downspouts. Without enough downspouts, it can overflow during extremely heavy rain.

    Valleys can be a bit problematic with any of them, but a diverter can be added to help in that area.

    Currently I have Leafguard on the front of our house, and Gutterguard on the back. The front, done some time ago, has short runs. When we did an addition and reroofed the back we decided to go with Gutterguard as there were some 70' runs where I only wanted a downspout at each end.

    First installed the helmet about 9 years ago, never have cleaned a gutter since.

    Have also tried just about all the other ones that clip on and don't work, and were a waste of time and money.


    Paul

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks everyone. I realized I wasn't clear. We already have the gutters, so we just need something that goes over them. So far it looks like Gutterhelmet might work. And maybe the cheap plastic gutter shields. Any other thoughts?

  • 20 years ago

    I bought my parents something like a gutter brush for their tallest gutters that they always save for me to clean out when I am home. I don't think they installed them yet, yes you guessed it, they are waiting for me. I found out about them on HGTV I want that show. They were not cheap BUT if I get better info about how they work I can certainly let you know......see below for more info

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Gutter Brush as seen on HGTV

  • 20 years ago

    Hey Pewl,

    Since you have tried all of the other gutter protection devices, did you ever try the Leaf Relief guard by Alcoa? Did it work for you?

  • 20 years ago

    Otis,

    No. But, from experience I've had with several different homes and different systems, I probably would not give it a try. Looks like it may be fine for only leafs, but would not want to count on it in an area of Pines.

    Paul

  • 20 years ago

    Does anyone have prices per foot for installed Gutter Helmets?

  • 20 years ago

    I have some of the plastic sections with the diamond shape holes. While they may work for some types of materials (large leaves) they don't work very well with oaks and pines, or other small debris. One of the reasons is that the leaves get caught in the holes, and they are too large to fall through, but they decay while stuck in the holes and then the tiny bits fall through. I am getting replacements. I am thinking of Waterfall or something like that. Try egutter.com they have a good selection of most everything made.

  • 20 years ago

    The only thing those gutter screens do is make it harder to clean out your gutters when they get clogged.

    I personally installed those screens from HD a while back - took a lot of effort, tore up my hands, tore up my jeans (sitting on the roof). The gutters still kept getting clogged - I have a lot of oak and maple trees. Finally, I had my gutters replaced with LeafGuard - no problems since (at least none that I know of yet, LOL).

  • 18 years ago

    try going to www.leafdeflector.com. just like gutter helmet but half the price