Ok, it's definetely going to be Hale Navy in the bathroom. I did samples of HN and the next one up, Newburyport Blue, but the NB was blue, not navy. (DH insisted on seeing NB, so I humored him, but there never was a doubt it was going to be HN.)

So...my question. Did you use it in flat or eggshell? I don't want shine at all. The BM man told me to tell the painter eggshell, but I am concerned it will have too much shine to it. This is a windowless bathroom, but the large window in my guest room throws light on one wall of the bathroom and I don't want that wall to look shiny. I'm sure the dark red on the walls now must be flat paint, no shine at all. I'm not worried about spots getting on the paint to clean up; this is a guest bath/powder room.

Anyone else with an opinion is more than welcome to weigh in, please.