Software
Houzz Logo Print
newhome2008_gw

help choosing patio chairs

15 years ago

HI

My new garden/patio is a work in progress. So far, I have a cedar table which we will let age naturally and metal dining chairs. I have been searching for 4 all-weather wicker chairs for around the fireplace area - they need to be the right size, colour and style. This has proven difficult and I need to be right because they need to last a long time.

I have brought home a chair from pottery barn and it is the right size and colour but I am not sure about the style. I like it and it is comfortable but not the style I was looking for. It also only comes with white pillows, but I can recover them later.

First some pictures, here is the patio (ignore the stack of brown metal chiars at the end of the table - they are being sold):

And here is the chair in question, also seen above):

My dining chair:

Here is what I had in mind - a lower back and rounded arms:

I have found several that are close but turn out to be the wrong colour or too big:

What do you think? Does the chair look good with the table and dining chairs? Would I be better to wait and see if next year I can find the style I had in mind - would that look better? Is the chair odd? :)

Thanks in advance!

Comments (22)

  • 15 years ago

    I like the big wicker "wing chair" (it looks a little like a wing chair to me!) It looks very comfy, which is what I am sure you want there in front of the fire. I like the second wicker chair as well... it doesn't look as comfortable, but I bet it is less expensive. I feel like I see that second wicker chair everywhere!

  • 15 years ago

    Wicker, really? Hmm, I guess I don't see that at all with what you have going on.

    I think you have an AMAZING space there! I am so jealous.

    But put 4 of the rather bulky wing chairs by the fireplace and it is going to feel a bit crowded, but also too traditional with the rest of the space. I just don't think either of those has the style and panache that the rest of the patio does.

    The PB Chesapeake chair would be my choice, at least from that source.

    chesapeake chair

    Or perhaps a woven chair that has a bit less bulk, a bit of the same contemporary feel in your chairs and fireplace and the clean lines of the whole space.

  • 15 years ago

    The first wicker chair appears to look more comfortable but I'm not too keen on those "wings". They look large esp from the side view. The second wicker chair appears less formal but too bottom heavy with the wicker enclosing the bottom sides. Hard choice.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the responses so far.

    It is a wing chair - that is what I would call it too and the back is quite high (the seat is low so when you sit in it, it is over your head) and the wings do stick out (you have to look around them). DH's opinion is "they are fine" but I am still second guessing them.

    Les - Thanks! It is definitely a work in progress and only 2 years old. Our growing season is short so the plants will take awhile to fill in. We are building a screen along the fence this weekend to block off the neighbours view into our yard. About the chairs - I like traditional but not too much, and I am not sure about the wing chairs. Maybe like schoolhouse said - too formal...

    Hope to hear what a few other people think...I do not want to make a mistake and yet I have other people like my DH and my mom saying they are fine. Maybe I should wait and keep looking even if it means next year.

  • 15 years ago

    What a fabulous space! You've done a great job with it so far!

    I agree with les, I'm not really seeing either of those chairs in the space. The space is really contemporary. I could see something a bit rustic, but not really traditional. We get a lot of use out of our lounge chaise and I'm wondering if you would consider doing a pair of those instead of the 4 chairs. Here are a few other chairs to consider:

    http://www.cb2.com/outdoor-furniture/outdoor/sawyer-chair/f5652

    http://www.westelm.com/products/dexter-outdoor-lounge-chair-g311/?pkey=coutdoor-accent-tables-chairs

  • 15 years ago

    I think the rounded back chairs are a really nice complement to the cafe type chairs you have going. I think it's bringing an eclectic vibe.

  • 15 years ago

    htnspz - I think eclectic is what I am going for, not really contempory - once the dining table ages weathers and turns grey it will help get that look. And my thought about the rounded type chairs was the same as yours - they compliment the dining chairs well. If everyone loved the wing chairs I would go for them, but I am going to return them - too expensive to be not quite right and I agree with whoever said they are a bit bulky looking. I will have to keep looking and waiting.

    This was helpful because it helped confirm in my mind that something was not right with the chairs. And, so the search continues!

  • 15 years ago

    What a marvelous patio space! I like the combination of the table with those chairs, too. I am linking to a Crate and Barrel chair that might be similar to what you want. It looks like the color would go really well with your dining chairs and may not be as big as the wing chairs. There is also a smaller version on the website that could work. I am loving the purple cushion, too!

    Here is a link that might be useful: c&b chair

  • 15 years ago

    Hi Newhome2008, Love your space, (ooh! an outdoor fireplace!) especially your dining chairs. If you want to mimic their arched top, Home Depot has an option in faux wicker. I bought them in white late last season, and I must say they're not too big, and they're very comfortable, although they may be too dark for your space. Teh website says they're online only, but the stores had them on the floor last season.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Home Depot faux wicker chair

  • 15 years ago

    You are so lucky that you have a Pottery Barn near you that you can bring stuff home to try. I love your patio and what you have done so far. Below is another PB suggestion that has the rounded back that you are looking for and isn't a real large chair. What I think is an added bonus is that they swivel so guests can turn and talk to people where ever they are.

    http://www.potterybarn.com/products/palmetto-all-weather-wicker-occasional-swivel-chair-honey/?pkey=cpalmetto-outdoor

  • 15 years ago

  • 15 years ago

    Hi - sorry for the delayed reply, I could not get to the computer last night.

    Tina - not too dark at all. My DH actually thinks dark would be good. I did not see them at HD here...I'll have to look again.

    cyn427 - Yes! I LOVE that C&B chair and it was the first one I brought home - right size, right shape, and very comfortable and (I thought) the right colour BUT when we brought it home the colour, for some reason, looked bad with our rocks and it turned this taupey greyish colour with yellow undertones that was not looking too great so we gave up on them (even DH who does not always have an opinion said "that does not look good"). I do think they are exactly what I am looking for though - maybe I will have to revisit them again.

    Zoey - I never considered that one - I guess because they do not have it at the store to see, but maybe I will investigate. The arms have a good shape - I'll have to see how deep they are.

    Thanks!

  • 15 years ago

    Well, darn. On my screen the color looked just right! I hate when that happens. Hope you find the perfect thing soon. It will be worth waiting for.

  • 15 years ago

    I also am not seeing 4 chairs in your space. To get the comfort you want I think it will take up a lot of room. It is nice to have some open patio space, esp. if you entertain at all so people can mingle. I would like to see you mix it up a bit and add a sofa, chase and or ottoman into the mix, perhaps a small round table for drinks, etc.

    I got a nice wicker set from Costco a few years ago. It included two chairs each with it's own ottoman and a small table. This works well for us as we can lounge on the chairs and put our feet up if there is one or two of us there, or if a larger group, then a few more will perch on one of the ottoman. The small table has a glass top which is nice for drinks, book, etc.

  • 15 years ago

    valinsv - I originally wanted a sofa and 2 chairs, but I thought 4 chairs might be better for entertaining because the sofa would be quite small and I did not think that 2 people would very often sit on it....it would be more comfortable for us though - I would like to be able to lounge on a sofa. Maybe because I have space for people to sit on the hearth and also the wide stairs leading down to the patio, the sofa would be okay. A sofa would have to go perpendicular to the fireplace because of the stairs - either by the lawn or cutting the patio in half and I thought that might mess things up too??

    Size is a limiting factor definitely - I've seen some nice chairs that were just too big....when you build a patio you always think it is going to be big enough and then it could have been bigger - although we were limited by the shallowness of our yard.

    Here is a picture showing a bit more of the space.

    Now, I am really glad I did not rush into things - so much to think about :)

  • 15 years ago

    Barrel chairs are comfy...but not bulky I've linked one below that MIGHT work for you. (Not sure about the color.) If not that one then take a look at the other Lloyd/Flanders vinyl wicker stuff...

    My Ace Hardware caries Lloyd and Flanders. Perhaps someone near you does as well.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Lloydflanders vinyl barrel chair.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree that 4 chairs might be a tight squeeze, but it might be the picture angle. Can you simulate the size of the chairs with indoor chairs to see how it all fits? Perhaps 2 chairs and matching ottomans would work (ottomans can always be used for seating if needed). Don't know where you live,but here in the NE,outdoor furniture is well picked over by this time of year.Two yrs ago, I found all weather wicker sofa/chairs at Sears (I was surprised).It is more reasonably priced than Lloyd Flanders and a nice quality.

  • 15 years ago

    Hi again

    mjsee - nice chairs - unfortunatley lloyd flanders does not have a dealer in my city according to their website, but that style would work too.

    ratherbesewing - I do think there is more room than the picture shows (and it does not help that the wicker chair in the picture, which I returned, has such a high, bulky back). I did lay out indoor chairs as well as tape off lines on the patio and it seems fine - I just have to be careful not to get some of those mammoth chairs that are out there.

    I know stuff is quite picked over right now and I have pretty much resigned myself to waiting until next year - but if that means that I get soemthing great I'm okay with that! My kids are almost done school too and they won't want to be furniture shopping with me either :)

    I am thankful for everyone's help - when I returned the chair yesterday I actually felt good about it, instead of wondering if I was doing the right thing. I'll keep looking and being patient.

  • 15 years ago

    Go have a look at the cote de texas blog. She just did a write up about the kooboo (sp?) chairs that you like. She found some that are smaller, but I can't remember where they are from. I love the idea of grey wicker and I think, if they are the right scale, 4 chairs would look fantastic in front of the fire.

  • 15 years ago

    Could you turn the dining table the other direction? That would open up the space a bit more, and you could easily put a couch on the right side of the fireplace, back to the dining area, and get perhaps two chairs facing the couch, then a couple of small square ottomans or a long upholstered bench that could sit right in front of the fireplace, tucked next to it, for extra seating.

    Don't discount the fact that guests can also pull over the dining chairs near the fire, if you have left some room for that, particularly in front of the steps facing the fireplace.

    One other question. I think that is your grill that we see on the right side of the stairs? Is there a reason you didn't extend the patio so that you would not be walking on and standing on lawn when cooking and serving? Or will you be moving the grill over to the dining area?

  • 15 years ago

    daisychian - Hi! I did see that blog about the chairs. I think she got the smaller ones from overstock, which unfortunately does not ship larger items like furniture to Canada. But I know that style is popular so I am sure it will keep showing up at other retailers. What surprised me most, though, was that I think she put regular wicker outdoors which would never work here in our harsh climate - I need the all-weather wicker.

    les - We probably can turn the table - I will experiment (except it is heavy)! Yes, that is our grill and the reason we did not extend the patio larger was money :) It is super expensive here to have the stamped concrete done and my dh did not mind standing on the grass. We were starting with a completely blank slate (just a pile of dirt) because it is a new build, and things add up quickly so there had to be some compromises. The nice thing about the location is that you can not see the ugly barbeque from inside the house - unless we ever get the nice built-in outdoor kitchen set up :) but that is not happening any time soon! He is still part of the action right there.

  • 15 years ago

    Your patio is fabulous! What a wonderful outdoor space!

    We recently bought two " glider rockers" for the deck outside the MBR in the Charleston range of outdoor furniture made by North Cape International. They are available in a medium brown similar to the PB ones you've looked at, but you might find the darker expresso better complements your stone, weathering grey table and metal chairs.

    We bought these because DH and I went to a show house and he sat in these chairs on the porch and asked why we didn't have any chairs as comfortable as this? I promised to find the manufacturer and buy them, and finally did...he is very happy! Their specs seem large but they are actually smaller than we thought. Anyway, there's a link below. They are very good quality and in the medium price range for that type of thing at about $850 per chair with cushions. They really do last forever, we have two Lane Venture rockers in that same all-weather wicker on aluminum frames that are 12 years old and look brand new.

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{!gwi}}

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio