Software
Houzz Logo Print
formosalily

Constractor Dilemma...please help!

19 years ago

Here's the dilemma we are facing...

We had contracted parts of our home improvement project to a remodeling company, including replacement of roof and skylights. They started with interior work first ad did a fine at the beginning, but then the quality of their work started to go downhill for the most part of the interior job they eventually completed. After having multiple problems with their workmanship, DH and I just couldn't convince ourselves to entrust them with the roof over our house. The owner of the company agreed to void the roof contract if we desire except for the skylights.

Due to the unusual size of our existing skylights, we had to order new custom-sized skylights through this company for replacement. The skylights have been delivered to this company and are waiting to be installed at the time when our new roof is installed. We have the following options but none is good enough:

1. The owner agreed to let us pay for the skylights without installation if we so choose (over $3K for three 24"x72" american skylights). But we are concerned about having other contractor install the skylights purchased through a different contractor. We can already imagine the disaster we will have to deal with if there's any leakage after the new skylights are installed - the installation contractor would blame the product, and this company that ordered the product for us would blame the installation or the product, and the skylight company would blame the installation... do we worry too much?

2. We can proceed to have this remodeling company replace both roof and skylights, so this company can be held solely accountable if anything goes wrong after the installation. BUT we have no confidence in the quality of their job and feel strongly that we are going to regret this.

3. We asked the remodeling company about the possibility of installing the new skylights without replacing our roof. They said they can do it but they won't warrant their work because our roof is very old. Is this statement acceptable? (our existing roof and skylights have no leakage problems despite of their age.) Can we insist that they install the skylights to existing roof with warranty?

We know we always have the option of paying for the skylights without having them installed and then hire another company to replace our roof only. But $3k is not a small amount; on the other hand, we don't want to replace skylights that will introduce more costly problems later on...

Do we have other options that are better than any of the ones listed above? We need to make the decision ASAP, any suggestions are greatly appreciated.

Comments (4)

  • 19 years ago

    go with Option #1. Make sure the price they are charging you for the skylights is their cost and no mark-up involoved. To double check just find out the local supplier they ordered them from. Give them the same measurements and have them price them to you. They should match and if not then go back to the contractor and advise him you will pay for them at cost with no mark-up. He won't want to be stuck with $3k worth of skylights anymore than the next guy.

    Then hire a good roofing contractor who also can do skylights. The warranty should not be an issue as long as the skylights are brand new and measured properly. This should all work out.

  • 19 years ago

    The skylight mfgr should have a warranty on their product, but is only valid as long as the installation goes according to mfgrs install directions. So it doesn't really matter who installs the skylights as long as those mfgr's outlines are followed.That leaves the roof which is generally covered by the installer as far as leaking,followed by the roofing mfgr concerning any defects. You should have everything down in writing regardless of which avenue you take.I dont understand why the roof and skylights weren't done before approaching the inside work.

  • 19 years ago

    can you have the new roofers do the roof, and frame out the skylights as they do so? And then have the original guys install?

    But if you can get mfr's instructions, and mfr's warranty, I'd try to get a new person to install the whole thing.

  • 19 years ago

    There's no reason you can't find another contractor who will install the roof and the skylights and warranty them both.
    Ron