Software
Houzz Logo Print
provenance_gw

PICS -- need help choosing floor stain

17 years ago

We are finishing our house and the floors will be sanded, stained, and sealed next week. The floors are red oak. We are undecided on the stain, and would greatly appreciate any thoughts/suggestions.

Initially I had thought to keep them light, and maybe just do a clear coat on top. However, I've been having second thoughts. Maybe it would look better to do a darker maybe reddish brown color? We refinished the floors in our old house and they were a golden oak color, I would like not to have the orangey quality in our floors here.

As you can see in the pics, we have a lot of golds and earth tones throughout the house and I'm not sure what would look best with these. The trim is white throughout the house, we also have two double interior tapered columns off the entry area. We like the simplicity of mission style and our furniture is a mix of this and contemporary. We're still in need of nice downstairs furniture, but I'm thinking of going with darker mission/contemporary. Either espresso or dark reddish brown color.

Do you think we should keep the floors light or have them somewhat darker? We would also use the same stain on the stairway oak, the fireplace mantel/surround, and the front door (exterior side, the interior will be painted white).

If you have any thoughts on window treatments, these would also be very much appreciated. I'm not sure quite where to begin with all of this...this is the point where I'm really regretting not having a designer to advise us.

Thank you so much!

Amy

Here is a link that might be useful: House album

Comments (23)

  • 17 years ago

    For some reason your link didn't work for me. I tried it twice.

    The darker floors are more popular right now, but I like mine somewhere in the middle. Too dark shows too much dirt and too light shows too much dirt, IME. More medium tones show less. Maybe because they blend in the dark specks/threads and the light specks/threads that drop on them. Probably the most practical solution is take a cup of dirt from your back yard to the store and match that. lol!

    Sorry, no advice on WTs because I can't see your pics.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm sorry, I thought I fixed the link. This should work:

    Here is a link that might be useful: House pictures!

  • 17 years ago

    Hi,

    Thought i would show you what our oak looks like with just poly. Ours had alot of color variations from board to board that you could see while unfinished. We originally were going to go dark like you but once we saw it unfinished, we liked the simple color variations.

    Sorry about my dog in the pic but this is the best close up one I have in my photobucket!

  • 17 years ago

    IF you have a couple of scraps of unfinished flooring, go buy a couple of the small Minwax cans for 3 bucks apiece and make up some samples.
    Having lived with a very dark floor which we then refinished quite a few shades lighter I can tell you that the mid tones are much easier to keep clean. We used Minwax "Ipswich Pine" on our last home when we refinished and loved it-I think that color would suit the rest of your pallette really well.
    If you want to look at a darker shade, the floors in our new home are in Minwax "Provincial" which is a mid-dark brown. It has actually been easier to take care of than our old floors when they were a dark color. We didn't get to pick the color in the current home and we liked the house so much we didn't really worry too much about it-we figured at some point we would probably refinish anyway. Now we really like the Provincial-go figure.

  • 17 years ago

    One of my favorite colors for red oak is a mix of Minwax's "Red Chestnut" (about 1/3) and "Provincial" or "Chestnut" (2/3).

    They are "reddish", and look well-aged without being as intensely unnatural red as the straight "Red Oak".

    Another combo is a BIG can (quart) of Special Walnut with a couple of tablespoons of Red Mahogany (that stuff is INTENSE Irish Setter red). This gives a nice brown floor with a hint of red highlights.

    Definitely find some scraps of that style wood and test the stains. Some have a ghastly yellow overtone - more intense on a floor than on the small store sample.

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you to both of you...I just can't decide...Lazygardens, how do you think the combo of Minwax Red Chestnut and Provincial would look in our house, with the white trim?

    I just came back from SW paint store, where I spent a while talking with the salesperson. He said he thought a lighter color stain would work better with white trim on doors/windows and white treads/spindles on stairway. But when I questioned what furniture, he said oak...I like the darker oak mission style much better, have spent years with the old golden oak on EVERYTHING. Any suggestions of what stain would tie in white trim and yet darker furnitre?

    Amy

  • 17 years ago

    We replaced all our ugly flat panel doors and pine trim we used minwax Chestnut on the Red Oak doors. We have QS White Oak Floors but White Oak doors were too expensive.


  • 17 years ago

    I'm going to use Minwax English Chestnut on our floors, and it's a warm brown color. 1 coat is nice, but we're going with 2 for a richer color. Even with 2 coats, it's the same tone as the mahogany colored wood in my daughter's room, and hers doesn't show much as much dust and dirt as my sister's espresso stained floors.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm sorry I meant to say English Chesnut.

  • 17 years ago

    First what a beautiful home you have! We just installed a very similar (maybe even the same) slate in our bathroom, Indian Autumn and the colors do lend to the warm side. Actually can I ask what granite you installed? It too looks very similar to what we did. Even though the lighter floors are beautiful I think a darker color oak would work better with the slate. Especially if you enhance it. Are you going to just seal it or enhance it? We enhanced ours (twice) and love it. You may of seen it already as I've posted the pic of the floor a few times, but just in case you haven't here's a pic for reference

    {{!gwi}}

  • 17 years ago

    Lukkiirish, our granite is Golden River....thank you for posting your picture, I hadn't seen it before. Your room is beautiful. I loved our granite with all the veining. Which granite did you use?

    We do plan on sealing our slate. It looks dusty now, and we'd like to wash it often for a couple of months and then seal it to bring out more colors. Also have a little bit of a wet look to it. So you think that a darker stain would look better on the hardwood? Our downstairs is all open plan, so you see the slate on the fireplace and kitchen along with the hardwood. I don't want to go too dark though. I kind of liked a wood classic color called cinnamon. What do you have on the floors outside your bathroom?

    Amy

  • 17 years ago

    I don't know with white trim and dark oak furniture if I would go dark, but I'm afraid if you try for a midtone you'll end up with some red. Here is red oak hand rail with just Natural stain (no poly yet, but I imagine poly alone on your floor would bring out the red like Natural did here). Best thing to do is try different things on scrap wood if installer left you any.

    I love your house!

    {{!gwi}}

  • 17 years ago

    Another thought -- what does everyone think of going with a hardwood stain similar to the cabinet color in lukkiirish's photo? Her bath cabinets are similar to our kitchen cabs -- this color might be a nice tone in the medium range that might tie everything together. Is this a good idea or not?

    Amy

  • 17 years ago

    Provenance, Thank you so much, we put a threshold of matching grante (Golden Shore) and then have a freize carpet with browns and tans in the bedroom.

    Important to know: There are two kinds of sealers. Enhancer/sealer & Impregnator Sealer. To bring out the colors and get that wet look use Enhancer/Sealer. The other will dry and look just as it does now. Bill Vincent suggested Miracle 511, I found the best price at HD, but it's still pricey at 43.00/qt. You should be able to get 1 coat per qt. and 2 coats will darken it even more. The Miracle 511 Impregnator is also available at HD, and works well on the granite. Here's their website

    I think the Cinnamon color would be perfect. Not too dark and not too light.

    Your granite and slate are gorgeous, I hope you post a pic when it's done.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Miracle 511 Sealers

  • 17 years ago

    I forgot to include a picture of the granite (installed a week ago). We fell in love with it because it has a shape that looks like a shamrock and well being irish....LOL
    {{!gwi}}{{!gwi}}
    {{gwi:1476998}}

  • 17 years ago

    Amy, I just saw your comment about the cabinets, the color, is maple cognac, in person they do have a redish tint to them. If you used a similar stain, it's definately going to read different on oak but I converted the Minwax Oil Stain chart to a jpg, and think that there are a couple that would work beautifully. Red Chestnut is my favorite and seems very close to the color of your cabinets. I think it would be a little darker than the cinnamon, and look great as well with the slate.
    {{!gwi}}

    BTW, I looked up some slabs of your granite and love it! Knowing the way these colors make me feel when I'm in our bathroom I can guarantee you're going to love that kitchen when it's done, it's going to be so pretty.

  • 17 years ago

    I stripped the paint off my old front door last summer and stained it English Chestnut. It looks redder in real life than the color in the chart above.

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, I do think the red from the red oak is going to come through except *maybe* on a really dark stain. You can see the difference b/t Natural on the chart and Natural on my handrail.

    I do like the English Chestnut, but how will it look with your furniture? Do you have pics of the furniture?

    Maybe try Early American, Provincial, or Fruitwood on a sample and see how dark/red it comes out, and how it looks with furniture and cabinets?

  • 17 years ago

    I have English Chestnut on my red oak - one coat. I needed the floors to be lighter because my cabs are really dark. They definitely read red, but not too red. I worked on a spec house for resale, and on that red oak, we did a browner floor stain. I can't remember, but I want to say that it was either Special Walnut or Dark Walnut.

    English Chestnut in current kitchen
    {{!gwi}}

    Special or Dark Walnut in spec house
    {{!gwi}}

  • 17 years ago

    Oooooh...I love that walnut! Of course I'm biased, our kitchen has walnut flooring. It's just a great color, works with most anything.

  • 17 years ago

    Actually, most of our nice furniture is in the office/study and bedrooms -- those will be upstairs in the new house. Our current sofa sectional will be in the tv room downstairs. So...we still have to pick out new dining room set, stools, and living room furniture and can plan to get what will match the rooms.

    What I would love...darker mission oak furniture and/or contemporary in that same darker oak (with a slight reddish cast) or expresso finish. I'll try to take and post some pics of our dresser to show the finish tonight or tomorrow.

    I also just LOVED the Korean chest of drawers someone posted a pic of yesterday. Our daughter is Chinese, we have some Chinese drawings andwould like to put ina couple of Asian pieces as accents. What would all this mean for the floors, especially if we have the white trim? Any thoughts?

    I almost want to go with a lighter stain now, after thinking about it yesterday. One company has an Autumn Maple that is just a hair darker than golden oak but a slight auburn cast. Would contrast well with darker mission oak I mentioned. But the last couple of pictures of the walnut stain (posted yesterday) are gorgeous.

    Thank you all so much, all the comments have been so very helpful and I really appreciate them.

    Amy

  • 17 years ago

    Hi again -

    Too funny, that was me that posted the Korean chest from Craigslist. That's my English Chestnut red oak floor - the floor color looks off in that picture becase of the lighting.

    If I had to do it again, I'd have done the floor in walnut like I did the spec house because it's more neutral (to me). Either floor color would work IMO with Asian pieces and white trim.

    Here's an asian piece in my dining room in progress. I'm not sure if I'm going to keep that Asian armoire there - it might move to a bedroom now that I have the Tansu so closeby. I don't want to get too theme-y.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 17 years ago

    Lukkiirish-- Thank you for the advice on sealing our slate floors. We do want a slightly wet look on the slate when we're finished, not the dusty look it has now. We're still thinking about whether we'll seal the tumbled slate on the fireplace.

    Mom2Reese -- that is a beautiful floor, we really like the color of the English Chestnut. It looks like it has some golden undertones, but we like the neutral color of it. The cabinet and the table are the color of our dresser (upstairs), which is the furniture tone I'd like to go with in the dining and living areas.

    Did you do it yourself, or have someone do it for you? We are having someone do our floors, so I'm not sure if they'll be using Minwax with the same color names. They are sanding tomorrow and will do some color samples on Tuesday.

    By the way, my husband noticed your window trim, it is the same as in our new house. We went with the sanitary style with the slight overlap on top.

    Thank you so much,

    Amy