Software
Houzz Logo Print
kokomo61

When to replace the roof?

18 years ago

Our asphalt shingle roof is 21 years old - house built in 1987. While we have no sign of leaks or missing shingles, I'm seriously considering replacing the roof this year before any damage.

My wife wants to postpone the job until we HAVE to do it, but I'd like some opinions as to when to replace.....other than missing shingles (which there maybe 2-3 tabs on the entire roof) or gaps (which I don't see).

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    If you are going over the existing if you currently have one layer, then you are going to want to do that well before the existing start to get brittle and cup. It's a good idea to fill in the missing tabs before the re-cover and i always use 30# felt between the new and old, cut back the existing shingle overhangs, and run new drip edge. Be sure to check all flashings and roof jacks as well to see if they need attention or replaced.

    Overall, i always recommend stripping the old down to the sheathing. This gives you a chance to tighten up the nailing on the sheathing and repalce any areas that are negative. Also gives you a chance to replace any needed flashing areas, although you can still do that on a re-cover as mentioned above. This is a far more involved effort and of course more money.

    20 years is about the life expectancy of 3-tab shingles, imo, but it is dependent on where you live. Out here in the desert, you can expect about half the life span of mfgr's life span claims. A correct install factors in as well.

  • 18 years ago

    House is in Northern Virginia / Mid-Atlantic area. Climate is fairly mild, though summers can be 90+.

    Replacement will be a tear-off. I'd rather do the job right instead of covering up an existing problem. I will also spec out checking/repairing any flashing as part of the job.

    My guess is that 21 years is a good run for the roof and that I shouldn't try to get too many more years out of it before replacing it.

  • 18 years ago

    if you plan to rip off the old anyway, you could wait, you say you have no leaks and a couple missing ones, you could fix the missing ones and buy some time. Of course you are not waiting until they come off in bunches, but if they're laying flat and no leaks, me, I'd wait.

  • 18 years ago

    I would wait....you could always have a hail storm...
    I replaced a roof a few years back and and within 3 months wwe had a very destructive hail storm. Because my roof was new, there was no visible damage....but you know it shortened it's life. People with 10 year old roofs had insurcnce buy a new one...
    If it looks good and you don't have blistering and a big loss of "gravel", I would hang on as long as you can.
    Linda C

  • 18 years ago

    Hang on as long as you can and hope for hail or wind damage. Let your insurance company help with the cost.

  • 18 years ago

    If the shingles haven't shrunk, are not curling and have little or no granular loss I would think you could get at least 5 more years out of the roof.
    I have a customer who had a 3 tab shingle on the house when he moved in, in 1974. He finally changed it in 2007. He had no leaks, no curling and very little shrinkage. He did have granular loos in a section or two. The old roof never leaked and no roof sheathing needed to be replaced.
    On your house, I would replace the missing or damaged shingles though.
    Ron

  • 18 years ago

    Now would be a good time to start looking for a good roofing contractor, rather than wait until it's a rush job due to leaks.
    If you can get up on the roof, I'd check to see how brittle the shingles are. Along with curling and loss of gravel, that would be another indicator of the coming of the end of their life span.

  • 18 years ago

    We replaced our roof a few months ago -- in North Carolina. Our house was built in 1985. Although it was not urgent, I didn't want to wait until it started to fail. We tore off the old stuff, and had defective wood replaced, new flashing put in, and ridge vents, which are required in new construction and strongly recommended in remodels because they keep the attic cooler in summer and so the roof lasts longer, and your heating/cooling bills are lower.

    One thing we were told that you might want to consider for the near term: those collars that are fitted around vent pipes where they abut the roof do not last even half as long as the roof itself. I did not know that and just when we had the roof redone I noticed that one of the collars had worn off completely so that, when I looked up in the attic, I could see the sky!!

    We also had new gutters and downspouts put in and something called Leaf Relief, which prevents leaves from getting into the gutters.

    All told, we might have eeked out a few more years from the old roof, and just patched up the worn collars. But we got our value out of the old one and didn't see the point in waiting.

  • 18 years ago

    Kokomo, to be fair, you have to let the spouse see the result of your "poll", I think she won,:)

  • 18 years ago

    You need to know what your wife's criteria are for a new roof. Is it when the water is dripping on her side of the bed?

  • 18 years ago

    Just tell her you want a new white energyStar rated roof to save on the power bill.

Sponsored
Kuhns Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Central Ohio's Trusted Home Remodeler Specializing in Kitchens & Baths