Software
Houzz Logo Print
kevin1900

Who is responsible for broken window

20 years ago

Checking out the addition to our home, we spotted a cracked pane in one of the new windows.

When I pointed it out to the contractor he said he noticed it too, and that his people did not break it, therefore someone in my family must have. This response surprised me as he didn't seem to even consider that the damage would be his responsibility to fix.

Who is normally considered responsible for any accidental damage before a job is complete?

For what it's worth, the only time we would be in the addition (which even now is still cut off from the rest of the house) would be to check on progress of work and answer the builder's questions. No one but the builder performed any work there, other than taking measurements.

I believe but am not sure that it is the inner pane of the window that is cracked.

Possibly an improper installation would do damage?

Thanks for any advice.

Comments (11)

  • 20 years ago

    Think I'd ask him how much to fix it... then withhold paying that amount. When he complains tell him nobody in your family broke it, he hasnt finished his job as far as your concerned.

    Small things on new construction get screwed up all the time and the appropiate sub notices and just assumes another idiot sub did it and simply grumbles to himself and fixes it, no questions asked. He hasnt finalized nor finished his job ... if leaving it with a busted window.

  • 20 years ago

    My new windows came with a 1 year breakage guaranty - no matter what the cause - have your builder check oiut this option.

  • 20 years ago

    Do not repair the window. Let him know that you expect him to make it right. No arguments, no heated debate...remember, it's simple business.

    In the meantime, make inquiries (through your builder or through a third party, your choice) to see if it is covered by warranty. If not covered by warranty make inquiries as to how much it would cost to repair the window.

    Include its repair on the end-of-job punchlist that is to be completed before you give the builder the final maount of money owed for the job.

    If he fails to repair it, then deduct the amount it will cost you to have it repaired from his final bill. Include s copy of the window repair/replacement invoice with your final check to him.

    Do NOT ask him how much to repair and then give him the go-ahead to make the repair, and then withold that amount from your final payment. Askng and then authorizing implies that you are agreeing to pay him to do the repair. Witholding would then put you in the wrong.

  • 20 years ago

    There is a practical, diplomatic, right way to do this.

    Tearing down a relationship with your GC or others is not the way. Blaming it on someone isn't the right way.

    Describe the crack. Is it corner to corner? Is it nested tightly in the corner? ??

    What type of window? Wood or Vinyl?

    Glass cracks! Often! IG unit stress cracks are a common warranty issue among window manufacturers.

    I'll wait for your answer.

    Michael

  • 20 years ago

    Things like this happen all the time. This should be a new window free from defects. Ask him how can you "show off" the completed job to your neighbors with a busted window? It's just good business practice (if for no other reason) for the GC to take care of it.

  • 20 years ago

    The GC is responsible to have it fixed/replaced. 2 of our windows arrived with cracks. Our GC called the window company; it took them 3 weeks but they came out and replaced the broken windows.

  • 20 years ago

    I talked to him yesterday explaining very simply that I would expect to take possession of the addition without defect and he agreed to fix it but acted like he was the injured party.

    These are Andersen 200 (I think) windows which makes them wood. I'll tell the contractor to check on the warranty possibility.

    I'll have to check again but I believe the crack runs from the corner to the center.

  • 20 years ago

    Call Andersen and tell them you have a stress cracked window. The warranty information needed is on the bug (Etching) in a corner on each piece of glass. The bug contains numbers that reference what window and glass size you have. They will ship a new piece of glass to you no questions asked. If you feel uncomfortable have your GC call it in. Anyone dealing with Andersen knows they are one of the best warranty companies around. Here's their number: 1-888-888-7020 Good Luck!!!

  • 20 years ago

    It's possible it arrived on site with the crack and no one noticed till it was in. However it happened the contractor can get a replacement. No ? asked.

  • 20 years ago

    If you want to replace it yourself.
    ou just want to make sure you have gloves on, and this is really sharp, and just pick up all the large pieces up out of the way. Determine what kind of window it is. On this one, the window insets inside the frame, so you're going to have to remove the whole entire frame to replace this window. We just slide the window over some to take out the frame, and lift it up and out real carefully so that you don't cut yourself or any of this glass falls. And then you can take it outside and you can proceed with replacing the window pane itself.

    And we have to take the frame apart. There's some screws set up in the corners of each side- just want to unscrew those. Be careful not to cut yourself. Sometimes, near the end, it gets hard to get the screw completely out. And then, you just want to slowly pull the frame apart like that. And you're going to do each corner exactly the same way until you have all of the glass falling out. And you'll have a rubber seal that you'll want to keep to slide the new glass into when you reassemble the frame.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Broken window

  • 20 years ago

    Our replacement windows came with a 50 year breakage warranty -- regardless of cause. Sounds unbelievable, but it's true.

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio