Software
Houzz Logo Print
miamicuse

A unique drainage problem from a unique house

20 years ago

I have a unique roof drainage problem. I have talked to roofers, drain companies, gutter companies, and they can't help me because they are all specialized in their own area and cannot take a step back and look at the problem completely and offer a solution. A few of them said I need an architect...I am not sure, seems I have an engineering problem, although what I am thinking of doing would be really really ugly. So I think I will try it here and see if anyone may offer any advise. I apologize in advance

for the long post.

The house is a wrap around house with a center courtyard like this:

http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2005-10/1090906/IMG_0153.JPG

On three sides are gabled tiled roof, therefore half the water runoff will flow into the direction of the courtyard, the top of the courtyard is enclosed in a screen, therefore in between there is a gutter. It is not a normal gutter but one that has a asphalt surface (like those of a flat roof)

and in some spots it feels "spongy" when I walked on it, indicating moisture beneath it. Like this:

http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2005-10/1090906/IMG_0164.JPG

Due to this reason, the gutter does not have a smooth grade and hence when it rains it does not flow quickly to the drain. I think I need to fix this gutter, but in talking to several gutter companies they told me they do not service this type of gutters, they only install new aluminum gutters. I asked them who I should call, they don't know. Now is this a gutter problem or a roofing problem? Is this "gutter" really a portion of the roof or is it a specialized custom gutter?

Now, on the front side the roof is not gabled. It is flat. There is a section connecting the two sides and below it looks like this:

http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2005-10/1090906/IMG_0152.JPG

Above however is asphalt roof like this:

http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2005-10/1090906/IMG_0165.JPG

and it has an overhanging section extending out to cover the car when parked:

http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2005-10/1090906/IMG_0147.JPG

this is what it looks like directly above:

http://img.villagephotos.com/p/2005-10/1090906/IMG_0166.JPG

This flat section has no gutter. So it drains at the edges, worse, when the other gutters at the bottom of the gabled roof are not draining quick enough, the water backs up into this flat section, and pours down below like a bucket.

The courtyard is covered with bricks and have three drains on each side, except the front area where the problem is. So water ponds up and gets inside the sliding glass door and the floor gets wet...a big mess.

Now I am wondering if this is a grading problem of the courtyard, a lack of gutter in the flat section of the roof, a grading problem in the existing gutter, or may be the existing downspouts (2 of them) are not enough to take

the water quick enough. I have no idea where the downspouts go, they go into the courtyard and I presume they continue below the slab and tie into either a storm drain or the sewer...not sure.

What kind of professional do I need to look at all these issues all together, and fix it? Is it an architect? a knowledgeable roofer or I need an engineer?

My first thought would be to install a metal gutter system around the perimter of the flat, overhanging portion. But in talking to the gutter company, that section has so many 90 degree turns that to proper drain the water at an acceptable rate, I will need four downspouts and that would make the front of the house very very ugly. Plus I cannot imagine a wrap around gutter on this...yuck!

Any advise would be appreciated.

Thanks and sorry again for the long lengthy post.

MC

Comments (3)