Software
Houzz Logo Print
chickadeead

Pix please: baseboards without shoe molding

18 years ago

All,

We are building a home and are almost at the point of installing the baseboards (white). The floors are natural red oak hardwood throughout, except for bathrooms and laundry room. Can you show me pictures of baseboards that do NOT have shoe molding (or toe molding or quarter-round molding)between the floor and the baseboard? I'm trying to decide whether or not to use the shoe moldings in our home, but I'd like to see pictures. (I've always lived in homes with shoe molding, so that isn't hard for me to picture.) Thank you!

Comments (12)

  • 18 years ago

    Chic, in the condo I just sold, the only shoe-moulding I had was around the wood floors, not the tile. I recently built a home in Austin, and the shoe moulding is used with wood AND tile.

    I think it's whatever YOU want~both are acceptable. IMO, it's used when wood/tile have been over cut, so basically when the cutting isn't perfect. Again, okay with me, at least mistakes can be covered up.

  • 18 years ago

    I admit it, I have very strong negative feelings about shoe (quarter-round) molding. I think it looks like it's covering up a sloppy flooring installation, and it pushes furniture like freestanding bookcases even further off the walls than the baseboards already do. JMO, of course.

    From my previous house, sold last winter (1994 Cape, hardwood floors installed 2005; baseboards were removed and reinstalled over new flooring):
    {{!gwi}}

    Same house, tile floors installed 2006 (plumber's mess notwithstanding, this is the best picture available of baseboard):
    {{!gwi}}

    Current house, 1900 vernacular, original pine floors:

  • 18 years ago

    No shoe molding in my house either, and I tend to agree with johnmari that it looks like a cover up to a poor installation.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a freind who purchased a 100 year-old historical home last year with original wood and tile. There is shoe moulding in all the areas with the tile and wood.

    My Father, who was a perfectionist, installed shoe moulding when he retiled the kitchen/bathroom floors back in the '60's. He referred to it as the finishing touch.

    As far as it being used to cover up shoddy work, you could also look at it from another perspective by saying the trim person is being lazy by not using it. I don't see it as right OR wrong, just a personal preference.

  • 18 years ago

    To me, using shoe molding looks very "finished," and I like it. It should always be the colour of the baseboard, not the floor, as that gives the baseboard a heftier profile and looks nicer. Shoe molding does keep furniture away from the walls, but I think that is a positive, not a negative.

  • 18 years ago

    I don't like the shoe molding. In my old house I didn't have it. In our new one we have the shoe molding. It looks fine either way.

    The reason I don't like it is because of furniture that has legs that make it stick out further from the wall due to that little molding. I hate the gap you get. I tend to have furniture like shaker style where the legs cause this gap. Never thought about it before having shoe molding in this house.

    Here is from my old house.

    {{!gwi}}

    The difference in color between baseboards wasn't as obvious in real life as you never faced the FP due to the layout of the house. Just showing this one as that is all I could find that showed tile too.
    {{!gwi}}

  • 18 years ago

    We didn't put it in either in our remodel. I didn't want it as I felt it would just be one more area to collect dust. And now that it has been mentioned that it keeps the furniture away from the walls that would be another reason. That may be OK for shorter pieces like beds and sofas, but for anything tall like bookcases or curio cabinets that gap in the back looks terrible enough with just a baseboard.

  • 18 years ago

    I've been wondering about this, actually. I never saw a house without them until I got to Maine. (My experience is only with pre-WWII houses.) I chalked it up to a regional difference.

  • 18 years ago

    Have a bunch of floors (hardwood and tile) with no shoe molding. I like the look, but don't have a problem with it. I may end up with some.

    This is the Dining Room

    The floor in the entry is tumbled travertine bordered by wood. Then there are the painted base boards.

    Another view - the coat closet.

    I usually decide based on how the baseboards meet the floor. If they look good and there are no big gaps (not always caused by poor workmanship, BTW, sometimes the nature of the flooring causes irregular heights) I like to go without the shoe moulding.

  • 18 years ago

    I think both look good. We opt for the quarter round, but like said before, it's a personal preference thing.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you, thank you, thank you, for all the pictures and good advice! We've decided to skip the shoe molding. If we want to, we can always add it later.