Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardenwebber

Choosing a sink

18 years ago

From the beginning of our remodel, I thought I wanted a SS sink - drop-in style into our laminate countertop. I have always had SS sinks and so I am familiar with how they function and scared of the white sink.

Now I am second guessing and wondering if I should go with white?

From a looks standpoint, I am thinking white would go better with my appliances (they are white) but then again - I just had a friend who has replaced her white sink because it was impossible to keep clean (I saw it and it was quite grungy looking, and probably about 7 years old.) She replaced it with SS. I don't know what her sink was made out of it - but it was darn ugly when she ripped it out.

SS just seems like an old dependable stand-by. Any thoughts on this?

Our appliances are white, cabinets maple w/ mocha glaze, butterum granite tops and black hardware on the cabs.

Comments (17)

  • 18 years ago

    I just had my sink installed less than an hour ago. So I am not speaking from experience but rather education from gathering knowledge and experience from other TKO's.

    My problem was I absolutely hated my SS sink. I wasn't too fond of my laminate cabinets and had no problem selecting granite and a fabricator. But I labored over the sink decision. I looked at the Kohler Smart Divide and was intrigued by it's lowered divider enabling a double sink to act as one sink. But I didn't want the hassle of cleaning a porcelin sink that I knew would scratch easily.

    Luckily, the posters on this board guided me to the blanco silgranit sinks. Many of them posted pictures of their sinks and even though they were black, they intrigued me enough to go to a specialty plumbing shop and see the other color samples. I chose an off-white even though I have white appliances. The off-white looked better with the granite.

    I'm told the silgranit is colored through and through so in case of chipping it wont discolor like the Kohler sink. I cannot describe the texture of this sink, so I won't go there. Suffice it to say I petted it everyday it sat in it's box waiting for the install. The silgranits most definitely come in white. My plumber told me that most of the high end jobs he is doing is using this type of sink.

  • 18 years ago

    I just got a black (aka anthracite) silgranit sink (I believe my style is identical to previous poster's) and I love mine as well. Not sure about how easy it is to keep the white one looking clean, but I can tell you my black one is a dream.
    Good luck.

  • 18 years ago

    Today I read in dec mags that matching is passe, and even SS is beginning to get a bad rap for keeping clean (esp. refrigs)

    I had a SS put in 10 yrs ago. I've not been happy with ability to keep it clean like a nice white porecelin sink. Perhaps the precelin of old was just made better re finish and am starting to look at other materials. More and more I read people are getting the old sinks and having them refinished. Am redoing kit this Fall.

    It is a hard decision - change is hard, 'get used to it' urks me.....IMHO

  • 18 years ago

    I have a white double bowl porcelain sink that was installed around 1978. (Rest of kitchen is way older!) I was also trying to decide what kind of sink to get for the remodeled kitchen but was thinking I might want to keep the old sink --- even though it is a drop in, and even though it has a tiny chip and a few scratches. Am I crazy? Any one else thinking this way? (Sorry didn't mean to hijack the thread -- just fascinated with what treeskate said above)
    If I do replace it, it does look like the Silgranit is just lovely . . .

  • 18 years ago

    I, too, am finding this to be a surprisingly difficult decision. Currently have white "porcelain" and it is really not hard to keep clean. Looks great when it has been cleaned. Still, I was leaning toward stainless until found them to be more expensive, plus many complain about the water spots and general "dirtiness" or dinginess with them. I personally am not a fan of the siligranit sinks simply because they look like a dull, dirty laundry tub to me, but understand many here love them. I have indecision fatigue along with OP too and feel that a sink is low enough on my priority list of the thousands of decisions to make that who really cares? How much will I regret ss or fireclay, either way I go?

  • 18 years ago

    I didn't think the silgranit looked good in photos; I was glad I made a special trip to see one in person. It is hard to describe the texture of the sink. It is not shiny like an enameled sink, which I thought I wanted, but more like a smooth stone that is not polished. It feels incredible.

    Sayde, go for the new sink! After 30 years you deserve one! My silgranit is the first sink I've ever had the pleasure of choosing. I've always lived with someone elses decision. I love MINE. Tee hee, no one noticed that there's no faucet in my picture!

  • 18 years ago

    I have always had ss sinks til I moved into this house with a white sink. It was not a cheap sink, it was a big expensive white kohler sink, but it looked like crap every single day except for about 5 minutes after I cleaned it with softscrub with bleach. It AWLAYS looked dirty.

    I am so happy to have SS again!

  • 18 years ago

    I've had stainless steel and white cast iron in the past. I decided to get a white fireclay sink because I wanted the look of porcelin with easy upkeep. It's a fireclay Franke Orca, been installed for 9 months, gets very heavy use and I've never had to clean it with more then a damp sponge with liquid dish detergent. No staining or chipping or scratching. It doesn't show water spots. I do have grates so that may help. I love it.

  • 18 years ago

    I have never had a stainless sink I liked, but have had a few Kohler porcelain enamel over cast iron ones...Actually 5 or 6, since I currently have 3 of them...Main sink, prep sink, and laundry room sink. I've never had a stain Comet couldn't handle, and I didn't have any chips after having the one in our last house for 8 years. My beloved 20 yo dd washed out her French press yesterday in our prep sink...Leaving clods of used coffee grounds and a puddle of strong coffee sitting in the sink. (She does have a broken ankle, so dealing with such things is difficult on crutches...But I'm not sure I could say she would've handled it differently otherwise! My kids are not famous for their dedication to cleaning sinks...Berries, tea bags, and other things have been left overnight.) Anyway, because we were gone all day yesterday until late, and then busy this morning, I didn't find it or deal with the coffee mess until this afternoon. I just rinsed it out with water...Didn't even need to scrub with more than a soft rag. It looks as good as new.

    I just like the look of them, especially in a setting that calls for a self-rimming sink. I like the shiny, clean appearance, the nice, hefty edge, and to me they have a homey, old-fashioned feel that I'm comfortable with. I am thinking of replacing the dbl bowl with a single, and am sad I can't find any of the cast iron ones sized as nicely as a silgranite super single...so it may be my first try at one of those. I just hope it looks OK with the cast iron one on the island.

  • 18 years ago

    I decided to give my refrigerator a good cleaning and proceeded to fill up my kitchen sink. A phone call tore me away and 45 minutes later I came back to the kitchen, lo and behold the water is still warm and sudsy! This would not have happened with my old SS sink.

    Rhome, if you are a Kohler cast iron fan looking to go to a single bowl you might consider the Kohler Smart Divide. It's lowered center divider will let you use a small bowl when appropriate or you can fill both sinks and it will act as a large single. It is a self rimming sink.

  • 18 years ago

    Oh my... this is going to be another hard decision!

  • 18 years ago

    I have had a white Corian sink and cannot get it out of my kitchen fast enough; it has always looked dirty. Yes, we abuse it with red wine and coffee, but I think our well water has been the worst offender. If you have iron in your water, bleach will not remove the stain, and once the stain sets, it is near impossible to remove. We have a better water treatment system now, but still, I would never go with a white sink again.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks, neesie, but I really want a flat bottom. The main reason I want a single bowl is for soaking and scrubbing the 12 x 24" black underburner pans from my Wolf rangetop, Additionally, I could like a sink that my 15"+ cast iron skillet and dbl burner cast iron griddle/grill pan will sit in. They are so heavy and hard to hold onto at an angle. Thanks for the suggestion, though! It was thoughtful of you to try to help.

  • 18 years ago

    Many of the Kohler sinks come in different colors. I chose a biscut color as it goes better with my granite.

    I HATE stainless steel sinks. They are noisy, spot and look like a lab to me.

    I would have LOVED the silgranite. Couldn't afford one. I also wanted the Franke fire clay. Couldn't afford it either but that is the one I really, really wanted. They wear like iron.

    Sayde--you can always use your same sink if you wish. Someone can come and re-enamel it if necessary.

  • 18 years ago

    Well water is probably what dulled our previous SS sink. I can see that it is not going to be a problem with the Silgranit surface. Mustbnuts - my silgranit is in biscuit also to match the granite! I was worried about the price as well (but ended up getting it for around 325.00) but my husband said to get what I wanted. "When it's something you're going to use everyday, you should get what you want," is how he put it. After that I just kept researching. I guess there's something for everybody and if you know what characteristics you want you have to go out and look for it.

  • 18 years ago

    Neesie, can your husband please share his attitude with other DHs?

    GW'r, my old white Kohler tract house POS sink was low on my list of things I hated in my old kitchen. It did end up getting clean after enough elbow grease (unlike the faucet, fridge, oven, MW, DW, and cooktop). I just grew up with a big single bowl sink and didn't like the double bowl. I now have a single Shaw's sink without the minor detail of running water so can't comment on its long term prospects, sorry.

  • 18 years ago

    Ok, despite how these posts are going, not everyone hates stainless steel sinks. Try a search for Ticor, Franke or one of the other popular models and you will also find dozens and dozens of posts about people who chose SS and also LOVE their new sinks. By the way, my sister has a white solid surface sink and hates THAT, says she will never get a white sink again and SS is the way to go. I went with SS over white silgranit because of cleaning concerns, and its not that I think the maintenance would be hard, I just don't want to worry about it. The black silgranit are probably great, but it wouldn't go with my countertops. But people who have black sinks can't really tell you how white sinks fare, and others cooking and use may not mimic your own. If you want the least maintenance, in my opinion, go with black silgranit or SS. You will only have to wipe dry with a towel when you want it really spot free if you have hard water. If you don't mind cleaning your sink a little more or aren't a heavy, messy user of it, go with white if you like it better.

    I wish there were "samples" of silgranit colors you could get like granite. If I put a variety of sauces and juices and stuff on it and let it sit a overnight, then wiped it off with soap and a sponge without scrubbing, and it came clean nicely, I might have gone for the white or off white silgranit. I would have liked to take a piece and drop in a pot of old coffee for a day and see what happened. But that still doesn't tell you for sure how it will be after 2, 3 or 5 years of wear. I just know my bathroom sink is easy to clean but light colored and I now see staining around the drain from emptying the coffee pot, and other liquids down there. That is over about 9 months.

    Sue