Software
Houzz Logo Print
luvn2oxfrd_gw

Exterior help!

13 years ago

I posted over in the remodeling forum yesterday and it was suggested that I cross-post here for more ideas.

We are redoing the exterior front facade of our house. The existing stucco is failing and we are going with Hardie plank instead of stucco. While my materials decision was an easy one, I am terrible with color! I am a visual person and cannot picture what this is going to look like. On top of that, I have a list of concerns. Any help or suggestions is greatly appreciated:

One, the roof, fascia, gutters and downspouts are all brown. I am not changing any of that and need colors that will compliment the brown.

Two, the sides and back of the house are cream aluminum siding with brown trim. It is not in the budget to redo the entire house at this time. We will have to do it eventually, but I am holding off for the time being. Can I choose an entirely different color scheme for the front and ignore the back and sides for a few years, or would it be better to choose complimentary colors now?

My original thought was to do the Hardie plank in Mountain Sage with either a bright white trim or maybe something more creamy (Navajo beige or Sailcloth?) Keep the brown shutters and paint the front door a burnt orange. Then I got to worrying that it is too great of a departure from the cream and brown back and sides.

My second thought was to do the Hardie in Khaki with a Countrylane Red shutters and door. But, that is very predictable (lovely, nevertheless) and looks like every other home in the neighborhood.

If I chose to go neutral and complimentary to the back/side, I would still like some visual interest to the front. I am lamenting not having a gabled roof so that I can add in a third accent color, or a different texture like shingles. I am getting throw by the hipped roof. I don't want the house to look flat.

lol! Basically, I don't know what I am doing! and I don't want to screw up because it is very very expensive! Help!

Comments (23)

  • 13 years ago

    Are the windows paintable or will they remain bright white? They stand out, so if they aren't changing, you'll need to take that into account in your color scheme.

    To be honest, I don't think plank siding will do this house justice. The horizontal lines of the plank just don't seem right for the house style. Plus you have those pretty garage doors, and their lines wouldn't blend in well with horizontal planks. Stucco seems more suitable. If you really insist on plank siding, a wider size would look better than the narrow type.

    I like the house, even the hip roofs! Good proportions, looks solid & sheltering, pretty doorway, lamps & garage doors. The shutters look like real shutters, not the fake tacked-on things. Guess I feel that a narrow plank siding would be too fussy for this nice, simple home with good details.

  • 13 years ago

    Awm, we are not huge stucco fans and with the expensive of the current stucco failure, we've been burned and don't want to do stucco again.

    Any suggestions on what to use if not plank or stucco?

    To answer your question regarding the windows, they are not paintable. That is why I was originally going to use white trim...then I second guessed myself because the back and sides are cream! I am not really sure what direction to go with this house!

  • PRO
    13 years ago

    Do you have actual stucco or is it foamboard / Dryvit Stucco?

    Because I agree with awm03, 86ing the stucco on the front of your home will completely change the appearance of your home and perhaps cause your home to lose value.

  • PRO
    13 years ago

    Are these the Hardie Lap Saiding colors you can select from?

  • 13 years ago

    No, it is real Portland cement stucco :(

    lol. We wanted to change the appearance of the house because we don't like it. I am realizing I might have poor taste ;)

    What about keeping the stucco but adding stone wainscoting?

  • 13 years ago

    Yes, Beverly, exactly!

  • 13 years ago

    Luvn2oxford, sounds like you're in a dilemma: failing front facade that needs fixing now, and you can't afford to change the remaining siding. I wonder if the aluminum siding on the sides & stucco on the front was problematic in that there was moisture ingress which contributed to the stucco failure.

    I'm wary of just fixing the front, though. Is there no way you can do all the siding at once? You should address the issues that lead to the stucco failure before slapping on new siding -- make sure there isn't a moisture problem first. You'll be happier if all the siding is consistent, too, instead of a piecemeal job.

    I was looking at pictures of American Four Square homes: boxy 2-story houses with hip roofs (I love them). Your house lacks the big front porch and deep eaves, but still, your house is close enough in style. You can see in the link below that there's a variety of sidings used on these kinds of homes that look good. Maybe some of the pictures will give you an inspiration.

    Here is a link that might be useful: boxy house, hip roof, siding styles

  • 13 years ago

    thank you, awm. that helps. i was wondering what style my home was! boxy is a good description. you have me second guessing. the color scheme of brown and cream is not very inspiring, but i certainly don't want to do a detriment to the house with this repair.

  • 13 years ago

    You can paint aluminum. We just did, with Sherwin Williams Duration (Emerald was a flop and never cured). It just needs a REALLY good power washing to remove and chaulking. At least then the whole house could match, color wise.

  • 13 years ago

    oooo! eclectic! thank you. i had no idea!

  • 13 years ago

    No problem-we didn't either until a house down the street changed color without residing, then I looked into it!

  • 13 years ago

    Are you sure that portland cement stucco is More expensive than Hardie Plank? I don't think it is here. Stucco is the go-to secondary finish, however there is a lot of masonry construction here.

    Don't do anything like stone wainscot. It has every limited applications where it looks "right" and your house isn't really the right style.

  • 13 years ago

    I agree with the others above who think Hardie Plank siding is not right for your home. In fact, I think that visually it will be a disaster to put horizontal siding on your house unless you are prepared to change a whole lot of other features, too.

  • 13 years ago

    kswl, out of curiosity, what else would you change to make it look "right"? Would adding a porch help?

  • 13 years ago

    Have you considered vertical siding?

  • 13 years ago

    So stucco is it, huh? And we like stucco because it is not visually distracting from the lines of the home. Is that correct? So something like brick would not work because the mortar lines would be too chaotic, yes? And stone doesn't work?

    I trying to wrap my mind around this :). Stucco just seems so boring!

  • 13 years ago

    Ok, palimpsest, talk to me...why does vertical siding work?

  • 13 years ago

    Here are some very crude mock-ups (I need to learn drawing skills!), but you can at least get an idea of how they might look.

    #1

  • 13 years ago

    Verticals

  • 13 years ago

    Bicolor

    Once again, sorry these aren't more refined. Still, you can get a general impression.

  • 13 years ago

    awm03, the last one made me shudder, that would be a perfect example of what not to do to this house! ;-)

  • 13 years ago

    Ha! That bad, eh, chispa? Oh well...! I kinda like it, thought maybe banding and color blocks might break up some of the boxiness :) Just wanted to toss it in the idea hat, maybe it was better tossed in the computer recycle bin, lol!

  • 13 years ago

    Well, the visuals help! Thank you awm. So what should I do with the house? Is cream stucco the hands down favorite?