Software
Houzz Logo Print
thermsen_gw

Should I trust the paint guy?

16 years ago

I went to Home Depot yesterday to get some supplies to begin my HUGE painting project of painting my oak trim and cabinets. I was buying sandpaper sponges, TSP, tape, liquid sandpaper, etc. I decided to ask the man at the paint counter if I should use the liquid sandpaper or the regular sandpaper or both. He gave me his answer (liquid sandpaper is fine for spots that aren't damage but regular should be used for trim that needs some repairing due to chipping, etc.). Somehow we got on the subject of priming and painting and he said that if I use the Behr Ultra, I could go straight from cleaning and sanding to painting since the primer is in the paint. He said that it's best with light colors and semi-gloss finish. Too good to be true?

I've used the Behr Ultra before when painting a pale yellow deep red. I have to admit, the coverage was amazing - I remember reading on this forum that there is no such thing as paint and primer in one but when I painted with the Ultra red there was definitely a difference than when I used plain red paint to cover a light wall in another room. Without a tinted primer and using regular red paint, I think it's impossible to get a red that matches the paint swatch. The Behr Ultra did the job though in TWO coats.

Having said all of this, I never thought that the Ultra was good enough to use as a primer when painting cabinets or trim. I looked at the man like he was nuts and he swore it would do the job just as well as another primer (I was going to use Gripper which I've had great results with). He even said he is using it right now for his own house project painting his window sills.

So what do YOU think? Should I trust him? Would you? I know many of you wouldn't use Behr paint anyway but I love it. I love working with the consistency and have had great luck with it on my kitchen island (where I used the Gripper).

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    Okay, so I did some research online after posting this. It seems that every painter hates Behr. I haven't had any bad experiences with it but I do have knockdown texture which hides any lines there might be. I have painted with really thick paint, and I HATED it. Maybe I will stick with the traditional priming and painting. I really loved the Glidden Gripper for a primer even though I hate Glidden paint. You can't even try to chip the paint on my island cabinet. FYI- I did use Behr paint on my island!

  • 16 years ago

    The painter that painted my bedroom and bathroom said, he did NOT like Behr but used Valspar from Home Depoe, he loved it.

    I remember using Glidden years ago and I loved it. Go with what you know, so you have no regrets.

  • 16 years ago

    Here's the thing: You KNOW the cabinets are going to work if you go with primer and paint over it. It's highly questionable whether the Behr paint with primer will work. Your time is what's at stake here. Are you willing to take the risk of redoing the entire project, plus having to spend the time stripping, resanding, etc.?

  • 16 years ago

    I don't think Behr's good paint for this purpose, and I wonder why the guy wanted to dissuade you from buying MORE products. You silly girls.

  • 16 years ago

    I haven't used that paint yet but a few friends have and liked it.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm thinking that I will do what I know will work which is to prime and then paint. It's not a huge deal. It's the sanding that stinks! Thanks for the opinions!

  • 16 years ago

    I love working with thick paints, don't like Kelly Moore, have never used Benjamin Moore, but it looks interesting, most recently have used Velspar from Lowes and Behr from HD....sooooo based on my experience I go with what I like...which would be a Velspar or Behr. Doesn't mean I'm not open to other brands, I would just like to have a repeat positive experience.

    It sounds like you have had some specific experiences, so I suggest you go with what you feel comfortable with. I think vendor opinions are helpful for those people that don't have experience and need the advice.

  • 16 years ago

    One year ago, when the Behr paint and primer had just come to HD I used it to paint a bathroom cab in my basement. Cleaned, sanded lightly and painted two coats and got a great result! I have no problem with Behr and the painter who painted the basement walls and ceiling preferred Behr.