Software
Houzz Logo Print
eating_in

Marvin: Bad reputation?

18 years ago

I was doing some research on Marvin windows and found this long thread (in a music forum, no less) at Topix. Sounds like pretty scary stuff. Marvin seems to have a good rep here. What's going on? Should I still consider buying Marvin?

Here is a link that might be useful: Marvin windows thread

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    Marvin doesn't have a bad reputation and is a good overall quality window company.

    Name any product or manufacturer and I'm sure there will be someone who will have something bad to say about it. I've heard Gibson guitars really suck. :)

  • 18 years ago

    That's what I thought. I was just shocked to see 107 posts on how bad a company they are when I'd read here that they were one of the best. Apparently, there are Marvin reps on that thread admitting that Marvin made some bad windows during the late '80s-early '90s, but that was the fault of the coating manufacturers.

    Just wondering what others' experiences were.

    Don't know about Gibson guitars, though.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm kind of surprised to hear of that many people with problems. The one common theme I seemed to pick up on many of the posts was "We just discovered the windows were rotting". Wood takes a while to rot which indicates they were not performing the upkeep required with wood windows. Wood windows are not "install them and forget them".

    Also I'd take the rantings of a former Marvin Rep. with a grain of salt without knowing the circumstances of his termination.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi, we did the exact same research about 5 years ago and came across similar info. Skydawggy is a pro, I am not :-).

    A chemical that Marvin used to treat their wood failed to perform and there was widespread rot problems. Marvin customers brought class action against Marvin, Marvin sued the chemical company and everyone settled. I believe Marvin had a replacement program in place for all customers impacted by that problem. This all concluded way back before 2000's and likely before 90's.

    We bought aluminum clad, wood interior Marvin five years ago and have had no problems so far. Even though these are aluminum clad, we have inspected them twice in the past five years just to be sure there are no surprises. So far, no telltale signs of mildew, water damage, rot or insect damage. No splits or warps or cracks. Aluminum cladding has put up with some hail, some snow, mostly heavy wind driven rain, high wind, some impact by wind driven small gravels. No noticeable color loss (forest green) and no deformation caused by heat in our northern CA location.

    All but one type of hardware continue to operate as new. The one exception is the standard handles on the Ultimate French doors. Dealer recommended a custom heavy duty set but we went the cheap route and got standard Marvin handles. The hex screws somehow began to loosen and one set of handles fell off and another set became loose within the first 24 months. Sure, I can easily tighten and not complain but geeee, a simple hex screw coming loose? So far, no more problems after tightening.

    They may have done away with those cheap handles after five years but it is worth checking with your dealer just to be sure.

    Good luck!

    Good luck with your research!

  • 18 years ago

    Consumer Reports offered a window comparison in the October 2007 magazine issue. Marvin windows rated the best of all clad wood windows tested (about 5-10 different manufacturers). Granted, Consumer Reports should not be the end-all comparative entity, so one should provide their own educated research.

    As with many product manufacturers, sometimes their vendors may provide a faulty component. Such was the case with Firestone tires on Ford vehicles in resent past, and also the case with Marvin's glass vendor and wood preservative supplier. As long as the manufacturer addresses the problem and takes corrective action, including compensation for existing/previous customers, then they should not be poorly judged.