Software
Houzz Logo Print
wapiti7

Help me buy windows

20 years ago

We are going to build next year and are trying to decide on windows. The choice is between Pella(@ Lowes) or Anderson at a local building supplier. On either window, we'll probably go one step down from their high end. Please feel free to comment.........wapiti7

Comments (7)

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The construction of their windows are somewhat similar. they both use the block and tackle balance system with similar wood interiors. The big difference is the exteriors. The Pella window comes with an aluminum clad exterior and the Andersen window comes with a vinyl clad exterior. You can get the Pella in a large assortment of colors and the Andersen doesn't have that many selections with out painting. Personally I would take the Pella over the Andersen any day of the week. JMO though, if you have the option of getting the Pella Impervia fiberglass unit, and it fits your criteria, jump all over it. It would be a great choice for any new home. It's much more energy efficient than the other choices and much more resilient! Hope this helped in some way, Good Luck!!!

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Be careful on the energy advice. The Impervia has a U-value of .33 for a whole unit rating with lowE glass, and the other Pella and Andersen offerings are in the .30 to .34 range, depending on the glass and grille selection. So the difference in energy efficiency is very minimal.
    Also, when going a step down from the high end product lines, your color choices are very limited. Custom colors in the top of the line add significant cost as well.
    Pella's most efficient product is the triple pane Designer Series, but their cost is a drawback for many folks.
    Check out both lines, and try to narrow down your selections. Pick a color, and see which options are a "must have". If one can provide what you want for a better price, it's a clear choice.
    I would caution you on the use of the big box retailer. While their price is always attractive, their level of service and product knowledge are not. Make sure your quotes and orders are accurate before signing off on anything, and insist on clarification for anything that you don't see or understand.
    Good luck.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The big box stores are not a bad place to get your windows at. I know there are horror stories circling the internet, but you must take into consideration the jobs they roll through their stores verses the independents. I can tell you right now it's 3 - 4 times more than any independent supplier. When you roll that kind of volume there's bound to be issues. The independents have just as many headaches, you just never here about them. Being in the door and window trade for 32 years has opened my eyes to many things. My company has installed windows for almost every window supplier in our area at one time or another. I can tell you first hand they all have the same problems. The big box stores just have it at a much bigger scale than the little guys.

    My company has been installing for Lowes since they opened their first store here two years ago. I can tell you right now that they have a good program & good installers. The only problem I see with them in any way is the sales staff has to many turn overs. The big box stores aren't much for having a carrier job in the Millwork Department. Most of the aggressive people move up the ladder and on to management in another area. Ounce they get the right sales staff in and settled the issues fade away.

    Lowes has done one thing the others never let us do, sell the product. Since we have to go out and measure the product we have the chance to sit with the customer and answer the questions they might not have gotten answered at the store. We can then make them feel more comfortable and educated in the process and product. This has increased the sales and cured most of the problems that occur. This way has made a dramatic increase in the sales of doors & windows.

    Their biggest downfall is getting that customer the independents wouldn't even think of selling to. The customer that wants hay spun into gold. No matter how well the job is done, they want their money back. I've seen jobs that were perfect with out incident and the customer wants their money back because their cat was traumatized from the hammering of nails, and I'm not making this up in any way. I could write a book on the reasons people want their money back and get it because the store finds it cheaper than going to litigation. It's the saddest thing I've ever seen!

    I know that Lowes stores or any of the other big box stores across our Nation don't have the same things we have here. I think it's very important to make sure your getting what you want and it's done the way you expect it to be. If you take into consideration that the big box stores have many more jobs than the independents. The percentage of satisfied customers is enormous than those that are unhappy. You never see people coming on line and posting about their great job done by them. You only hear about the disgruntled home owner and what happened to them. It happens to the independents the same way. Problems occur straight across the board. It's just how well they are satisfied that makes a difference. Take the time to educate yourself and don't drop your guard. In the long run the big box stores will back their products and installation a lot more than any of the others.

    As for being analyzed by Mike, I just answered the question and compared the two companies. If it were my choice I'd pick neither one of them. I'd get the Eagle window that Andersen just bought recently. The Eagle window sits at the top of the pack as far as I'm concerned.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Marvin Has 11,00 Stock sizes for any phase of construction not to mention the cost effective Integrity line. Both Made with Hight quality materials that are not in direct contact with the wood window frame to prevent rot. Go for Marvin It will last longer and be more cost effective in the long run

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's that high turnover rate that hurts the big boxes. And the very reason I issued the caution. I'd feel much more comfortable with someone that has experience. If I was dealing with a 32 year veteran installer, I'd have no problem dealing with that retailer. But you are a rare breed for this region, guy.
    mlloyd, can you just stick the Marvin logo next to your name? Every post from you sounds like a commercial. I also saw one of your posts with the email address mlloyd@marvin.com. I don't mind factory reps offering advise, but keep it impartial.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The Big Box store Pella windows are supposedly not exactly the same as the ones you buy from a Pella dealer or a Pella store (which is not to say they aren't great windows either way). I was told Pella makes them special for the Big Box stores and "takes cost out" of the product so they can sell them to the Big Box cheaper and then to you cheaper. But......that is not to say they're still not very good windows.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The Pella windows you can purchase at Lowe's are the same as the window you would purchase from a Pella dealer. The pricing for their stocked windows is awfully good. If you have to order something custom or from a line that they don't normally stock, you will pay more for it. Same proline or architect series window. Entry doors are different in several subtle ways.