Software
Houzz Logo Print
enduring

What Backsplash Options Work Best?

15 years ago

Hi there, I am planning on installing my backsplash tile soon and I would welcome critiques of the options I have listed below. The sizes represented are not necessarily the size I will use. I have not planned on anything larger than a typical 3x6 subway tile, but I am open to suggestions/ideas.

I have included one view of my nearly completed, very small, kitchen to help describe the space and style. The cabinets are cherry with a very light stain and a "coffee" glaze that hangs up in the nooks and crannies. The counter tops are soapstone, black when oiled with whitish veins. At least one vein has a strong camel color similar to the cabinets.

My New Kitchen, 7'x12' with 4 doorways! Not a lot of wall space left.

Option 1, Lansdale Carrara marble from The Tile Shop. Creamy with golds. No veining, slight mottling.

Option 2, Glass clear white subway tile.

Option 3, Cream or off white cracked glaze shiny ceramic tile. Rather large for my purposes I believe. I like this color and texture, very nice.

Option 4, Standard sized subway tile, matte off white, from The Tile Shop. I like this one too.

Option 5, Glossy off white ceramic tile. Not bad but I like others better.

Option 6, San Dona marble from The Tile Shop. They didn't have the smaller subway tile in stock so I tried this large tile for color. It is kind of nice. May be too white.

Comments (12)

  • 15 years ago

    It's hard to tell options 3-6 apart from each other besides the sizes. Without being able to see the textures and finishes, I like 4. 3 is nice too.

    Are you going to tile up to the uppers? And the entire wall behind the range?

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for your input Breezygirl. You're up late!

    I will tile the entire back wall below the upper cabinets. Eventually a small SS23ew2 Vent-a-Hood will go above the stove. The hood will be 6" deep in front but it slopes to 9" deep in the back. I believe it is so the hood can house the full sized fan that is used on the larger hoods. I plan on putting the hood over the tile.

    3-5 options are really the same off white color but #3 is crackle glazed, #4 a matte, and #5 is shiny. Option 6 is a white crystally marble that has a bit of dingy gray cast to it. Option 4 is a favorite of mine. 3 is lovely but it only comes in the 4x8 size and I don't know, it may look odd.

    My door casing will be reused and painted the same color as the walls, BM Titanium, a very light greenish gray.

  • 15 years ago

    Hi again. I'm west coast, plus I'm a night owl. ;)

    I meant to add earlier that your kitchen thus far looks lovely. A room that size with all those doors must be a challenge. The soapstone swirls near the range are outstanding! I like the marble subways in option 1, but I feel they distract from that ss that should take center stage.

    The textures and finishes aren't reading on your pics from the distance and angle of the camera. I can't wait to see more pics when it's all done!

  • 15 years ago

    All the whites look fine but I can't really discern between them online. I do like the glass because... well... I like glass plus I think the glass will play nicely off the color of the walls.

  • 15 years ago

    I like like the classic look of #4 in your kitchen best. 3" x 6" subway tile is going to look classic for a long time. I also like #3. I love your soapstone!

  • 15 years ago

    I also like 3 and 4. I definitely would not go with 2. That's my two cents.

  • 15 years ago

    I love your ss! I like #3 best but #4 runs a close second. I can't tell from the pics but what color is your wall?

  • 15 years ago

    Hi, thanks for your feedback. I have added a few more pictures of option #s 2, 3, & 4.

    Option 2

    option 3

    option 4

    Breezygirl, I too like the marble but I don't want to make it too busy. I was hoping that there might be support for that little mosaic, but this input really helps.

    Remodelfla, I love the look of the frosted glass example I have, it almost perfectly matches my wall color which is very light greenish gray. I am thinking that it is too contemporary, but I could be just holding back!

    Francoise47, I am striving for timelessness in this kitchen. This remodel has been a long time coming and will be a long time til the next. Option #4 is a favorite of mine because of the subtle style.

    And MrsHanson I really appreciate your take on #2, can you tell me more about why you would not go with #2?

    CeltinNE thanks for your comment, the soapstone is something I have wanted for 10 years ever since I first saw it in a nice causal restaurant in Ames, Iowa. I recently asked one of the owners how it has held up. He is very happy with it. He would not use it in the restroom lavatory sinks again, they have streaked. Theirs was out of a Vermont company and it is soft. They have it installed in the restrooms as sink and counter, at the bar counter and behind the bar, and at the coffee bar area both the customer bar and behind the bar. They keep it oiled. Oh, and the color of my paint is BenMoore "Titanium" a very light gray green. Looks great in my north facing room.

  • 15 years ago

    1 or 4 would be my vote. I love glass tile (!) but don't know if it would be my first choice in your kitchen (though it would certainly look fine there--I just like the other two choices you showed better).

  • 15 years ago

    I have to say I like #1 the best. IMO, I don't think there's so much going on that it distracts from the counters and I like just the touch of gold color and I think it will give you that timeless quality you're looking for. If you don't go with the marble, I think a matte finish would be better than shiny.

  • 15 years ago

    Hi, thanks for your feedback. I have added a few more pictures of option #s 2, 3, & 4.

    Option 2

    option 3

    option 4

    Breezygirl, I too like the marble but I don't want to make it too busy. I was hoping that there might be support for that little mosaic, but this input really helps.

    Remodelfla, I love the look of the frosted glass example I have, it almost perfectly matches my wall color which is very light greenish gray. I am thinking that it is too contemporary, but I could be just holding back!

    Francoise47, I am striving for timelessness in this kitchen. This remodel has been a long time coming and will be a long time til the next. Option #4 is a favorite of mine because of the subtle style.

    And MrsHanson I really appreciate your take on #2, can you tell me more about why you would not go with #2?

    CeltinNE thanks for your comment, the soapstone is something I have wanted for 10 years ever since I first saw it in a nice causal restaurant in Ames, Iowa. I recently asked one of the owners how it has held up. He is very happy with it. He would not use it in the restroom lavatory sinks again, they have streaked. Theirs was out of a Vermont company and it is soft. They have it installed in the restrooms as sink and counter, at the bar counter and behind the bar, and at the coffee bar area both the customer bar and behind the bar. They keep it oiled. Oh, and the color of my paint is BenMoore "Titanium" a very light gray green. Looks great in my north facing room.

  • 15 years ago

    I don't know how that duplicate post got posted; by me? Sorry for that.

    cat_mom, I think I am with you either #1 or #4.

    drdannie, I like the natural stone quality of the marble. I think that if a ceramic or glass tile cracked on the wall it would drive me nuts, yet if the stone got a crack I would think,"thats ok, it looks natural"

    I have another area, about the same size as the stove wall, with the sink & DW. It will get BS too. I will tile the entire area under the wall cabinets. Old wood trim will be painted the same color as the walls.

    Sink wall