Have you thought about cork? GF used cork in her kitchen and it is wonderful, soft, warm and has a nice contrast with her cabinetry yet blends with her wood tones. It comes in a variety off colors and patterns.

Thanks Annie. I have considered cork, but I am concerned about getting a lot of water on the floor (my husband is a very careless and messy cleaner-upper), as well as dents and scratching from the counter stools. But maybe I should consider it. I really want something light to open up the space and contrast with the cabinets--we have a lot of wood.

GF took samples home and gave the the high heel test...stood on the samples in spike heels. She chose one that didn't dent. Back in the day home depot had Expo which was an upscale design store. One of their kitchen displays had cork flooring and it looked great and stood up well to store traffic. But test the samples first as quality does vary...like any product.

We chose amtico vinyl flooring and are very pleased...kitchen we did a stone look while the family room looks like rosewood. But it was very $$. Other vinyl products available now may perform and look as well for less money.

Here is a link that might be useful: Amtico wood looks