Software
Houzz Logo Print
jujybean

What would you do in this situation?

18 years ago

My dh and GC were finishing up the trim in the kitchen yesterday, and they noticed that the 42" uppers that we paid for were actually 40 1/2". Would you ask the custom cabinetry makers to refund the money or come back and take down the uppers and replace them with the correct size?

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    Are you happy with them otherwise? Will an 1 1/2" make a difference in storage to you? Are there any little extras (light rail, some molding, finishing touch) that you'd like but didn't do? I'd bring it to their attention and see if they could compensate you with some kind of perk. It seems a shame to take them out if you're otherwise pleased with what you have.

  • 18 years ago

    Neither at first. I'd check the elevation drawings to see what they indicate. Does the 42in include crown moulding or light rail? The cabinetry makers may have worked from the elevation drawings and allowed for these items in the cabinet box size.

    BTW, why didn't your DH and GC get out a tape measure before they started hanging cabinets?

    Personally, I'd leave them be and enjoy the extra space between the counter and the uppers. More options for coffee makers...

  • 18 years ago

    if you do as mooring suggests as far as checking, and you're not happy with them still, i'd have 42" boxes made. if you don't see the difference and reallydon't care....take a price break and move on :)

  • 18 years ago

    Unless you absolutely needed the extra 1.5" for storing some appliance, the extra hassle in changing a cabinet when you're already at the trim stage isn't worth it IMO. If it matters to you, ask for a freebie on an extra (which they're more likely to give you than a price break). Otherwise, don't sweat the small stuff.

  • 18 years ago

    The crown moulding will not match to the opposite wall if we keep them at present. The DH and GC will have to rehang them before we have counter placed on Wednesday. No we didn't measure the cabinets before hanging because why should we? We trusted the cabinet maker to give us what we paid for on our contract. The GC measured the distance based on what we should have gotten. When they tried to put up the crown(which is another story aside from this one) there was a large gap between the doors and the spacer which looked really odd. We thought they just didn't give us the right size. Its all because of 1 1/2 inches that wasn't there. My DH didn't realize the difference until he was putting up some side moulding on the cabinets to hide wall cupping. Whether we measured correctly or not there still is that 1 1/2 inch they screwed us out of. Either pay for my DH and GC to rehang them (they will have to take a full day off from work) or replace them with correct size and they install them at no charge to us for their screw up. I am sure the BBB would like to know about this. As I am itching to let them know.

  • 18 years ago

    If it were me, and I were satisfied with the cabinets they installed, I'd go to the shop owner and give THEM the choice-- either give me the cabinets I ordered, or give me some money back, both for the difference in price of the cabinets, as well as the time that's going to have to be spent reworking the trim and other finishes to make everything work. One way or another, I'd demand to be compensated.

    Most likely, they'll give you money back-- it's the cheapest way out for them.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm sorry. I didn't realize from your 1st post that it was a serious problem with matching crown molding and other cabs. It's not small stuff.

  • 18 years ago

    thanks Bill for your advice. That's probably what will happen, but who knows until they have talked to the owner and not his stupid brother or the sales agent(who is NOT to be blamed)

    Blue, I guess I should have stated in that in the first post. I love my cabinets and would hate to be without uppers for 5 weeks or however long it takes.

    This was the final straw for our GC with this Cabinet Maker.
    We still have not received one last door. They delivered 3 drawers a couple of weeks ago, but didn't bring the door at that time. I called in about it the next day. We think they hadn't even ordered it and did so only after I called. When the GC called on Thursday to find out when it would be available for pickup they told him early Friday. He called to make sure before driving over there and they said late Friday. He then called at 4:30 and they were gone.

    They just don't understand that messing with clients of a reputable GC will lose them business in the long run. And with my husband in an industry where is in homes that they have money to spend, he will not be referring them to this company, such a shame for the little guy who is messing up royally. (I didn't forget my bitter pill this morning)

    I JUST WANT MY KITCHEN TO BE FINISHED!