Software
Houzz Logo Print
msrose

Backsplash issues

13 years ago

I'm starting to have some questions about my backsplash installation, so I wanted to get your opinion on if it was done right or if they could have done things differently. The tiles don't go all the way up to the cabinets, so they filled in with grout. I'm sure it's not obvious to others that walk in my house, but I notice it.

The tiles are small and they couldn't have put another one, so is the way they handled it the best solution?

They also grouted the top of the tile here. I'm thinking I can probably paint the grout, so it blends with the wall.

You can also see some scratches on the tiles. I think it was really delicate and I don't know if it could have been done without scratching it. It had the paper on the front, so that had to remove it after the tile set and I don't know if it got scratched during that process or during the grouting. My mother said you don't really notice it unless you look up close and no one else will be doing that.

Comments (24)

  • 13 years ago

    Did the installer not own a wet saw? It's REALLY sloppy. Especially that section to the left on the last picture. I wouldn't consider it acceptable at all and would want it removed and replaced. Probably NOT by the same installer.

  • 13 years ago

    I agree with GreenDesigns - very sloppy job, totally unacceptable. I would also insist on it being removed and replaced, and as stated, by a different installer.

  • 13 years ago

    I am sorry you are not happy with the installation. And, I think there are things that could have been done better by a more skilled craftsperson. Your backsplash is beautiful and it looks lovely in the pictures you post(when you are not pointing out potential issues.)
    That said, you need to evaluate the specifics of your job, how you hired your tile person, etc....
    In my current house I have had two tiling jobs done. The first was my small mudroom. It had been damaged and needed a new subfloor installed. Contractor put in subfloor. Tiler used ditra, laid the tile. Room is all straight edges so curves. It is a stunning job and I paid a lot.
    When it came time to tile my kids' bath I went cheap. I hired a handyman to rip out the linoleum put in the new tile, I paid the same for the demo and tiling of a space that is more than twice the size of the mudroom. It shows. Where there were tile cuts that could have made things more finished I got spaces filled with grout. I am not pleased.
    I acknowledge it is my fault. I cheaped out and I got what I paid for.
    I am not saying this is what happened to you. I am saying you need to evaluate what you got in light of what you paid for. It is not a perfect job. Did you pay the price of a very skilled tile setter who should do a perfect job?

    This post was edited by localeater on Sun, Jun 30, 13 at 13:35

  • 13 years ago

    I have mini brick tiles and my tile guy cut them to fit a skinny row up at the top. Sorry if the pic is turned. I'm on mobile. Your grout works looks very sloppy. I would not be happy at all.

  • 13 years ago

    After all your hard work! That is terrible. And it was what, $32/sf tile? I don't know how these people can be so wreckless or sleep at night. Hope you can get it resolved without financial loss. Anyone who would do such a terrible job probably will not take ownership of the problems and reimburse the losses without some outside "assistance".

    Are the white lines we see on the gray tile examples of the scratches? He used a sanded grout on onyx?

    Good luck, so sorry to hear this project has gone sour.

  • 13 years ago

    Agree with others, very sloppy! And your tile should not have been scratched, that is horrible. Just had my tile put in and they were meticulous about being even and going with tile all the way to the top, it had to be cut, but they did it without a second thought. They obviously wanted to get in and out without taking any time to do it right. I would be so heartbroken.

  • 13 years ago

    Mrose, when you showed us your finished BS you were happy and everyone liked it.
    I remember that the your tile installer was reluctant to put these tiles in, and if I am remembering right it was this same person who did install them?
    When standing back and viewing your kitchen, is any of this noticeable or do you have to look under?
    In my kitchen we didn't paint the underside trim on the cabinets. When sitting at the kitchen table you see the light wood. I decided to live with it as it doesn't effect the overall look of the kitchen. And really, no one would notice it.
    Am I right to assume from seeing your photos that yours is not an eat in kitchen? So, unless you ducked under the cabinets, you would not see these mistakes.
    Yes, it could have been neater, but if you can't really notice it, unless you try really hard, then I would just accept it and move on as you are just reacting to this now, not when it was installed..

  • 13 years ago

    Is that viahara tile? It is so lovely. It is a shame that it was not done skillfully to maximize the exposure of the tiles.

  • 13 years ago

    I had a feeling this is what you guys would say and I know I should have dealt with it right away and certainly before I made the final payment, but I didn't. Just as a refresher on the situation, I found a tile guy and once I showed him the tile I wanted to use, he wouldn't return my phone calls. I found out the place that sells the tile would actually provide a contracter to install it. I thought that was great, because they would be experienced with this type of tile. I guess I will email some of my pictures and ask if there's anything we can do to make it better.

    Snookums - Yes, that's the scratches you're seeing on the gray tiles. It's actually a glass tile instead of onxy, but maybe they should have used the same type of grout you would use with onyx.

    ellendi - You probably can't see these things when you stand back. That's why I didn't know whether to complain or not. You're correct that it's not an eat in kitchen. I can see it when I'm sitting at my dining room table though.

  • 13 years ago

    What would be the alternative to sanded grout? Unsanded grout? I'm trying to put an email together to explain some of the issues.

  • 13 years ago

    I am so sorry for your problems. Unsanded grout should be used with glass tile. Also, I believe that silicone caulk should be used at the edges and in the corners. Hopefully he caulked between the tile and the countertop. If not, these are all no-nos. He certainly should have cut tile for the top row. Sloppy and lazy in my opinion. For a professional opinion, check out the John Bridge tile forum. There are tile guys there that can address all of your issues and give you some ideas on what should be done to correct them.

  • 13 years ago

    I agree. A tile "Pro" should have a wet saw and should have done a better job. I'm assuming you didn't go "cheap" and hire just some guy. We Tile Mechanics spend LOADS on training, tools, insurance, etc.....only to be blown away by some moron that doesn't know what end of a trowel to work with. I hope this was not the case with you. "Cheap" isn't cheap if you have to re-do a job.

    The above advice is good. Go to John Bridge dot com and we can further advise you. I'm there as well, but cant give you the URL as they seem to think that it's "spam" here....

  • 13 years ago

    I'd like to second StoneTech's recommendation to seek advice at John Bridge dot com. Several years ago I had a mystery leak in a shower-over-bath. The folks there were endlessly patient with me and helped me troubleshoot the problem. Later I had a bathroom floor tile job go horribly wrong and they were extremely helpful.

  • 13 years ago

    I feel for you. I am no expert and pretty new to this, so if I were in your shoes Id be doing the same...asking on here IF I had the right to be mad.

    I personally think I'd be more upset about the scratches on the tile itself, and I also think you'd have a better chance getting them to accept some responsibility for that. I guess they made 2 mistakes, but I think the thick grout isn't quite as unacceptable as scratching up the actual product.

    Remind them how expensive those delicate tiles were, and by all means if the place that sold you that beautiful expensive tile provided you with an installer, they really should've sent someone who knew how to protect the materials.

    Im sorry it happened, but on the bright side, it really looks beautiful regardless, and I am insanely jealous of your Taj Mahal. I got a quote for that today that nearly made me pass out. It wont be going in my kitchen, so enjoy yours!!

  • 13 years ago

    corgimum - Actually, he did grout between the backsplash and countertop. I didn't even think to ask ahead of time what he would use. I know from being on here that caulk is better, but I had grout before and when my mother got her granite countertops and backsplash a couple of years ago, they used grout. Why do you guys know about using calk, but the tilers don't?

    homebuyer23 - Well, that's one good thing about have a small kitchen. It made Taj Mahal doable :)

    I sent an email with pictures tonight, so I'll let you know what kind of response I get. Meantime, I'll check out John Bridge. Thanks, guys!

    This post was edited by msrose on Sun, Jun 30, 13 at 23:13

  • 13 years ago

    wow, if all those white scribbles are scratches on glass tile, that installer is in deep. You are due a complete replacement. By a competent tile man.

    This should not cost you one penny extra! It's really pathetic how we women are made to feel we are being too picky!! So old.

    Good luck, hope the tile store has some leverage. There's always Angie too if he doesn't step up to the plate.

  • 13 years ago

    I would definitely complain as you are doing. If they are a good company they will want a happy customer. You can always tell them you have several friends who have asked you to refer them to a good place for backsplash etc and now you are unsure what to say..... blah blah blah. They need to realize that business comes through referrals and if they do not have a good reputation it will hurt them in the end.

    So sorry about this guys lack of skill!

    Amy

  • 13 years ago

    I was told by the tile store that glass needs someone who is experienced installing it BUT they also recommended sanded grout because they felt the look was richer and that plain grout would cheapen it. We used sanded grout and have no scratches. Our glass is iridescent and textured. And initially it looked like there were scratches, but it was merely some fine film left in the textured areas.
    I think your tile looks beautiful from a distance. I don't think anyone would walk into your kitchen and see what you see on a daily basis. It is so hard when we put our heart and soul into a kitchen only to have little defects that we are the ones to notice everyday. Good luck, I hope it works out to your satisfaction.

  • 13 years ago

    Hopefully you receive help from the store - you have more leverage dealing with the store than just a tile contractor. If you paid with a credit card at the store, I would get them involved if the store is not helpful.

    The tile is absolutely gorgeous. I think it should be fixed at the top - you will always be unsatisfied if it's not, and definitely for resale.

  • 13 years ago

    "Why do you guys know about using calk, but the tilers don't?"

    This is the even more amazing thing about so many of the inept things that go on.

    With the caulking, they like to grout because -- the job is done. Otherwise, they have to come back on another day to do the caulking.

  • 13 years ago

    I would definitely have the thick grouted area replaced with properly cut tile. That's just unacceptable and lazy.

    As for the scratches, I didn't focus on them at first, but once you brought it to our attention, they stand out and I can't unsee them. Question for you: If the tile had come new, complete with scratches, would you have selected it anyway? You need to remind yourself that the original tile has been damaged and you paid for undamaged tile.

    My tiler was one of several recommended by my tile shop, separate entities. If yours is affiliated with the shop, then I'd think you'd have leverage to get it fixed, up to and including having the whole thing torn out and replaced to your satisfaction at no extra cost.

  • 13 years ago

    Is this the way it's supposed to look, i.e. the grout has been wiped off the tiles? To me it looks like there's still grout on the tiles. If not, and these are the scratches, I most definitely would not accept this. Ditto with not cutting the top row. Also, doesn't the top row of tiles usually have a different edge?

  • 13 years ago

    I agree with nosoccermom. It looks like there is still grout in the scratches, further emphasizing them. Can you test in a less obvious space and see if you can dig out grout from a scratch?

    Where in the kitchen is the area where there are no cabinets above the tile (white scratch on wall)?

  • 13 years ago

    I wish it was grout on the tile, but it's definitely scratches.

    This is a distant shot of the area I posted above. There is a similar area on the other side of the sink.