Software
Houzz Logo Print
erin_1776

Semi-custom insets - experience?

13 years ago

I'm considering inset door cabinets from both Decora and the Omega Dynasty line. I know inset cabinets can be a bit more cantankerous than overlays and I also know that because these lines are semi-custom and not full custom that there will be a seam present between adjacent face frames. Does anyone out there have semi-custom inset door cabinets who either hates or isn't bothered by the seams? Or can anyone speak directly to their experience with Dynasty or Decora insets specifically?

Thanks for all the help - both with this question and every other question I've had answered by pouring over this forum. The level of information is astounding!

Comments (4)

  • 13 years ago

    Don't know either of those brands. I have semi-custom from Plain & Fancy with inset doors. I combined shaker style doors with slab front cabinets for a slightly country look. Very happy with the inset. I don't care for the hinges showing. No issues whatsoever otherwise and mine are aging well. They are painted and that is holding up well, too. I saw an installation in advance so knew what I was going for.

    Good luck with yours.

  • 13 years ago

    Eliminating the seam in any manufacturred cabinets is done with a "modification". Many semi custom brands will do that modification, it does not need be a custom brand. The cost varies quite a bit from brand to brand but is not exhorbitant.
    One of my custom brands does not charge at all for combinations, my least expensive semi brand only charges a small fee once, my mid range charge 10% per cabinet

    The typical size limit is 96" in either direction. Custom will often do larger (did one base at 141" many talls at 104 hi). Semi will not combine around a corner, some custom will.

    Honestly I would not combine a semi past the limit. Semi will most often have pocket hole construction (as will most small local custom shops). It is fine up to a point. The size limit is not often an issue since it has to be a pretty big kitchen to need larger-and you have to get them in the house. The trick is to balaance the wiide stiles that you end up with.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for the input jakuvall - I'll definitely ask the sales guys about the possibility of this modification. I haven't gotten a P&F quote because I was afraid that it'd be out of our budget range. But that said, I was sure that the Dynasty inset would also blow the budget and yet even with the quarter sawn and inset up charge, it came in 5K less than the Kraftmaid quote which was for a full overlay door (go figure). I'll go have a look at the Plain & Fancy cabinets next week.

  • 13 years ago

    I just finished a Dynasty and Omega display in my new showroom. We had some contractor issues with the wall construction in the center of the U being 9" shorter than the plan indicated, or I would have done some combining cabinets in the display to show that it can be done. As it was, we ended up doing several Omega custom sizes in order to have the run actually work.

    However, if you have a good installer, you really cannot see the seams between the cabinets all that well. This isn't the best photo illustration, but you can see that we were waiting on a custom 17 3/8" cabinet for the cabinet to the left of the sink (contractor issue referenced above) and then you can see that run after. In an in person close up, the seam is barely visible.

    It's the same for the corner to the right of the sink. We had to replace that cabinet with a smaller cabinet for hardware clearance issues. In person, that cabinet looks as though it has an extended stile, not that it was an after the fact attached filler. My guy does a tiny bit of the touch up stick between the cabinet and filler before he tightens the attachment between the two. You can't even tell there's a seam there. Time will tell, but in the 4 months since it was done, and with the season change from winter through spring and now into summer, it's as perfect as when he originally did it.





    I did just come back from Waterloo, Iowa, and visiting Omega and it was a very interesting trip to see the custom area and the production line. They didn't seem to have any employees who had been there less than 10 years. And they were all very proud of producing a high quality product with 99% passing the final second quality control inspection. I'll be uploading some pics from my trip and do a post later this weekend, but right now, I'm trying to shake off a 15 hour travel day.