Software
Houzz Logo Print
remodelfla

Do you like this light for over my table?

17 years ago

I'm starting a new thread so people can chime in without having to read my "out loud thinking" as I went round and round on the other thread. We both really like the Clemson double pendant from Restortion Hardware. For some reason I cannot imbed a pic on DH's computer.

table:

{{!gwi}}

layout:



bakers table:



couches in family room:

{{!gwi}}

bar stools:

{{!gwi}}

I was thinking 2(?) 8" pendants over the overhang. And again, about 3 feet back from the oven either a solartube or I can use a semi flush in the same light? I don't know the typical spacing design wise for pendants. How much space between? I want them over the 8' overhang. The ones on the double Clemson pendant are 14" each and the fixture is 36" across. Sorry I can't imbed the pic to show you.

Comments (18)

  • 17 years ago

  • 17 years ago

    WOO-HOO!! So... HONESTLY... what do you think?

  • 17 years ago

    erika... we cross posted! Things are taking so long on this PC. Thank you do for doing that for me. Well... what's your thought? You can't leave me with a pic and no comment telling me what you think. YOu read through my long thought process that led me to this light.

    As an aside, the Hickory Hardware cup pulls I bought are brushed nickel. If I get this light, should I exchange them for the polished nickel? Brushed nickel hardware woudl go elsewhere.

  • 17 years ago

    Honestly? It looks kind of surgical to me, not as soft and friendly as your baker's table and stools. Plus, it looks like it belongs over a rectangular table, not a round table like yours.

    I didn't read the other thread, so maybe you have come to this contender after eliminating many other choices.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with morton. Does it come in a larger single bowl version? That would be better, but everything else you've done is warmer-- tropical, really, except the bakers table which is such a fun, one of a kind piece to juxtapose. I think I'd like something in pewter or orb. I don't think you need to match it to your pulls. BTW, everything looks awesome and looks really comfy and welcoming.

  • 17 years ago

    I keep losing messages so I hope this doesn't post 2x. I was saying... that I apprecite the straightforward input from morton. It helps send me in a new (hopefully right) direction.

    Here's why these work for me:
    I love the ribbed glass
    Shape of globe is soft yet modern
    Has a lightness to it so not too heavy
    I think it may look kinda cool to mix polished and brushed finishes.
    Unobtrusive
    Little Sparkly!
    Please tell me what you think of these or any others you know of that take all the things I like about this one in mind.

  • 17 years ago

    Not sure...What do you mean by unobtrusive? What brushed finishes are you mixing with it? I also don't think of this as the best shape for a round table. I don't see it as surgical, though, and, IMO, the shape and the traditional type of look will go with the bakers table. What I'm not sure it will go with is the rest....

    But if you both love it, does it matter what we think?

  • 17 years ago

    I agree that if you love it, and your husband likes it, that's the most important thing, but I don't think it goes well with your other things, and also agree that it's the wrong shape. What went really really well was the drum shaded pendant you showed us first. Certainly some kind of round.

    Can you get your DH to tell you what he doesn't like about it? Would he like a different color? Or is it the shade he really dislikes? Does it remind him of something from childhood that he didn't like? Or someone?

    This is something I fully intended to use in my kitchen, but couldn't figure out how to get it in. It's made of capiz shells:

    Here's something really funky in a similar shape:

  • 17 years ago

    Ack how to say this nicely...LOVE LOVE LOVE the fixture....HATE HATE HATE it over a table (it screams island or direct kitchen lighting to me). It's beautiful, but lacks the softness you should have over a table and it's down lighting so you look up into the bulbs which is never nice.

    Gad ok so I said it. Love the light...really...I'd love to see it over that fabulous bakers table frankly, but not over a table.

  • 17 years ago

    Igloo said it perfectly. I couldn't think how to express my thoughts on this because I think you have great taste ( and I especially love the flooring you have in another thread- the wood look porcelain... the bakers table, the bar stools, the whole mixture you have got going there...) and I do think the light is quite attractive but I really don't think it "goes" over the table. Scale wise and shape wise. As an aside, I might be the only person left who cringes at drum pendants and that whole retro 50's vibe that seems so popular. Maybe it's because it is actually retro for me and not new and fresh?
    But again, what rhome410 said as well I guess is spot on - if you love it who cares what we think?)

  • 17 years ago

    Hmmm....I am not sure I like it. Maybe it's too flashy to mesh with your other things? Not sure what it is. I do like the shape of the globes and might even like it in a different finish, but it looks a little too commercial for your space.

    Boy I sure do love what you have done with that baker's table though.

  • 17 years ago

    OH Man... I"m so grateful you all told me this. Lighting is the one thing I really have no sense about. I never changed the fixture that came in my dining room over that table now. You should see it... it's lucite and chrome ceiling fan.... DISGUSTING! It's not that I loved it... it's just something I liked that he liked too. I saw some pendants with the capiz shells but thought it might be too funky! Now I'll rethink it.

    I think by unobtrusive I meant that it doesn't have curly arms or extra pieces hanging from the arms. I think I"m more drawn to the straight clean lines without embellishments.

    Don't hesitate to offer more suggestions. I'm going back to the drawing board. What shape should I look for? I really need direction on this. If I get a multi-light hanging pendant is 3 lights OK? I seem to be drawn to 3 rather then four. Must be cause I'd odd too!

  • 17 years ago

    Elyse, You're right on track with three. It's a prime number and more pleasing for a grouping. But the main thing is to put either a single element over your table, or a group in the round (or triangle or square), rather than something long and narrow. Even if you have leaves and the table becomes long. Round/square goes fine over long, but long doesn't go well over a circle or square.

    JC

  • 17 years ago

    As the link says, not my usual taste but something very interesting about this one. I don't know size/scale just looking at shape/materials etc.

    Here is a link that might be useful: notmyusualtastebutinteresting?

  • 17 years ago

    Love the light, just not over a table.

  • 17 years ago

    I am the one who suggested RH, and I still love a lot of those styles with your stuff but I agree the light above looks like it goes over something long and rectangular.

    You didn't mention in this post that you are going modern in your kitchen-- that might help folks, too-- or not!

    Lighting is always tough..

    Take a look at Robert Abbey, too, he always has classy/classic lighting.

  • 17 years ago

    I'll chime in with an at-this-point useless post just saying I agree with various other posts - kind of surgical-looking, not warm, wrong shape for round table, doesn't fit with your other furnishings (which I love!). At least, IMO.

    Wow, I remember spending *hours* on various online lighting stores looking for just the right fixtures for my kitchen, bathroom, and foyer. Craziness. I found CSNLighting and LightingDirect to be the most organized sites to look through - a lot of overlap in their selection, but they each have some brands the other doesn't.

    People here had also sent me to Rejuvenation and Schoolhouse Electric, which both have some interesting fixtures.

    HTH.

  • 17 years ago

    can you tell me the code to imbed a picture so I can post some ideas...I'm having fun shopping lighting :o) DH said if I buy one more fixture he'll divorce me...but he didn't say I couldn't shop for others (perhaps the ten or twelve extra fixtures we found in the garage suprised him LOL)